Journal of Geoscience and Environment Protection, 2014, 2, 117-125
Published Online June 2014 in SciRes. http://www.scirp.org/journal/gep
http://dx.doi.org/10.4236/gep.2014.23016
How to cite this paper: Elsner, A. (2014). The Dominant Role of the Chemical Potential for Driving Currents in Oceans and
Air. Journal of Geoscience and Environment Protection, 2, 117-125. http://dx.doi.org/10.4236/gep.2014.23016
The Dominant Role of the Chemical
Potential for Driving Currents in
Oceans and Air
Albrecht Elsner
Am Mühlbach 14, D-85748 Garching, Germany
Email: alimeli.elsner@g mail.com
Received January 2014
Abstract
Applying the thermodynamic zeros of the entropy
S
and internal energy
U
of the gas mass
M
in the volume
V
yields the numerically unique relation between these quantities, thus allowing
calculation of the chemical potential in the gas fields of temperature
T
and pressure
p
, viz.
=MUST Vp
µ
−+
. A difference in chemical potential provides a force for freely moving matter flow.
Since
µ
is intrinsically a negative function, decreasing as the temperature increases, natural
flow processes are initiated by high
µ
values in cold regions directed to low
µ
values in warm
regions. Modeling the Gulf Stream circulation, calculations show that the force deduced from the
chemical potential for certain temperature differences in water outweighs all other forces acting
on this current. The chemical potential provides the force not only for flow of matter but also for
its changes of phase and for chemical reactions, and thus the chemical potential plays the domi-
nant role in modern theoretical oceanography and meteorology. As an example of a gigantic water
flow, the oceanic circulation of the Gulf Stream is investigated. The chemical potential is here in-
troduced for identifying the sources of the forces driving the Gulf Stream. There are two main en-
ergy supplies of the Atlantic warm water current: 1) the vertically upwards directed tempera-
ture-dependent chemical potential difference reduced by the gravitational hydrostatic energy in
the equatorial region, which generates forces that press cold deep seawater from the Atlantic into
the Gulf of Mexico, from where the then warm water current finds its pole wards flowing lane at
the surface of the North Atlantic, and 2) the vertically downwards directed chemical potential dif-
ference enlarged by the gravitational energy in the polar region, which generates forces that con-
tinue to transport the then cold surface water to seawater at great depths, from where deep sea-
water flows back to the Atlantic, thus closing the water circulation in the North Atlantic basin. In
general, momentum fluxes in oceans are caused by different seawater conditions at different oce-
anic locations. The cold water reservoirs at the poles and the warm surface water reservoirs at the
equator are the sources of oceanic circulations. Similarly, a cold low-pressure area is the origin of
extensive motions of rainy clouds.
Keywords
Chemical -Potential Temperatu re Fun ctio n , Thermo-Mechanical Pressure, Gravitational Press ure ,
Gulf Stream, Oceanography, Meteorology
A. Elsner
118
1. Introduction
What driving mechanisms are the basis of currents in the atmosphere and currents in oceans? The answers of a
meteorologist and an oceanographer concur: On our planet freely moving matter is essentially governed by the
forces of gravitation, rotation, friction and, especially in oceans, horizontal wind stress and thermohaline
convection. As the densities of air and water greatly differ, atmospheric currents move much faster than oeanic
currents. Besides forces, it is ultimately the conservation of mass, energy, momentum, angular momentum and
conditions prescribed by continental boundaries that determine the course of currents. The pertinent hydrody-
namic equations (Oertel Jr., 2002) are completed with thermodynamic equations (Apel, 1987), which inter-relate
parameters such as density, temperature, pressure, enthalpy, heat capacity, compressibility, conductivity etc. In
the case of seawater salinity also plays a role; here the thermodynamic relations are compiled in a so-called
International Equation of State for Seawater (EOS) (Apel, 1987; Businger, 1992). Evaluation of the Geophysical
Fluid Dynamics equations is done by means of powerful computer systems.
