Low Carbon Economy, 2011, 2, 32-40 doi:10.4236/lce.2011.21006 Published Online March 2011 (http://www.SciRP.org/journal/lce) Copyright © 2011 SciRes. LCE Analysis of Material Metabolism of Eco-Economic System in Chongqing Based on the Emergy Theory Gao Xue-song1,2, Luo Xiao-jiao3, Deng Liang-ji1,2, Z eng Min1 1College of Resourses and Environment, Sichuan Agricultural University, Ya’an, China; 2.Center for Rural Development Research, Ya’an, China; 3College of Architecture, Southwest Jiaotong University, Chengdu, China. Email: mxl-789@163.com, 359623545@qq.com Received December 3rd, 2010; revised December 29th, 2010; accepted January 10th, 2011. ABSTRACT Based on the emergy theory proposed by H. T. Odum, the material metabolism of eco-economic system in Chongqing during 2002 ~ 2007 is analyzed. The resu l ts s h ow that 1) the total available emergy in Chongqing is quite abundant and the economy is relatively more developed; the total metabolic output in Chongqing in 2007 was approx imately 70% of its total metabolic input and both are increased, with an annual growth of 7.07% and 14.3% respectively; 2) the de- creasing trend of most emergy efficiency indexes including system emergy self-sufficiency rate, emergy waste rate and emergy yield rate sho w that eco-economic system in Chongqing is still a resou rce consumption one, that the economic development mainly relies on local non-renewable resources, that the pressure of urban development on the environ- ment keeps increasing and that the urban recycling capacity is yet to be improved; 3) the metabolic efficiency and metabolic intensity of the system are both increased, with an annual growth rate of 7.34% and 8.41% respectively; and 4) the environmental impact index of metabolism drops slowly, while the environmental loading ratio is large? fluctu- ating between 16.8 and 13.7. The prerequisite of achieving sound operation of the metabolic system in Chongqing lies in the regulatio n and control of the intera ctive relationship between metabolic fluxes so as to promote th e coordinated symbiosis of urban metab ol i c emer gy fl uxes . Keywords: Emergy Theory, Material Metabolism, Metabolic Flux, Metabolic Efficiency, Chongqing Municipality 1. Introduction China’s rapid industrialization and urbanization have aggravated the demand for natural resources and the en- vironmental pollution. This extensive resource metabo- lism mode has increasingly obviously restricted the fur- ther development of the regional economy, and evalua- tion of the sustainable development of regional economy is urgently needed. The material metabolism analysis is to expound the d emand of regional eco-economic system for resources and the pressure of waste emission on the system, based on the analysis of resource input and waste output. The metabolism analysis has increasingly become an important means to evaluate the soundness of eco- economic system [1,2]. The study of mate ri al m etabolism analysis has, from its initial focus on single elements and basic raw materials, gradually emphasized the relation- ship among multiple metabolic processes, with study dimensions being increasingly widened [3]. The main study methods of metabolism analysis include material flow analysis (MFA), input-output analysis (IOA) and emergy analysis (EMA), etc. Some scholars hold that energy flow analysis is a vital way to comprehensively understand the metabolism of eco-economic system and may compensate for the disadvantages of material flow analysis [4,5]. Based on emergy analysis, many scholars have expounded the material flow and energy f low proc- esses of eco-economic system and the system operation efficiency from different perspectives [6-8]. With Chong- qing Municipality as an example, emergy theory is adopted in this paper to focus on the quantitative analysis of the metabolism of regional eco-economic system, diagnose the internal mechanism of resource and en ergy utilization and conversion, explore the optimal management mode of regional energy flow and the optimal energy use stru- cture, provide theoretical guidance for selection of ap- propriate regional system metabolic mode, and offer measures and suggestions on promoting the sustainable development of Chengdu-Chongqing Growth Pole. 2. Overview of the Region Under Study Chongqing, between North Latitude 28°10'-32°13' and
