Journal of Power and Energy Engineering, 2014, 2, 518-524
Published Online April 2014 in SciRes.
How to cite this paper: Liu, Y., Gao, S., Chen, J. and Lu, Y.L. (2014) A Method of Insulator’s NSDD Measurement and Its
Device Based on Laser Transmission Principle. Journal of Power and Energy Engineering, 2, 518-524.
A Method of Insulator’s NSDD Measurement
and Its Device Based on Laser Transmission
Yang Liu1, Song Gao1, Jie Chen1, Yanlong Lu2
1State Grid Jiangsu Electric Power Research Institute, Nanjing, China
2Wuhan Canneng Electric Power Science and Technology Company Limited, Wuhan, China
Received January 2014
Accuracy measurement of the Non-soluble Deposit Density (NSDD) on the insulator surface is v ery
impor tan t for the transmission line anti-pollution flashover works. A method to m easu re the
NSDD on double sheds porcelain insulator surface based on laser transmission principle is pro-
posed in this paper. Laser unit and luminous intensity sensor are installed between the up and
down surface of the double sheds porcelain insul ato rs , two glass tablets a re put between the
double sheds. The contamination on the glass tablets will influence the luminous intensity that
reache s the intensity sensor. The luminous signal is changed to electrical signal, and the insula-
tor’s NSDD could be obtained based on the difference of luminous intensity. The device can be
used in online monitoring of the insulator's NSDD co ndition on the insulator surface.
Laser Transmission; NSDD; Luminous Intensity; Real -Time Measurement; Device
1. Introduction
Insulator pollution flashover is one of the important problems which influe nc e the safety and stability of power
s ys tem. In sulator s of overhead transmission line operated under natural condition in long term and the surface is
polluted by conductive and non-conductive materials in the air. In wet weather conditions such as fog, dew, rain,
thaw and drizzle, the insulation performance of insulators significantly reduced which may lead to pollution fla-
shover and cause tripping under rated opera tion voltage. Due to the similarity of pollution condition and the si-
milarity of meteorologic condition in specific region, the success rate of reclosing after pollution flashover is
low and the failure of reclosing may cause line outage. Frequent occurrence of pollution flashover may lead to
large area blackout which may seriously endanger the safety and stable operation of the power system [1] [2].
The number of accidents caused by pollution flashover is the second major factor of total accidents of power
system which is second only to lightning failures. But the economic loss caused by pollution flashover is about
10 times of that caused by lightning failures [3].
Project supported by Science and Technology Project of State Grid Jiangsu Power Company (J2013010).
Y. Liu et al.
Polluting, wetting, formation of dry bands and partial arc, development from arc to completely flashover are
the four parts in the process of pollution flasho ver . The wetting process is an important factor because it deter-
mines the conductivity of contamination layer on the insulator surface. The NSDD directly determine the satu-
rated moisture water content and the pollution withstand voltage of insulators is also determined.
The measuring methods of pollution degree are mainly focusing on leakage current [4,5], equi valent salt de-
posit density (ESDD) [6,7], pollution layer conductivity [8,9] and surface flashover electric field strength [10].
But some of the measuring methods belong to indirect measurement and others need the disassembling of the
insulators. Thus the process of these methods is complex and is hard to apply to online monitoring of NSDD.
Some non-contact measuring methods are put forward, such as infrared temperature measurement [11]. But this
method is based on back propagation neural network. The measurement results are significantly affected by the
parameters of the model. Considering the characteristic of all methods above, a measurement method of NSDD
on porcelain insulator surface based on the laser transmission principle and relevant device are proposed in this
paper. The structure of the device is simple and the measurement result is easy to obtain. This method can be
applied to online monitoring of NSDD.
2. Measuring Principle and Devices
Laser is unidirectional and convergent. When the laser beam passes through a glass tablet, part of the laser will
reflect and the other part that passes through the glass tablet can keep good dire ctivity. This feature of laser en-
sures that the luminous intensity sensor can receive enough luminous signal. The principle diagram and sche-
matic diagram of measurement device is shown in Figures 1 and 2, respectively. The laser unit and the lumin-
ous intensity sensor are respectively installed on down surface of the upper insulator shed and the up surface of
the lower shed. Sampling glass tablet 1 and sampling glass tablet 2 can respectively collect the filth of the two
sheds. The filth collected in the two sampling glass tablets can equivalently reflect the density of contamination
on the insulator surface. As the sampling glass are gradually contaminated, the luminous intensity that reach the
intensity sensor d ecreases. Comparing the luminous density signal and the fitted cur ve of luminous intensi-
ty-NSDD which is calibrated in the laboratory in advance, the NSDD status of the test insulator is obta ined.
sampling glass tablet 1
sampling glass tablet 2
Figure 1. Schematic diagram
of measurement device.
