Journal of Applied Mathematics and Physics, 2014, 2, 55-60
Published Online April 2014 in SciRes.
How to cite this paper: Mansour, H.M.M. and Bakheet, N. (2014) Some New Particles beyond the Standard Model. Journal
of Applied Mathematics and Physics, 2, 55-60. h t tp://d x.d jam p. 2014.25008
Some New Particles beyond the Standard
H. M. M. Mansour, N. Bakheet
Department of Physics, Faculty of Science, Cairo University, Giza, Egypt
Email: mansourhesham@gmail.c om
Received December 2013
In this work a simulated B-L model at Large Hadrons Collider is presented using Monte Carlo si-
mulation software. B-L model is one of the scenarios proposed to add an extension of the standard
models. B-L model predicts the existence of three new particles at the LHC. They are a new neutral
massive gauge boson, three heavy neutrinos and a heavy Higgs boson.
Monte Carlo Simulation, Production Cross Section, Particles beyond the Standard Model
1. Introduction
There are many attempts to understand the world around us in terms of fundamental building blocks of matter.
The question here is what the world is made of? Now we can say that the behavior of all known subatomic par-
ticles can be described within a single theoretical framework called the Standard Model (SM). The Standard
Model of fundamental particles and their interactions is one of the most successful theories in physics. In partic-
ular, up to the weak scale (a few hundreds of GeV) it agrees to a great degree with a large set of experimental
data. However, there are several theoretical reasons, such as the so-called Hierarchy Problem, as well as expe-
rimental ones, such as the neutrino masses and the evidence for dark matter in the Universe, to expect that
something new (Particles and/or interactions) could lie at the TeV scale. Hints and/or answer(s) to these funda-
mental questions will be provided by the Large Hadrons Collider (LHC), a proton-proton collider which is run-
ning at high energies. In this work, Monte Carlo simulations [1-6] of new physics scenario B-L model are used
to simulate the phenomenological consequences of this model. In the present work a B-L model extension of
Standard Model is proposed and the results of simulation of gauge sector of B-L model (new neutral massive
gauge boson) are presented. Also the results of the simulation of fermions sector of B-L model (new heavy neu-
trino—Right handed neutrino) are presented along with the results of simulation of scalar sector of B-L model
(new heavy Higgs boson). Generators are used to set detector requirements, to formulate analysis strategies, or
to calculate acceptance corrections. The simulation process of the whole proton-proton collision at CMS is per-
formed through steps, event generator, GEANT4 simulation, digitization, event filter, reconstruction, and then
the physics analysis. There are many appropriate Monte Carlo (MC) event generators like PYTHIA and AlpGen
that produce events of proton-proton collision, and they also provide highly accurate statements of event proper-
ties: parton shower, hadronization, and underlying events. The events generators are interfaced to the CMS
H. M. M. Mansour, N. Bakheet
Software (CMSSW) via associated package developed by the CMS PH Generator group. In the current work all
the produced results are via using Monte Carlo (MC) programs, FEYNRULES program for the implementation
of the new model beyond the Standard Model. Our model here will be the B-L model which is based on a La-
grangian for calculation of Feynman rules in momentum space for any QFT physics mode. We also use
PYTHIA8 event generator for proton-proton collision and partons showers (PS), MadGraph5/Madevent is a
Matrix Element Monte Carlo Generator, CALCHEP for computation of Feynman diagrams and for effective
evaluation and simulation of high energy physics collider processes at parton level, COMPHEP is a Matrix
Element Monte Carlo (MC) Generator (MEG). As for MEG, it generates partons based on a Lagrangian also the
programs ROOT, Physical Analysis Works station (PAW) and MADANALYSIS are used for physical analysis
and to draw the results, in addition to Mathematica, C++, FORTRAN and Python programming languages, all
this works on Scientific Linux. Does the Standard Model of particles physics need an extension? The standard
model of electroweak and strong interactions is once again going to be severely tested as well as many of its ex-