Analysis of Material Metabolism of Eco-Economic System in Chongqing Based on the Emergy Theory 33 East Longitude 105°11'-110°11', is located at a junction area between relatively-more-developed East China and resource-abundant West China, neighboring Hubei Pro- vince and Hunan Province in the east, Guizhou Province in the south, Sichuan Province in the west and Shaanxi Province in the north. As a region with a mid-subtropical humid monsoon climate, it is hot in su mmer and warm in winter, characterized by light and heat in the same season, long frost-free period, abundant rainfall as well as humid and frequent overcast days. Average temperature is 19.0˚C and annual rainfall is 1 439 mm. With a total land area of 82 400 km2, the altitude of Chongqing gradually lowers from north-south to the valley of the Yangtze River. Northwestern and central parts of Chongqing are mostly hilly areas and low mountainous areas. With 19 districts and 21 counties under administration, Chongqing boasts a total population of 3 235.3 × 104 and GDP of RMB 4 122.5 × 108 in late 2007. Chongqing is the largest economic center in the upper reach of the Yangtze River, a key industrial and commercial city in Southwest China and a hub of water and land traffic. In recent years, Chongqing has made a lot of beneficial explorations in developing circular economy and brought about huge economic, social and ecological benefits. However, the traditional growth mode of “large-quantity production, large-quantity consumption and large-quantity waste” has not been completely changed, and resource and envi- ronmental issues have increasingly become bottlenecks that restrain further economic advancement. 3. Study Methods Based on the solar emergy conversion rates of various substances (energies), emergy an alysis method is adopted to quantitatively analyze the energy flow in ecological system and economic system, and, through computation of various metabolic indexes, to scientifically and rea- sonably analyze and evaluate the regional material me- tabolism. 3.1. Emergy Theory Emergy (unit: solar emjoules) is a concept developed from system ecology and eco-economics. The emergy theory is a method of quantitative analysis combining ecological system and economic system and according to the solar emergy conversion rates of various substances (energies) by regarding solar energy as the standard, in view of the fact that all energies originate from solar en- ergy [8]. The emergy theory is to establish relations among dif- ferent energy levels .and is to contact the economic sys- tem and ecological system of the bridge. Because it pro- vides a common scale for measuring and comparing various energies, metabolic indexes of urban system are computed on this basis so as to scientifically and rea- sonably analyze and evaluate the urban system metabo- lism. 3.2. Data Sources The original data adopted in this paper come from: Chongqing Statistical Yearbooks from 2003 to 2008 [9], Chongqing Statistical Communiqués on National Eco- nomic and Social Development, and the statistical data, statement s and reports of relevant departments. 3.3. Compilation of the Metabolic Emergy Table of Urban System First, main energy items of urban system metabolism in Chongqing during 2002 ~ 2007 are listed, including re- newable environmental resources, non-renewable envi- ronmental resources, renewable organic energies, non- renewable industrial auxiliary energies, renewable re- source product output and non-renewable resource prod- uct output, etc.; then, flow quantities of energies are ob- tained according to the energy computation formula, ex- pressed as energy flow (J), material flow (g) and money flow ($). After that, different energy units are converted into a unified emergy unit according to the emergy con- version rates of different resources so as to establish a metabolic emergy table of urban system in Chongqing (see Annex 1). All the solar emergy conversion rates and emergy computation formulas of substances (energies) in this paper are cited from the references [10-13]. 3.4. Evaluation Index System of Metabolic Emergy of Eco-Economic System Based on the original emergy evaluation index system [5,6,9,10], the index system of metabolic analysis of eco-economic system in Chongqing is established from three perspective of metabolic emergy flux, emergy effi- ciency and metabolic evaluation. See Table 1 for the details. 3.4.1. Analysis Index of Metabolic Emergy Flux Analysis indexes of metabolic emergy fluxes refer to the emergy fluxes of the system itself and the emergy fluxes of resource and service outputted from system metabo- lism [6], including emergy fluxes of metabolic input, metabolic output and metabolic waste of eco-economic system, which consist of 15 indexes (Table 1). Renew- able resource emergy is numerically equal to the sum of renewable environmental resource and renewable organic energy, of which renewable environmental resource emergy input mainly consists of solar energy, wind en- ergy, rain chemical energy, rain potential energy, heat from the Earth rotation, and timber, etc. As solar energy, wind energy, rain chemical energy and rain potential Copyright © 2011 SciRes. LCE