Figure 2. Factual picture of measurement
Y. Liu et al.
According to GB/T4585-2004 (artificial pollution tests on high-voltage insulators to be used on a.c. systems
standard) of China and Q/GDW15 2-2006 (pollution classification and external insulation selection for electric
power system standard) of SGCC of China, NSDD between 0.25 mg/cm2 and 4.0 mg/cm2 can be divided into 10
grades. And calibration glass tablet is made in laboratory for testing the luminous intensity.
In order to eliminate the interference of background light in natural environment, the testing time of NSDD is
recommended to choose at night.
3. Measuring Device Module
3.1. Laser Units
Wavelength used in the laser uni t is 650 nm. The power of laser module is 20 mW. Factual picture of laser unit
is shown in Figure 3.
The luminous intensity of laser module is generally large. In order to keep the luminous intensity wi thin the
meas urement range of sensor, the peripheral circuit in the laser module of the device is redesigned. The im-
proved circuit is shown in F igure 4.
The circuit can change the luminous density of the laser conveniently so that the initial value is within the
collection range of the luminous intensity sensor. Meanwhile, in order to reduce the power consumption of the
whole system circuit, MCU is used to control the switch of the laser tube. The laser tube only operates when the
measuring process starts.
3.2. Luminous Intensity Acquisition Circuit
BH1750FVI is chosen to be the luminous intensity acquisition circuit [12]. BH1750FVI is an integrated circuit
used in two wire serial bus interface. The circuit can adjust the brightness of LCD a nd keyboard backlight (Ta-
bel 1).
According to the collected data of luminous intensity, with the high resolution of the circuit, wide range of
luminous intensity change can be detected. And the value is between 1lx-65535lx. According to the handbook of
the chip, the luminous intensity acquisition circuit is designed as Figure 5.
Figure 3. Factual picture of laser unit.
Figure 4. Circuit of laser unit.
Y. Liu et al.
Figure 5. Luminous intensity acquisition circuit.
Table 1. Diameters of laser unit.
Item Valu e Item Value
output wavelength 655 ± 3 nm conn ection m ethod common cathode
output power 20 mW Starting time ≤0.01
working voltage 2.7 - 4.0 V Service life >6000 h
working current <70 mA boundary dimension Φ12 * 35 mm
Working temperature 10˚C - 45˚C texture copper
storage temperature 40˚C - 80˚C color silver y
focal spot adjustable Net weight 12.5 g
spot diam eter adjustable Φ mm Directing of rotation CW laser
4. Main Circuit of MCU
4.1. Design of the Circuit
STC12 single chip is used as the MCU. STC series integrated MCU, A/D converter, E2PROM and other mod-
ules. Thu s, the peripheral devices of corresponding chip can be left out. It reduces the difficulty of circuit design
and software programming [13]. The main circuit of MCU is shown in Fig ure 6.
The circuit operates as the follow principle. MCU controls the switch of the laser tube to control which de-
termine whether the system begins to collect data. When the laser tube is off, the system is in low power state.
The system power consumption is reduced so that the life time of the system is extended and the efficiency and
durability of the system are improved.
4.2. Monitoring Platform
In order to get measurement values more conveniently and characterize the relationship between the change of
NSDD and the luminous intensity, a visual monitoring platform in the master computer of the device is designed
with Visual Basic software specially. The interface of the platform is shown in Figure 7.
With the platform, the real-time changes of the luminous intensity can be monitored and recorded. Changing
NSDD of the up surface and the down surface of the middle layer, the corresponding change of the luminous in-
tensity is recorded in the platform. With these data, a relation curve is formed in the platform.
5. Measuring and Testing
5.1. Measurement Methods and Steps
After the construction of the detection and monitoring platform is completed, the glass sheets can be calibrated
to verify the effectiveness of the device. There is no NSDD measuring samples for sale in the market, hence
NSDD measuring samples need to be calibrated. Production and calibrating methods are as follows.
Intercept a group of glass sheets of the same area, thickness and material as a backup.