tensions that have been proposed to cure its flaws. The observed pattern of neutrino masses the existence of dark
matter and the observed matter-antimatter asymmetry are the most severe evidences where the SM fails to ex-
plain. It is widely accepted that the SM ought to be extended but no one knows if the proper way has already
been explored in the literature. A joint collaboration is therefore needed between the experimental and the theo-
retical communities. The aim of this work has been guided by these principles. The aim is to fill some of the
gaps in the overall preparation towards real data, as well as to interact with the experimentalists. An extension of
the SM has been systematically studied, from the definition of its parameter space to the collider signatures,
leading to some new and exciting possibilities for the LHC to shed light on. Within the ambition of a complete
study, in all its aspects, the experimental help has been fundamental to efficiently concentrate on aspects of ac-
tual interest in a way which is useful for both communities. The main motivations for the extension of the SM
that we will describe concern the lack of a natural explanation for the observed pattern of neutrino masses, the
unknown origin of a global and not anomalous accidental U(1) symmetry in the SM (related to the baryon mi-
nus lepton (B-L) quantum numbers), and the absence of any observation of a fundamental scalar degree of free-
dom (the Higgs boson). B-L model is a triply-minimal extension of the SM. It is minimal in the gauge sector, in
which a single U(1) factor is added, related to the B-L number, by simply promoting to local the already existing
U(1) B-L global symmetry of the SM. It is minimal in the fermions sector, in which a SM singlet fermions per
generation. These fermions can naturally be interpreted as the Right Hand neutrinos (RH). It is minimal in the
scalar sector, in which a complex neutral scalar singlet is added to spontaneously break the new U(1) symme-
try, and at the same time to give to the new gauge boson a mass. The two latter points, once the U(1) symmetry
is spontaneously broken; naturally provide a dynamical implementation of the see-saw mechanism explaining
the neutrino masses. As we will see, the remnant degree of freedom of the new complex scalar severely im-
pinges in the phenomenology of the scalar sector. The general model we introduce is a one-dimensional class of
U(1) extensions of the SM, in which each element is characterized by the properties of the new gauge boson as-
sociated to the extra U(1) factor. The pure” B-L model is identified by the fact that the extra gauge boson, or
ZB-L, couples to fermions proportionally to their B-L number only. On the one side, this directly implies a
vanishing of Z-Z mixing (at the tree-level), that is consistent with the existing tight constraints on such mixing,
compatible with a negligible value. Moreover, the B-L charge does not distinguish the chirality, i.e., the LH and
the RH degrees of freedom of the same fermion which has the same B-L quantum numbers. It is important to
emphasize that this is a TeV scale extension of the SM. This means that the U(1) B-L breaking vacuum expecta-
tion value (VEV) is of O (TeV). Hence, the new particles will have masses at the TeV scale. We are mainly
concerned with the impact of the model at Large Hadrons Collider, on which the above phases do not play any
role. We will show that the Z new neutral massive boson in this model, with TeV scale heavy neutrinos, can
decay into pairs of the heavy neutrinos. The presence of new coupled matter, the heavy neutrinos, has important
phenomenological consequences. The possibility of the Z boson (and of the Higgs bosons, as we will show) to
decay into pairs of them, will provide new and exciting signatures. It is worth to briefly mention that the peculiar
decays of the Higgs bosons into pairs of heavy neutrinos, or into pairs of Z bosons, is a distinctive signature of
this model, offering the chance to distinguish it from the plethora of the otherwise identical, concerning the sca-
lar sector, singlet extensions of the SM in the literature. We will consider all the heavy neutrinos as degenerate
and with masses that are free parameters. In this work we study the details of the gauge and fermion sectors.