Results of these calculations are published in the media. The forecasting in weather reports on the temporal
development of air temperature, air pressure, wind intensity, wind direction, cloud formation and precipitation is
impressive because it readily predicts the actual weather situation accurately. There are also films of cyclones,
whose development can be explained (see Section 4). Impressive are likewise aerial photos of sea currents, e.g.
the Gulf Stream. The explanation that the cause of the currents is globally the transfer of horizontal wind
momentum to the ocean and thus represents the most energetic component of the oceanic circulation (Apel,
1987) raises, however, doubts. Can it be that it is just winds close to the air-sea interface, whose strength and
direction are continually subjected to change, that drive the narrow Gulf Stream band, 100 km wide and 7000
km long in the 6000 km wide North Atlantic, as sole prominent current? Furthermore, a wind-driven wave on
the ocean surface forces water masses to move up and down but does not transport them as a current in the
direction of the wave propagation. Nevertheless, oceaneographic science holds the view that wind exerts a
tangential force on the sea surface that induces a water current with a vertical so-called Ekman spiral.
Calculations of the Ekman solution are compared with observations, and differences are specified, viz. a shift of
the current by calculated 45˚ to the wind direction instead of measured 20˚ and a spiral depth of 15 cm instead of
a mean depth of the Gulf Stream of 500 m (Oertel Jr., 2002; A pel, 1987; von der Heydt, 2011). Wind shear is
ruled out as explanation for the cold deep-sea currents, which originate at the poles. On the other hand, a
physical explanation for their existence is lacking.
The cause of sea currents is obviously a freqently recurring question (von der Heydt, 2011). One must
therefore go back to the essential fundamental equations, viz. 1) the momentum equation with the driving force
as the sum of the gravitational force, Coriolis force, a frictional force of deceleration, wind stress (Oertel Jr.,
2002; Apel, 1987) and possibly a further, thermo-mechanical force of acceleration (see Sections 2 and 3) and 2)
the thermodynamic relations formulated by UNESCO (Apel, 1987). This makes study of a thermodynamic
textbook (e.g. Callen, 1960) inevitable.
Thermodynamics treats the physical theory of the reversible equilibrium states of a macroscopic system as
well as its irreversible processes (Callen, 1960). The theory emphasizes two facts: 1) A complete state
description of a thermodynamic system by the system parameters: temperature
T
, pressure
p
and chemical
potential
µ
and 2) the fact that a chemical-potential gradient generates a flow of matter. The circumstance that
this knowledge has not featured in the disciplines, oceanography and meteorology, is solely due to the fact that
the chemical potential cannot be calculated as long as the thermodynamic value of the internal energy of the
system as an absolute value is unknown. Numerical determination of the thermodynamic reference values of
entropy
S
and internal energy
U
, which are assigned to the system mass
M
in volume
V
, has
fundamentally changed the situation (Elsner, 2012). The absolute values of
M
,
V
,
S
,
,
T
and
p
make it possible to calculate the energy value of the chemical potential:
=MUST Vp
µ
−+
(1)
It is customary to calculate with mass-specific quantities, i.e. with
()/ =MM
µµ
,
/=UM u
,
/=SM s
,
/= =1/VM v
ρ
, where
ρ
is the density. For water as an example, Figure 1 presents
µ
as a function of
T
.
The general and essential properties of the chemical potential between absolute zero and the critical temperature
can be seen:
µ
is a continuous, negative, concavely curved, decreasing function of
T
. It thus holds that every
matter of freely moving particles flows from high
µ
values, i.e. from cold regions to low
µ
values, i.e. to
A. Elsner
119
Figure 1. Chemical potential of water between the absolute zero and critical
points. At the triple point,
µ
is continuous but the derivatives are discon-
tinuous where
li
/< /<0
iquid ce
d dTd dT
µµ
.
warm regions.
That a particle flow is due to interaction forces within the fluid is shown by the fact that within the fluid a
gradient of energy
M
µ
exerts a force on every fluid particle and acts as a force driving a current, this being
similar to the converse, where in a flowing fluid frictional forces occur between the particles and reduce the
kinetic energy of the fluid. The interactions between the particles are also responsible for the variation of the
particle motion when the fluid is subjected to an external mechanical pressure, which changes the
volume-pressure energy. The situation is different when the particle motion is subjected to gravitational forces
and Coriolis forces; here external forces act on every particle mass
m
, independently of its interaction with
other particles. The stated internally generated and externally imposed forces
F
, which set in motion the fluid,
i.e. the mass
=Mm
in the volume
V
, are treated as body forces
=/
f FM
(unit: dyne/g) or as volume
forces
=/
f FV
(unit: dyne/cm3). It holds that
= /=ffv f
ρ
.
