Increasing numbers of overweight and obese children resulting from sedentary and abundant lifestyles are a health concern in Hong Kong and other affluent communities around the globe. The importance of physical activity is well documented for health and wellbeing, with sedentary behavior emerging as an independent risk factor for chronic diseases and mortality. In this study, Pender’s Health-Promotion Model informed the development of an intervention program aimed to engage junior high school students in increased physical activity, specifically brisk-walking. The model set out to motivate participants to engage in behaviors to enhance their health across the life span, including developing self-efficacy with regard to brisk walking. The intervention featured four stages. First, participants were provided with information about the benefits and in stage two were trained in the technique of brisk walking. Next they engaged in the brisk walking program and in stage four were encouraged to serve as health ambassadors by introducing brisk walking and its associated benefits to others, thereby exercising peer influence to diffuse the practice of brisk walking more widely among members of the community. Motivational strategies were used as incentives in the program, including the involvement of a popular singing band to award certificates at the completion of the program. This 7-week intervention program including a 4-week brisk walking component was conducted in a high school context with 71 participants. Data were collected to enable paired-sample t-tests to be conducted to statistically analyze the data at pre- and post-intervention. Findings indicate significant differences among the mean Body Mass Index (BMI), Waist-to-Hip Ratio (WHR), knowledge and attitudes of the participants at pre- and post-intervention. These findings suggest that the intervention was effective as a strategy to reduce sedentary behavior with the concomitant effect of positive shifts in measurable indicators and attitudes.
In recent years, being overweight or obese has been recognized as a major health concern and more latterly as an intractable problem worldwide [
Though genetic predisposition may be a contributing factor, a range of potentially compounding factors including: the lack of physical exercise; unhealthy eating habits; unbalanced diet; overloaded school curricular activities; sedentary behaviors such as prolonged internet surfing and television viewing; insufficient parental knowledge of health; or a combination of these factors may contribute to this serious health problem [
A recent meta-analysis of sedentary behavior and cancer in 43 studies involving 68,938 people provides strong epidemiological evidence that prolonged sitting increases the risk of certain types of cancers [
As overweight young children will more easily become obese and suffer from chronic diseases and psychological problems such as depression or low self-esteem in adulthood [
Brisk walking is a moderate-intensity physical activity that is a safe and simple aerobic exercise. It can be undertaken at any time and place and does not require access to specialist equipment or clothing. There are many benefits of brisk walking, ranging from physical to social and emotional gains. Dunton and Schneider [
Self-efficacy is defined by Bandura [
According to Hills & Byrne [
The purpose of this intervention was to encourage participation of junior high school students to proactively engage in regular physical activity. The brisk walking could be conducted in school or out-of-school. The impetus for the program was to encourage physical activity in order to manage body weight at a normal level and increase the level of interest in participation of physical activities. An additional aspiration of the project was to share this experience with others, thereby adding the potential of a ripple effect to achieve greater community awareness of the benefits of brisk walking.
In order to determine the effectiveness of the intervention, four key factors were identified as objective indicators of success, these being that each participant:
1) Spends a minimum 15 minutes taking part in brisk walking on weekdays either in school or at home;
2) Identifies at least two benefits of taking part in brisk walking;
3) Reduces body mass index (BMI) and waist-to-hip ratio (WHR) by 1%;
4) Introduces brisk walking and its associated benefits to five people.
These four elements will form the reporting framework for the project.
Pender’s Health-Promotion Model [
1) Individual characteristics and experiences (e.g. personal, biological, psychological, and social factors, and prior related behavior);
2) Behavior-specific cognitions and affect (e.g. benefits and barriers to action, self-efficacy, interpersonal influences from family, peers, providers and activity-related affect);
3) Commitment to a plan of action and responses to immediate competing preferences.
To put the Pender’s Health Promotion theory into practice, four activities were designed to facilitate the aims of the project by providing participants with essential knowledge: in relation to the issues of overweight, physical activities and brisk walking; to instill their positive attitudes towards taking physical activities and brisk walking; to develop their fundamental skills to taking physical activities and brisking walking; to cultivate parent influence and support on their interest in taking physical activities and brisk walking; and to enhance and reinforce their decisiveness to continuously take physical activities and brisk walking. The entire intervention program was conducted over a 7-week period, with Activity 1 and 2 held in the first week; Activity 3 conducted over 4 weeks; and Activity 4 held in week seven. Activity 3, Brisk Walking Health Practice, was originally designed to be conducted for at least three months to achieve greater intervention impact as supported by literature, but had to be cut short to one month due to the constraint imposed by the school administration.