Their mutual interactions are fully included in the Z decay into pairs of heavy neutrinos. Altogether, this decay
provides new and spectacular multi-lepton signatures of the Zboson. One of the main results of this work is the
study of one of them, the tri-lepton decay mode (i.e., when the Z decays into exactly 3 charged leptons and
H. M. M. Mansour, N. Bakheet
other particles, such as jets and/or missing energy), together with the related backgrounds. We will present a
parton level strategy for reducing the latter in order to isolate the signal that will be validated at the detector
2. Gauge Sector-New Neutral Massive Gauge Boson ZB-L
In the B-L extension of the SM model, the extra Z'B-L boson and SM fermions are coupled through the
non-vanishing B-L quantum numbers. Searching for Z'B-L is accessible via a clean dilepton signal at LHC. We
will simulate B-L extension of the SM at LHC which is based on the gauge group GB-L = SU (3)C × SU(2)L ×
U(1)Y ×U(1) B-L using MC programs then search for the Z'B-L boson in the dielectron events Z'B-L l+ + l pro-
vides the most distinctive signature for observing the Z'B-L signal at the Large Hadrons Collider. The results in
this paper were produced by using simulation events generator PYTHIA8 and other software tools as CalcHep,
Mad Graph/Madevent, FeynRules, ROOT data analysis, Physics Analysis Workstation (PAW), ROOFIT pack-
age to fit any resulted histogram in order to get P.D.F. (Probability density function) and Mathematica produc-
tion of Z'B-L at LHC which includes production cross section. Figure 1 gives the cross section for Z'B-L at LHC as
a function of Z'B-L mass for various g" values (where g" is the U(1) B-L gauge coupling constant) at CM energy of
LHC = 14 TeV.
3. Fermion Sector-New Heavy Neutrinos
B-L model provides also a natural explanation for the presence of three right-handed neutrinos, [7-9] and can
account for the current experimental results of the light neutrino masses and their mixings. The heavy neutrinos
are rather long-lived particles producing distinctive displaced vertices that can be seen in the detectors. In this
section we determine the production cross section of heavy neutrino discovery at LHC for various CM energies,
5,7,10 and 14 TeV using MadGraph5/MadEvent and PYTHIA8 programs. We consider the production channel
of heavy neutrino pair production via the Z'B-L boson decay. The distinctive features of the B-L model take place
because the heavy neutrinos decay predominantly to SM gauge bosons in association with a lepton (either
charged or neutral, depending on the electrical nature of the SM gauge boson). Also, once heavy neutrinos are
pair-produced via the Z'B-L boson, they give rise to novel and spectacular multi-lepton decay modes of the inter-
mediate boson. Thus the rate for the pair production of the heavy neutrinos depends on the mass of the Z'B-L and
the strength of the B-L coupling g''. The process pp → Z'B-L vh vh can be tested at the LHC (for √ s = 5,7,10
and 14 TeV CM energy). If we take the value of the total integrated luminosity1 fb1 and take the maximum
value of the cross section to be 180 fb for mass of Z'B-L = 700 GeV and g'' = 0.2. For mass of vh = 100 GeV as in
Figure 2 we can say that approx. 180 events are produced according to the relation.
Figure 1. Cross section for Z'B-L as a function of Z'B-L
mass for various g'' values at fixed CM energy of
LHC = 14 TeV.
H. M. M. Mansour, N. Bakheet
Figure 2. Heavy neutrino pair production cross sec-
tions at the LHC for different values of g'' (for √s =
5,7,10 and 14 TeV, Z'B-L mass = 1.5 TeV).
where N is the number of events and L is the total integrated luminosity and σ is the production cross section.
Also, we can deduce from the figure that the production cross section depends on the Z'B-L mass and the value of
the g'' coupling in addition to the LHC CM energy.
4. Scalar Sector-New Heavy Higgs
The Standard Model is based on one complex Higgs doublet consisting of four degrees of freedom, three of
which, after spontaneous Electro-Weak Symmetry Breaking turn out to be absorbed in the longitudinal polariza-
tion component of each of the three weak gauge bosons W± and Z. The fourth one gives the physical Higgs state.
Minimal extension of the B-L model consists of a further U(1)B-L gauge group in addition to the SM gauge
structure, three right-handed neutrinos and an additional complex Higgs singlet which is responsible for giving
mass to an additional Z'B-L new gauge boson. Therefore the scalar sector in the B-L model consists of two real
CP-even scalars that will mix together. B-L model breaking can take place at the TeV scale far below that of any
Grand Unified Theory. In this section, we will present production cross sections for Higgs bosons SM-like
Higgs (light Higgs) H1 and extra Higgs (heavy Higgs) H2 by analyzing the data produced from simulated colli-
sions between two protons at different center of mass energies by Monte Carlo event generator programs .Also,
we find that the independent physical parameters of the Higgs boson in the minimal B-L extension of the Stan-
dard Model:
1) Higgs bosons masses MH1, MH2 and the scalar mixing angle α. Masses and couplings which depend on the
Higgs mixing have been tested against the experimental limits obtained at the Large Electron-Positron (LEP)
collider and at the Tevatron.