The oceanic water circulation of the Gulf Stream represents a continuous system of gigantic extent. It is truly
impressive how pregnantly this was described by American naval officer M. F. Maury in his book entitled The
Physical Geography of the Sea(1 85 5): There is a river in the ocean. In the severest droughts it never fails, and
in the mightiest floods it never overflows. Its banks and its bottom are of cold water, while its current is of warm.
The Gulf of Mexico is its fountain, and its mouth is in the Arctic Seas. It is the Gulf Stream (Apel, 1987).
In Sections 5 and 6, Maurys assertions are thermodynamically confirmed by investigating the sources of
forces that drive and confine the warm water. In order to handle the problem of driving forces in different
oceanic regions, a highly simplified oceanic model is considered to be a basin composed of six different homo-
geneous volumes
n
V
of densities
/=
nn n
MV
ρ
under the local conditions
[, , ]
nnn
Tp
µ
. It is intended to com-
pare the two main energy sources, viz. the hydrostatic and thermo-mechanical pressures in each volume
n
V
.
Typical Gulf Stream data allow calculation and comparison of gravitational and thermo-mechanical energies at
different geographic locations (see Section 6).
2. Flow of Matter Due to a Chemical Potential Gradient
Thermodynamics says that in an inhomogeneous fluid there may also be, besides gravitational and mechanical
forces, thermo-mechanical forces which generate flow of matter within the fluid from regions of high chemical
potential to those of low potential.
Let us consider the mass flow between two volumes
1
V
and
2
V
in which water is retained under the con-
A. Elsner
120
ditions, {
1
()T
ρ
,
11 1
[ , ( ), ( )]T pTT
µ
} and {
2
()T
ρ
,
22 22
[,()() ,()]Tp TTgHT
ρµ
+
}, where
ρ
is the local density
(Apel, 1987),
T
the temperature,
p
the vapor pressure,
µ
the chemical potential,
g
the gravitational
acceleration,
H
the vertical distance between
1
V
and
2
V
, and
22
() ()pTTgH
ρ
+
the hydrostatic pressure in
2
V
. The flow depends not only on these external thermal conditions, but also on the local surroundings and the
viscosity of water. If the viscosity can be neglected, i.e. water flows without any friction loss, the flow is
governed by the balanced external conditions, viz. the differences between chemical-potential and hydrostatic
energies,
12112 2
[()(( )()]VTVT gH
µµ ρρ
−− −
, where the positive sign determines the flow direction, say, from
volume 1 to volume 2. Before calculating
12
()
µµ
, one has to consider the well-known Gibbs relation (with
=1/v
ρ
) (Callen, 1960),
= <0d dTvdpdTs
µ
(2 )
which describes the temperature gradient of the chemical potential, i.e.
/d dT
µ
as the difference between the
function
dTvdp/
and the entropy
s
. Figure 2 shows the temperature dependence of these functions for water.
Note that
dTd/
µ
does not depend on the water phase, since it holds that
fc v
[/ ]=[/ ]=[/ ]
luid ondensate apor
vdp dTsvdp dTsvdp dTs−− −
. Integration of Equation (2) yields (with
vvv ==
21
)
12
12 1212
21
()==()()> 0for<
TT
TT
ddTdTvpps TdTTT
µµ µ
− −+
∫∫
( 3)
Equation (3) once again states that
µ
decreases as
T
increases.
As regards pressures, Equation (2) is multiplied by
ρ
, yielding
/ <0
dp dTs
ρ
. One then obtains the pre-
ssure relation
22
21 12
11
=()=()> 0for<
TT
TT
PddTdTpps dTTT
µ
ρµ ρ
− −−+
∫∫
(4)
The thermo-mechanical pressure
2
1()
T
Ts dT
ρ
is also termed fountain pressure as discussed in the context of
the helium flow in HeII (Allen &Jones, 1938). The vapor pressure difference
2
21 1
()=( /)
T
T
ppdp dT dT
is
Figure 2. Functions of water between the triple and critical points. 1:
/ =/>0ddTsvdp dT
µ
−−
, 2: s, 3:
, 4:
l
s
, 5:
/vdp dT
, 6:
v
/v dpdT
,
and 7:
l
/v dpdT
. Subscript v: vapor phase, subscript l: condensate phase (li-
quid water, ice).