Almost two decades ago Resnicow & Allensworth [
This introductory lecture session provided fundamental knowledge of health education about being overweight or obese to participants by health education academics. It included an educational lecture and videotape, and lasted for one hour. The lecture addressed personal, biological, psychological, and social factors, and prior related behavior in relation to overweight. The following five questions guided the content:
1) What is overweight and obesity?
2) What are the causes of overweight and obesity?
3) What are the health problems due to overweight and obesity?
4) How do you know you are overweight or obese?
5) What should we do to avoid becoming overweight or obese?
This was a second introductory session, in which fundamental knowledge of health education about physical activities and techniques for effective brisk walking was provided. It included a lecture, guest talk and videotape, and lasted for one hour. The lecture component addressed the following content:
1) What is physical activity?
2) What are the benefits of physical activity?
3) What kinds of physical activity suitable and convenient for the students?
4) How long and frequent should we participate in physical activity?
5) What is brisk walking?
6) What are the benefits of brisk walking?
7) When and how can we take part in brisk walking?
During the lecture, the licensed trainer demonstrated the techniques of brisk walking for the participants. A self-explanatory handbook was provided to participants in order to increase their understanding of the benefits of engaging in physical activities and to remove barriers to start doing physical activities by brisk walking.
After finishing the lecture and demonstration, the students were invited to participate in the 4-week Brisk Walking Health Practice. Those who were interested to participate in the program were required to sign a “Health Behavior Contract” to make a commitment to maintain engagement in physical activity by engaging in 30 minutes of brisk walking every day during the program.
The self-monitored brisk walking was a recurring activity as planned over a four week period. The participating students were self-monitored to undertake brisk walking in two 15-minute episodes at home and they were self-managed to record the date, time and duration of the activity in their personal log sheets, an example of which is provided in
When the 4-week Health Practice was completed, the students were requested to submit the personal log sheets to the HP committee and the total minutes taken and total number of days taken within 4 weeks, and average minutes taken a day of brisk walking were recorded.
Based on the total minutes taken during the 4-week brisk walking training, the participants were entitled to a certificate showing that they had completed the program and their level of commitment to the program, ranging from gold, to silver and bronze, which reflected the total minutes committed to the program. In addition, the certificate also stated the level of awards they achieved in accordance with the criteria set in
In addition to their participation in the brisk walking program, participants were encouraged to serve as ambassadors for advocating for increasing participation of family, friends and community members. They were also awarded certificates if they achieved these requirements respectively.
After the completion of the 4-week brisk-walking, a sharing of the progress of the program from planning to completion was conducted. The event lasted for one hour and participants and their parents were invited to attend an exhibition and ceremony where participation certificates and awards were issued to the participants. In the awards ceremony the singing band “C All Star” as “The Star of the Health Ambassador” of the program were invited to issue the certificates to each of the participating students. At this time participants and their parents were invited to complete an evaluation form with regard to the effectiveness of the program. The content of the evaluation form included participants’ satisfaction level and their comments on the activities with suggested improved courses of action.
This research was conducted in a government aided school located in North Point in Hong Kong. It is a co-edu- cational school catering students from secondary one to secondary seven. It is a secondary school affiliated to Hong Kong Baptist Church with 30 classes and approximately 1000 students. The school was selected because of the willingness of the school staff to engage in the study and hence forms the unique case study site.
Duration | Warm-up time | Brisk-walk time | Cool-down time | Total time |
---|---|---|---|---|
Week 1 | 1 | 5 - 7 | 1 | 7 - 9 |
Week 2 | 1 | 7 - 9 | 1 | 9 - 11 |
Week 3 | 2 | 9 - 11 | 2 | 13 - 15 |
Weeks 4 - 9 | 2 | 13 - 15 | 2 | 15 - 17 |
Level | Total min. | Total no. of day |
---|---|---|
Gold | >480 | >16 |
Silver | >420 | >14 |
Bronze | >360 | >12 |
Students of two secondary one classes were invited to participate in the program with consent being obtained from students, parents and the relevant school authority. Participants were aged between 12 and 14 years. Seventy-one of eighty students self-selected as participants in this study, following the information session. Of these participants, 33 were males and 38 females. The intervention program was mainly conducted during physical education lessons and the brisk walking component occurred most often after school.