Take respectively a certain amount of diatomite according to 0.25 mg/cm2 - 4.0 mg/cm2 NSDD and dissolve
the diatomite in a certain volume of water.
Apply the solution evenly to the gla ss samples.
Repeat step (2) and step (3) to make calibration glass of 10 grades. The 10 grades are determined according to
the NSDD ranging from 0.25 mg/cm2 to 4.0 mg/cm2.
Y. Liu et al.
Figure 6. Main circuit of MCU.
Figure 7. Monitoring platform interface.
When the calibration of glass is completed, the light transmittance intensity can be measured, and the mea-
surement steps are as follows:
Start the laser tube and adjust the appropriate luminous intensity value, then note the initial value.
Put the NSDD sample of the first grade between the laser unit light and the receiver of luminous intensity
sensor, record the data of luminous intensity when the number is stable measure all the NSDD samples as step
Modeling and get and the corresponding changing relation between NSDD samples and the luminous intensi-
5.2. Actual Measurement
Set the initial value of the light intensity to about 46000LX. The interface of the monitoring platform is shown
in Figure 8, and the luminous intensity reach maximum at this time point.
As shown in Figure 9, after putting into the NSDD samples in the device, the values of luminous intensity
changes significantly on the monitor.
Y. Liu et al.
Figure 8. Initial luminous intensity value.
Figure 9. Intensity value of NSSD glass tablet.
6. Conclusion
In this paper, a method to me as ure the NSDD on double sheds porcelain insulator surface based on laser trans-
mission principle is proposed. The design chart and relevant circuit is also demonstrated. Rationality and relia-
bility of the method are verified according to the actual measurement data.
[1] Gu a n , Z.C., Liu, Y.Y. and Zho u , Y.X. (2006) Extern al Insulation of Insulator and Electric Transmission and Transfor-
mation Equipment. Tsinghua University Press, Beijing.
[2] Gu , L.G. and Sun, C.X. (1990) Pollution Insulation of Electric Power System. Chongqing University Press, Chongq-
[3] Zhang, Z.J., Jiang, X.L. and Su n , C.X. (2006) Present Situation and Prospect of Research on Flashover Characteristics
of Polluted Insulators. Power System Technology, 30, 35-40.
[4] Wan g, L.M. and Li, B. (2010) Development of a 19-Channel Leakage Current Online Monitoring System for Natural
Pollution Deposit Test. High Voltage Engineering, 36, 559-564 .
[5] Kim, J.H. and Song, W.C. (2001) Leakage Current Monitoring and Outdoor Degradation of Silicone Rubber. IEEE
Transactions on Dielectric and Electrical Insulation, 8, 1108-1115.
[6] Chen, Y.Q., Wu, G.Y. and Tian , Q. (2001 ) Investigation of Salt Density in Substation and Transmission Line by Optic
Spectrum in Laboratory. High Voltage Engineering, 20, 481-487.
[7] Chisholm, W.A. and Buchan, P.G. (1994) Accurate Measurement of Low Insulator Contamination Levels. IEEE Tran-
sactions on Power Delivery, 9, 1552-1557.
[8] Zhang, R.Y. and Gu a n , Z.C. (1990 ) Conductivity of Partial Surface: A New Method to Describe Contaminated Degree
of Insulator. High Voltage Engineering, 16, 20-26.
[9] Zhao, Z.Y., Zou, J.Y. and Wu, G.Y. (2000) On-Site Measurement of Pollution Layer Conductivity for Suspension In-
sulators. High Voltage Engineering, 26, 37-38 .
[10] Shu, L.C. Yang, J.L. an d Jiang, X.L. (2009) E ffe ct of Pre-Polluting Methods on DC Flashover Characteristics of Arti-
Y. Liu et al.
ficially Iced Porcelain and Glass Insulators. High Voltage Engineering, 35, 1294-1300.
[11] Reddy, B.S. (2003) Study of Temperature Distribution along an Artificially Polluted Insulator String. Plasma Science
& Technology, 5, 1715-1720. http: // dx. doi .or g/1 0.10 88/ 1009 -0630/5/2/006
[12] Yun, Z.H. and Bai, T.R. (20 12) Indoor Light Intensity Measuring Instrument Based on BH1750FVI. Microcontrollers
& Embedded Systems, 6, 27-29.
[13] Xu, D., Dai, X.J. and Li, X.Y. (2012) Design of Digital Carbon Monoxide Concentration Transmitter Based on
STC12C5608AD MCU. Machinery & Electronics, 9.