A. Elsner
121
directed counter to the thermo-mechanical pressure. The imbalance (4) gives the principal source of flow
dynamics within an inhomogeneous fluid. Relation
>0P
µ
thus imposes the condition for matter flow from
volume 1 with
1
T
to volume 2 with
2
T
if
12
<TT
. In the case of the Gulf Stream the lateral pressures
µ
P
are
directed from its cold surrounding to its warm center and confine it, including the large warm and cold core
rings that exist for weeks after their detachment from the meandering main stream (Apel, 1987). Vertical
pressures at the sources and sinks of the Gulf Stream maintain the current and its prescribed direction.
3. Equation of Momentum
According to statistical mechanics and in agreement with Newton, the change with respect to time
t
of the
quantity, motion of mass
M
, moving with velocity
u
, viz. the momentum
Mu
, is caused by the force
F
imposed on the moving mass
M
:
( )==ddt MudMdtuMdudtF+
(5)
In oceanography and meteorology it is convenient to consider the flow of the volume
V
containing
M
,
and, consequently, from Equation (5) one obtains
( /)=
d MV dtuMVdudtFV+
,
=d dtududtf
ρρ
+
, and
ρρ
fdudtdtud =)(ln +
or
ln( )=ddtu dudtf
ρ
+
(6)
Important forces
i
f
come from five sources: gravity, Coriolis effects, mechanical pressures, chemical-poten-
tial-dependent thermo-mechanical pressures and friction, where it holds that
=
i
ff
. Whereas the sea water
density in oceans is nearly constant, the density of air in the atmosphere rapidly varies. Thus the term
u
dt
d
)/(
ln
ρ
in the hydrodynamic Equation (6) can be dropped when treating seawater, but must be regarded
when treating air currents. The relevant chemical-potential force
µ
f
along the path
ds
of changes in energy
)
(T
µ
can be expressed as follows:
==()=g( 1)fddsdTdsddTradient TsdpdT
µ
µµ ρ
− −⋅−
(7)
The direction of
µ
f
is the same as that of
T
radient
g
, since
( 1//)>0sdp dT
ρ
. Relations (7) express
µ
f
as a function of entropy
s
, density
ρ
and the differences in
T
and
p
.
4. Driving Forces of Air
The atmospheric flow of air is governed by the exchange of heat and moisture between air masses and the rapid
variation in momentum and torque acting on them.
Examples of atmospheric flow of matter in nature are: A hurricane develops vortical transport of water vapor
from a warm seawater surface (more than 25 C) to the troposphere (altitudes between 14 and 19 km) and forms
there around an inner core (of up to 30 km in diameter) walls of rainy cumulus clouds of considerable height (of
up to 1 km) and extent (of up to 1000 km in diameter). The hurricane vortex can exist 2 - 4 days and vanishes
after leaving its energy source, the ocean, setting free all water masses on land (Allen & Jones, 1938). The
development of a hurricane can be explained as follows: By thermal buoyancy warm water vapor from the ocean
surface is driven up to cold air, where it condenses to rainy cloud parcels. These then cold parcels are subjected
to thermo-mechanical and Coriolis forces and vortically transported around the warmer inner core of a
beginning cyclone in the troposphere. Subsequently, the inner core remains warm due to permanently rising
water vapor and release of heat of vaporization, so that the condition for thermo-mechanical forces towards the
vortex center is sustained to balance in part the centrifugal force. The increasing vapor masses expand the core
in width and height by condensation and in lower regions by frictional effects and thus the clouds are kept in
expanding circular paths of motion. The cumulative water and air masses rotating around the core, steadily
driven by Coriolis forces, travel with increasing velocity over sea and land until they lose water supply and mass.