2) g'' the new U(1)B-L gauge coupling.
3) The mass of the new gauge boson mass Z'B-L. An indirect constraint on the mass of Z'B-L which comes from
the analysis at LEP of the precision EW data:
MZg 7TeV
4) α = 0 is the decoupling limit with H1 behaving like the SM Higgs.
5) α = π/2 is called inversion limit where H2 is the SM Higgs.
Figures 3(a) top and (b) low show the production cross section of the light Higgs boson H1 and the heavy
Higgs boson H2 in B-L model at center of mass energy7 TeV at Large Hadrons Collider for different values of
the mass. We notice that the curve is a smooth function of the mixing angle α and maximum cross section is ob-
served at the smallest value of masses.
The cross-section for H2 at an angle α is equal to that one of H2 for π/2 α. The maximum cross-section for
H2 when α = π/2 coincides with the cross-section of H2 for α = 0. The minimal B-L context [10] for high value
of the mixing angle could lead to important consequences for Higgs boson discovery at the LHC [11]. As in the
SM, the main contribution to the production cross section comes from the gluon-gluon fusion mechanism. The
next relevant contribution is given by the Higgs production in the weak vector boson mechanism. This contribu-
H. M. M. Mansour, N. Bakheet
Figure 3. Production Cross-sections at the LHC in the B-L
model for light Higgs boson H۱ by standard methods figure
(a) at √s = 7 TeV and figure (b) at √s = 14 TeV using
MadGraph5 and Pythia Monte Carlo event Generator.
tion is at the level of a few fb, as estimated above. Furthermore, the production associated with Z/W is dominant
over the production associated with Z'B-L [12,13]. When we analyze the production of the heavy Higgs, it turns
out that its cross sections are smaller than the light Higgs ones. In the light Higgs scenario, the production asso-
ciated with Z'B-L is dominant over the Production associated with Z/W which is in agreement with our previous
[1] Sjostrand, T. (2005) A Brief Introduction to PYTHIA 8.040. CERN-LCGAPP-2005-05 July.
[2] Sjostrand, T., Eden, P. and Friberg, C. (2001) High-Energy-Physics Event Generation with PYTHIA 6.1. Phys. Com-
mun., 135, 238.
[3] Sjostrand, T. and Mrenna, S. and Skands, P. (2006) PYTHIA 6.4 Physics and Manual. Journal of High Energy Physics,
05, 026.
[4] Boos, E. et al. (2001) Generic User Process Interface for Event Generator. arXiv: hep-ph/0109068.
[5] Alwall, J., et al. (2007) A Standard Format for Les Houches Event Files. Computer Physics Comm., 176, 300.
[6] W.-M. Yao, et al. (2006) Particle Data Group. J. Phys., G33.
[7] Huitu, K., Khal il, S. and Okada, H. and Rai, S.K. Signatures for Right-Handed Neutrinos at the Large Hadron Collider.
[8] Matveev, A., Krasnikov, N.N., Kiranov, M.M. and Geninenko, S.N. Detection of Heavy Majorana Neutrinos and
Right-Handed Bosons. Physics of Atomic Nuclei, 70.
[9] Collot, J. and Ferrari, A. (1998) Search for Right-Handed Majorana Neutrinos at LHC in the ATLAS Detector.
ATLAS Internal Note. Genève.
[10] Basso, L., Belyaev, A., Moretti, S., Pruna, G.M., Shepherd-Themistocleous, C.H. Z Discovery Potential at the LHC in
the Minimal B-L Extension of the Standard Model. arXiv: 1002.3586.
[11] Basso, L., Moretti, S. and Pruna, G.M. Phenomenology of the Minimal B-L Extension of the Standard Model: The
H. M. M. Mansour, N. Bakheet
Higgs sector. ArXiv: 1011.2612v4.
[12] Mansour, H. and Bakhet, N. Search for New Gauge Boson Z’B-L at LHC Using Monte Carlo Simulation. arXiv:
[13] Mansour, H. and Bakhet, N. (2012) Search for Resonance in the Dilepton Mass at LHC Using MC Simulation. Journal
of Nuclear and Particle Physics, 2.