All participating students completed pre- and post-test data collection for comparative purposes as to the level of involvement and effectiveness of the program. Four data sources were utilized in this study and utilized at pre and post test. These instruments, their administration protocols and purpose, are presented in
In addition to these comparative data, a focus group meeting was conducted to solicit participants’ views on the design of the intervention program.
Data were collected at two times in the program. The pre-intervention data were regarded as the baseline measurement and was collected in Activity 2 “Health Walk” before commencement of Activity 3 “Health Practice”, while the post-intervention data were regarded as the post measurement and was collected after completion of the last session of Activity 3 “Health Practice”. Descriptive statistics reporting mean and standard deviations of body mass index, waist to hip ration, knowledge about benefits of brisk walking and attitudes towards taking part in brisk walking were calculated using SPSS Version 21. Paired-sample t-test was conducted for each pair of pre-post outcome measurements with the level of significance was set at p < 0.05.
In this program, the 71 participants were junior secondary students in a secondary school recruited to join the brisk walking program. The mean age of the participants was 12 years 6 months (SD = 0.680; range = 12 - 15). As presented in
Data collection instrument | Administration | Evidence for indicator of success |
---|---|---|
Body mass index | BMI = Body weight in kilograms/(body height in meters)2 | Reduces body mass index (BMI) by 1 |
Waist to hip ratio | WHR = waist measurement (cm)/hip measurement (cm); in which the waist measurement was taken horizontally at the smaller circumference of the natural waist, just above the belly button while hip measurement was taken horizontally at the widest part of the buttocks. | Reduces waist to hip ratio (WHR) by 1% |
Knowledge questions | · 10 structured open-ended questions. · The numbers of correct answers were scored with one score given for each correct answer. | Identifies at least two benefits of taking part in brisk walking |
Attitude questions | · 5-point Likert Scale was used to measure the participants’ attitude towards taking part in brisk walking by asking the extent to which they agreed or disagreed with ten questions. · Five scales ranging from strongly agree to strongly disagree for participants to select. · At analysis stage the five scales were further condensed and scored accordingly as strongly agree or agree (value = 3), neutral (value = 2), strongly disagree or disagree (value = 1). | Identifies at least two benefits of taking part in brisk walking |
Participants (n = 71) | |||
---|---|---|---|
Pre | Post | t value | |
Mean height (cm) | 158.69 (7.401) | 158.94 (7.62) | 3.641* |
Mean weight (kg) | 51.55 (11.54) | 50.30 (11.39) | 7.397* |
Mean waist (cm) | 70.69 (10.00) | 64.82 (8.89) | 8.847* |
Mean hip (cm) | 86.93 (8.95) | 83.77 (7.70) | 4.368* |
BMI | 20.32 (3.38) | 19.76 (3.29) | 8.043* |
WHR | 0.82 (0.13) | 0.77 (0.06) | 2.866* |
Knowledge about benefit of brisk walking | 1.51 (0.73) | 4.59 (1.18) | 19.864* |
Attitudes towards taking part in brisk walking | 2.11 (0.64) | 1.94 (0.56) | 2.682* |
*means significant difference at p < 0.05.
between the mean score of the participants at pre (1.51 ± 0.73) and post intervention (4.59 ± 1.18). For attitudes towards taking part in brisk walking, there were significant difference (t(69) = 2.682, p < 0.05) between the mean score of the participants at pre (2.11 ± 0.64) and post intervention (1.94 ± 0.56).
The findings reveal that 76% (n = 54) of participants achieved the requirements for the respective level of award while approximate 80% (n = 57) of participants spent the desired minimum of 15 minutes to take part in brisk walking in weekdays either in school or at home. Furthermore, a total of 322 names of people were provided by the 71 participants with an average of 4 people recommended through the health ambassador process.