The motion of cold air falling at night to warmer air layers below, there condensing to fog and dew, and rising in
the daytime to air layers above which it gets warmer and warmer by sun irradiation. Cold draughts through
canyons and, at home, through gaps in windows and doors at equal atmospheric pressures outside and inside.
Currents in inhomogeneous, electrically not neutral fluids in the form of flashes of lightning between clouds and
A. Elsner
122
of ions and electrons in plasma discharge devices, the cause here being not the chemical potential difference but
the electrochemical potential difference.
5. Sources of Driving Forces of the Gulf Stream
In the following, the origin of oceanic flows is explained. To be specific, the given external conditions which
lead to the current of the Gulf Stream in the Atlantic are discussed here.
For this purpose, consider the water volume
V
comprising six subvolumes
n
V
, where each
n
V
is charac-
terized by the homogeneous state parameters
n
ρ
and
(, , )
nnn
Tp
µ
, giving the different external conditions in
V
. Thus, the inhomogeneities of the density, temperature, pressure and chemical potential in
V
are described
by the local parameters
n
ρ
and
),,(
nnn
pT
µ
. The actual density
n
ρ
depends nonlinearly on the local values
of temperature, pressure and salinity, and is calculated by the UNESCO formula, ranging roughly from 1.03
[gcm
3
] to 1.05 [gcm
3
]. At atmospheric pressure, seawater freezes at
1.8
[C] and has its maximum
density
axm
ρ
(Apel, 1987).
The Gulf Stream can be highly simplified as a current cycle in a seawater basin comprising six subvolumes
61
,
,V
V
. It should be noted that each volume is characterized by water-specific properties and not by fixed
dimensions. The boundaries of the warm-water bed of the Gulf Stream, viz: the bottom and banks of the river
(Maury), are physically determined by the higher chemical potential of the colder surrounding Atlantic water (at
depths below 500 [m] and between the continental shelves). This, on the one hand, determines the north-easterly
direction of the current and minimizes the flow cross-section and, on the other, leads to continuous cooling and
spatial expansion of the Gulf Stream along its course, as a result of lateral inundation of cold water. The
following water properties in the 6 individual subvolumes are considered:
1
V
: seawater in the polar region around Iceland, which is cooled at the surface by ice and cold winds to
freezing temperature
1.8
=
1
T
[C] and has atmospheric pressure
1
p
and maximum density
axm
1
=
ρρ
,
1.05=
max
ρ
[gcm
3
] and chemical potential
1
µ
.
2
V
: deep seawater below
1
V
at a depth
2000
H
[m],
with
4=
2
T
[C],
2m
<ax
ρρ
,
1.04=
2
ρ
[gcm
3
],
21 2
=pp gH
ρ
+
,
12
<
µµ
.
3
V
: deep seawater between
Iceland and the North American shelf with
23
=
ρρ
,
23
=TT
,
2
3
=p
p
,
2
3
=
µµ
.
4
V
: deep seawater on the
North American shelf with
3
4
=
ρρ
,
34
=TT
,
34
=pp
,
3
4
=
µ
µ
.
5
V
: water above
4
V
, where cold deep
seawater displaces warm equatorial water from the Gulf of Mexico, with
45
<
ρρ
,
1.03=
5
ρ
[gcm
3
],
25=
5
T
[C],
1
5=pp
,
45
<
µµ
.
6
V
: water at the surface between the Gulf of Mexico and Arctic Seas (Gulf
Stream between
5
V
and
1
V
), with
56
=
ρρ
,
56
=T
T
,
1
6=p
p
,
56
=
µµ
.
In
3
V
and
6
V
, water streams in opposite directions as required for continuity of flow; the external conditions
cause no driving forces either between
2
V
and
3
V
,
3
V
and
4
V
, or
and
6
V
. The driving forces of the
current between
1
V
and
2
V
derive from the chemical potential difference (
21
µµ
) and hydrostatic energy of
the weight of the water column
H
. Both the thermo-mechanical and the hydrostatic pressures act in the same
direction from the surface to the sea bottom. Further driving forces of the current between
4
V
and
5
V
are
caused by the chemical potential difference (
54
µµ
) and hydrostatic energy; here
4
µ
[4 C] is more positive
than
5
µ
[25 C], i.e. the relevant thermo-mechanical pressure is counterdirected to the hydrostatic pressure.
Since the thermo-mechanical pressure outweighs the hydrostatic pressure, the force is directed from the sea
bottom to the surface.
In the water flow direction the sum of the two hydrostatic pressure drops approximately vanishes,
12452 m5
()()= (2())(2.082.08)= 0
ax
gH gHgHgH
ρρρρρ ρρ
−−+ −−+≈−
[MPa]. The thermo-mechanical
pressures in (
1
V
,
2
V
) and (
4
V
,
5
V
) are obtained from the expression
25 5
141
() ()()
TTT
TTT
s dTs dTsdT
ρρρ
+≈
∫∫∫
. The
total flow-driving pressure is thus given by
de e
Gpd p
=()()=()
TT T
ss s
ulf StreamTT T
ss s
Ps dTsdTs dT
ρρ ρ
+
∫∫∫
(8 )
where ps = polar seawater, ds = deep seawater, es = equatorial seawater.
Equation (8) can be evaluated as follows: Without distinguishing between seawater and freshwater, the
estimates yield with
0=
ps
T
[C],
4=
ds
T
[C] and
25=
es
T
[C] the total thermo-mechanical pressure value
88 [MPa] (see Figure 3). This shows that the Gulf Stream is essentially driven thermo-mechanically. The main
A. Elsner
123
Figure 3. The functions
ll
(/ )
T
Tt
sv dT
and
1000 (()())
t
pT pT
⋅−
of liquid
water above the triple-point temperature
t
T
. Note that
l lll
( / )=()sv s
ρ
.
Numerical values at 298 [K]: ther mo-mechanical pressure = 88 [MPa], vapor
pressure
1000(()()) = 3.2
t
pT pT⋅−
[MPa]. The hydrostatic pressure at a
depth of 3300 [m] is 33 [MPa].
pressure contribution of 77 [MPa] is made by the chemical potential difference ensuing from the confluence of
cold deep seawater and warm surface water from the Gulf of Mexico, viz.
e
d()
Ts
TssdT
ρ
. The contribution of 11
[MPa] of surface water in the Arctic Seas sinking to the region of deep seawater results from
dTs
s
T
s
T
)(
d
p
ρ
.
Evaluation of chemical potential differences according to Equation (3) and Figure 2 yields
11=2949)
2938(
=
)( 277273 +
−−
µµ
[J/g] and
77=3026)2949
(
=)
(
298
277
+
−−
µµ
[J/g]. Multiplying these
values by the density 1 [g/cm3] also gives the above-mentioned pressures 11 [MPa] and 77 [MPa]. The hydros-
tatic pressure at a depth of 3300 [m] is 33 [MPa].
6. Gulf Stream Data
After comparison of the balanced hydrostatic and thermo-mechanical pressures one should now consider the
Gulf Stream data (Apel, 1987; von der Heydt, 2011)) measured in the four subregions of the circulation,
21
VV
,
42 VV
,
54 VV
,
15
VV
. The discussion here takes a very simplified form.
The Gulf Stream (in
between
5
V
and
1
V
) is
6
102.5=L
[m] long,
5
10=W
[m] wide, and
2
108= D
[m] deep, i.e. it has a water volume
14
6
102== LWDV
[m
3
]. Of this
7
6108= V
[m3s
1
]
flows through the Atlantic at a velocity of
1=u
[m s
1
]. The warm equatorial seawater thus needs
6
66
=/=/=2.510[s]
u
tLu VV
or about 1 month to reach the vicinity of the North Pole. When fully cooled from
25 [C] to 0 [C] by lateral incursion of colder seawater and by winds, it transfers in this time to the surroundings,
viz. North Atlantic water and air, a heat of
143631 122
h6
===2 10[m] 10[g]4[J]25[C]=2 10
eat tosurroundingsu
QV cTQmgC
ρ
− −−
∆⋅⋅⋅⋅ ⋅
[J]. This is equivalent
to a power of
]W[108=/
15
uu
tQ
.