What this data means is that the participating students were able to identify at least two benefits of taking part in brisk walking and reduced BMI and WHR by more than 1%. Over 75% of participants would like to spend a minimum of 15 minutes taking part in brisk walking in weekdays either in school or at home, and were interested to introduce brisk walking and its associated benefits to at least four people.
In the focus group meeting, most of the participants reflected that they enjoyed brisk walking very much, revealing a successful design of the intervention program. Their mastery experience of reducing BMI and WHR within a short period of time had undoubtedly enhanced their self-efficacy to combat overweight with brisk walking daily. Brisk walking was identified as one of the useful ways to increase activity level as it could be conducted at anytime, anywhere and free of charge. Receiving awards from “C All Star” was highlighted as one of the most exciting incentives for their behavioral changes and a role model for observational learning. Peer influence was further identified as one of the effective ways to promote brisk walking.
As stated at the outset, in order to determine the effectiveness of the intervention, four key factors were identified as objective indicators of success, which are being that each participant: spends a minimum 15 minutes taking part in brisk walking on weekdays either in school or at home; identifies at least two benefits of taking part in brisk walking; reduces body mass index (BMI) and waist to hip ratio (WHR) by 1%; and introduces brisk walking and its associated benefits to five people. After completion of the program, the mean Body Mass Index of the participants was reduced by 2.75% and the mean Waist to Hip Ratio of the participants was reduced by 6.09%. With regard to knowledge about benefits of brisk walking and their attitudes towards taking part in brisk walking, the findings reflected that the educational content of the program could help the participating students explore and deepen the knowledge about brisk walking and its associated benefits, and enhance motivation to increase their level of interest in participation of brisk walking. The fourth of these indictors, introducing brisk walking and its associated benefits to 5 people, was not achieved, with instead an average of 4 people being engaged by participants.
From a theoretical perspective, Pender’s Health-Promotion Model as illustrated in
With respect to a focus on the development of self-efficacy—that is the confidence and competence to engage in the brisk walking program—the model featured all of the elements promoted by Bandura [
The significance of this program is in addressing the elements required for establishing a habit to commit to exercising among the junior secondary students. The example in this case was brisk walking, an easily-adopted exercise to get students moving from their typically sedentary lifestyles. Supported by a role model, this group was interested to commit to the intervention. The results showed the model was innovative and successfully motivated the students. For many exercise programs implemented in association with school settings, one difficulty could be the self-initiative in undertaking the exercise in their leisure time. This study demonstrates a possible solution may be found by engaging simple rewards for those achieving the set target and contributing to a sense of efficacy in undertaking the program. The findings differentiate this intervention program from other intervention programs by considering the role-model effect and the focus upon self-efficacy.
7-week duration of intervention was identified as the major limitation of this study. For a more sustainable development of participants’ physical activity habits to combat overweight, it is suggested to increase the duration of intervention and the hours of engaging in physical exercise each day. It is proposed to launch either a single six-month or two sessions of three-month training programs within one school-calendar year and 30 minutes or two sessions of 15-minute training session daily either in the morning session before class or after school. A very supportive school policy and collaborative teaching teams is also a useful recipe for a successful intervention program.
In addition, the participants were self-administrated to take part in brisk walking at home and submitted their self-reported record of personal log sheets. In order to increase the reliability, it is proposed that the participants should be supervised to take part in brisk walking in school and submit their records with endorsement of the supervisor.
Overall, the objectives of the intervention program were well attained which demonstrated that the brisk walking program was effective. Sustaining this program would no doubt assist in combatting the challenges associated with young adolescent rates of being overweight or obese, and of attending to the increased patterns of sedentary behavior featured in the contemporary society.
This study is important as it serves as a benchmark for comparison with future data sets in order to investigate the role of interventions and strategies to increase self-efficacy of participants in brisk walking programs, which in turn has the potential to reduce sedentary behaviors and enhance overall health and wellbeing. It is recommended that further studies conducted to investigate the program are a range of settings with regard to the development of sustainable practices.
The authors would like to thank Ms Chen Sik Wing, Law Tak Fai, Leung Yuen Ching and Mak Fung Mei for their contribution to the project.