The circulation of the Gulf Stream mass
20
6102== VM
ρ
[g] includes a kinetic energy
172 10=2= uME u
[J]. If the water in the polar region sinks with a velocity
0.1=
v
u
[m s
1
] to the
A. Elsner
124
deep-water region, it reaches a depth
3
103= H
[m] after
4
103=/=
vv uHt
[s]. The energy thus released is
21
106== gMHE
g
[J] and this is again expended when deep water rises along the North American coast.
Accordingly, the energy balance of the circulation can dispense with the contribution of the compensating
potential energies, viz.
0=)( HgMgMH −+
. As the water sinks and rises, a power
17
102==/
vvg gMutE
[W] is being permanently converted. The flow of water from the polar region to the Gulf of Mexico is subject to
turbulences and hence friction losses, which are set equal to the kinetic energy
152
10=2=
vv
uME
[J].
Sustaining the circulation, i.e. the sum of the kinetic energies
u
E
and
v
E
, requires an energy source, this
being present owing to differences of the chemical potential due to different water temperatures in different
oceanic regions. In addition, there exists yet another energy source which acts as a wind-driven oceanic
circulation at a shallow depth below the water surface in the north-easterly flow direction; its value is negligible
in comparison with the chemical-potential energy. The total circulation energy
shearindpotentialhemical
EE
wc
+
can
be estimated. According to Figure 2, the exchange of polar water of 0 [C] and deep seawater of 4 [C] yields the
chemical potential energy
11]g[102=)(
20
K277K273
⋅⋅−
µµ
M
[Jg
1
]
21
102.2
=
[J]; and the exchange of deep
seawater and equatorial water of 25 [C] yields the energy
77]g[102=)(
20
K298K277
⋅⋅−
µµ
M
[Jg1]
22
101.5=
[J]; this makes a total of about
22
c101.7=
potentialhem ical
E
[J], and adding the wind-driven energy
shearind
E
w
gives an estimated value
22
102
[J]. This energy is equal to the heat
22
h
102=
gssurroundintoeat
Q
[J], taken from
the Gulf of Mexico and transferred to the environment. The circulation energy is available as long as 4 [C] deep
seawater in the Gulf of Mexico displaces an equal mass of 25 [C] warm water and this is cooled on the way to
the polar region to 0 [C] surface water through heat transfer.
7. Results and Discussion
Meteorologists and oceanographers are concerned with flows of air in the troposphere and water in oceans, and
with exchange of mass, momentum and energy at the interface of air and water. Studies of the circulation of
oceanic currents concur in concluding that the currents are driven by surface flux, mainly wind shear at the
ocean surface and thermohaline convection in deep water ((Apel, 1987; von der Heydt, 2011). The basis of this
theory and conclusions from it yield the equation of state (UNESCO 1981 formula) for the thermodynamic
conditions and the Navier-Stokes differential equations for the dynamic processes. Despite all efforts to clarify
what drives an ocean current, no satisfactory answer has hitherto been forthcoming.
The chemical potential is a decisive quantity in the equation of state and must therefore be taken into account
when describing flow of matter in inhomogeneous fluids. It has a higher value at low temperature than at high
temperature, which can immediately be deduced from Gibbs's relation
0</=/ dTdpsdTd+−
ρµρ
. In the case
of free-particle transport it thus follows that matter always flows from a region of high chemical potential and
low temperature to one of low chemical potential and high temperature. This is how the well-known fountain
effect in helium physics is explained as well as the work done by an engine in the ocean (Ocean Thermal Energy
Conversion, OTEC) (Baretta-Bekker, Duursma, & Kuipers, 1998). It is important in oceanography and meteo-
rology to know that it is, besides Coriolis and centrifugal forces, mainly the existence of thermo- mechanical and
gravitational forces exerted on the fluid that effects the motion of sea currents and air.
In this paper it is shown that Maurys description of the Gulf Stream is correct: by the flow of cold deep
seawater into the Gulf of Mexico, the warm water there is channeled by the presence of land masses in the
north-easterly direction. Along its entire course the warm water is then kept together, as the Gulf Stream, by
incursion of surrounding, colder ocean water, being continuously cooled and thus being subjected to confi-
nement loss. Furthermore, the current at the free surface also transfers heat to the colder air. It sinks close to the
60th degree of latitude in vertical channels of
3
10
[m] diameter as 0 [C] surface water with a high velocity of
up to 0.1 [ms
1
] to the deep seawater of the permanent 4 [C] (von der Heydt, 2011).
The sources needed to sustain the North Atlantic circulation, while giving off heat to the surroundings from
rapidly flowing warm water of narrow extent at the surface and driving backwards slowly flowing, cold, deep
seawater of wide extent at the bottom, are the vertical thermo-mechanical and gravitational energy potentials in
the Gulf of Mexico and the polar region. Since the total water current is steady, the forces in the equatorial and
A. Elsner
125
polar regions must be balanced. When comparing the strengths of the upwards and downwards driving forces,
one has to set the corresponding expressions for the upwards and downwards pressures equal, viz. the relevant
sums of the thermo-mechanical and hydrostatic pressures. With equal values of the upwards and downwards
hydrostatic pressures
gH
ρ
being taken for granted, this gives
0=))(())((
4
0
52
4
gHdTsgHdTs
C
C
C
C
ρρρρ
+−−∫∫
or
0=)(11)(77 gHgH
ρρ
+−−
(in [MPa] units). The model described allows the averaged pressures for
driving the Gulf Stream to be estimated as 44 [MPa] and the depth at which the water flows back as
3
103.3
[m]. This should be compared with the contribution resulting from the momentum transfer of wind at the water
surface and the efficiency of the Ekman layer and its depth, which varies from some 10 [cm] to 100 [m] (Ap el,
1987).
The analysis of the large-scale oceanic circulation resembles that of an electric circuit. The two Kirchhoff
rules apply: both the sum of the voltage drops around a closed loop and the sum of the currents into a node
vanish. A sufficiently large set of measured data (such as the World Ocean Circulation Experiment, WOCE)
should thus make it possible to identify the sources and currents in the global network of oceans and the
troposphere. The local and temporal variations of the energy sources and currents are very much more
pronounced in the troposphere than in the oceans, where, in turn, they are the weaker, the deeper the sea. It will
transpire that the pictures of the oceanic circulation, viz. the wind fields over the ocean combined with Coriolis
effects and, in deeper parts of the ocean, the thermohaline processes, which are simply assumed to be generated
in proportion to the differences in water temperature and salinity, are not tenable and should be replaced
essentially by the pictures of chemical-potential and hydrostatic energy differences. The energy for maintaining
the existence of oceanic circulation is supplied by the sun. About half of the incident solar radiation is absorbed
by oceans, where it heats the upper levels of the sea. This amount contributes to circulation of water and
evaporation across the sea-air interface (Apel, 1987).
Acknowledgements
The author would like to thank Institut für Plasmaphysik (IPP), Garching, for providing computing facilities. He
is also grateful to A. M. Nicol for the English translation.
References
Allen, J. F., & Jones, H. (1938). New Phenomena Connected with Heat Flow in He-II. Nature, 141, 243-244.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/141243a0
Apel, J. R. (1987). Principles of Ocean Physics. Academic Press, Chapters 1.2, 2, 3, 4, 6.
Baretta-Bekker, Duursma, & Kuipers (1998). Encyclopedia of Marine Sciences. Springer, 110.
Brockhaus, V. (2012). Wissenswelten: Geografie, Natur, Klima. Mohn Media, 596-600.
Businger, J. A. (1992). Ocean-Atmosphere Dynamics, Equations (1)-(7). In R. A. Meyers, Ed., Encyclopedia of Physical
Science and Technology (Vol. 11). Academic Press.
Callen, H.B. (1960). Thermodynamics. John Wiley & Sons, Chapters 3.2, 3.3, 6.4, 16.
Elsner, A. (2012). Applied Thermodynamics of the Real Gas with Respect to the Thermodynamic Zeros of the Entropy and
Internal Energy. Physica B: Physics of Condensed Matter, 407, 1055-1067. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.physb.2011.12.118
Oertel Jr., H. (2002). Prandtl-Führer durch die Strömungslehre. Vieweg, 11. Auflage, Chapters 4.1.1, 5.1, 5.2.1, 12.2.4,
12.4.1.
von der Heydt, A. (2011). Die Physik der Ozeanströme. Physik Journal, 10, 23-29.