Analysis of Material Metabolism of Eco-Economic System in Chongqing Based on the Emergy Theory 34 Table 1. Index system of emergy-based metabolic fluxes and metabolic analysis. Emergy Index Calculation ExpressionMeaning Renewable environmental resource (R1) Input of self-owned environmental resource em e rgy of the system Renewable organic energy (R2) Input of self-owned auxiliary e n ergy of the system Renewable resource emergy (R) R1 + R2 Self-owned renewa ble emergy w ealth of the system Non-renewable environmental resource (N1) In p u t of self-owned e n vironmental resource emergy of the system Non-renewable industrial auxiliary energy (N2) Input of self-owned auxiliary e n ergy of the system Non-renewable resource emergy (N) N1 + N2 Self-owned non-renewable emergy wealth of the syste Gross domestic product (GDP) Economic yearly gross domestic product Import emergy (I MP ) System emergy inputted from the outside Export emergy (EXP) System emergy outputted to the outside Money flow (M) GDP + IMP + EXP Total money emergy wealth of the economic system Metabolic input Total input emergy (U) R + N + IMP Total emergy wealth owned by the system Waste emergy (W) Waste emergy discharged by the system to the outside Renewable resource products (O) Emergy wealth produced from system metabolism Non-renewable resource products (F) Emergy wealth p roduced from syst em metabolism Metabolic emergy fluxes Metabolic output Total emergy output (U`) O + F Total emergy wealth p roduced from system me- tabolism Emergy self-sufficiency rate (ESR) (R + N)/U Self-support and sustaining capacity of the system Emergy waste rate (EWR) W/R Recycling capacity of the system Emergy yield rate (EYR) (R + N + IMP)/IMP Economic benefits of t h e s ystem Renewable resource emergy ratio (R) R/U Environmental potential o f the system Non-renewable resource emergy ratio (N) N/U Pressure of system resource utilization on the envi- ronment Emergy efficiency Waste flow emergy ratio (W`) W/U Pressure of system discharge w a st e on the envir o n - ment Metabolic efficiency (u) (O + F)/U Input to output ra tio during m etabolism Metabolic intensity (d) (O + F + M)/U Sum of metabolic flows of metabolic system pass- ing the analysis interface Metabolic environmental impact (EI) W Sum of environmental impact caused by pollutants discharged during metabolism Metabolic evaluation Metabolic ecological stress (ELR) (N + IMP)/R Indirect impact of m etabolic system on ecological system Note: All the indexes and calculation f ormulas in this table are cited from the references [7,8,11,12]. Copyright © 2011 SciRes. LCE
Analysis of Material Metabolism of Eco-Economic System in Chongqing Based on the Emergy Theory 35 energy are compounds from the same process, only the maximum item of them is counted in the merging to avoid repeated computation. Non-renewable resource emergy is numerically equal to the sum o f nonrenewab le environmental resource and non-renewable industrial auxiliary energy. Non-renewable environmental resource emergy input is the sum of the emergy of all minerals, raw coal and natural gas, etc. and the emergy loss of sur- face soil layer. Import emergy of purchased resources of urban ecological system is noted as IMP; total emergy (U) means the total “wealth” of urban eco-economic system, which is numerically equal to the sum of the renewable and non-renewable resources of the system itself and the import emergy of the system. Non-renewable resource products mainly include raw coal, natural gas, steel ma- terials, and aluminum materials, etc. Renewable resource products mainly include tap water, hydropower, agricul- tural products, animal products, and aquatic products, etc. Waste emergy (W) refers to the emergy of discharged pollutants, which is the sum of the emergy of waste water, waste gas and solid wastes. 3.4.2. Analysis Index of Emergy Efficiency System emergy efficiency should include correspond- ing indexes reflecting economic efficiency, resource utilization efficiency and pollutant discharge efficiency. Evaluation indexes in this paper mainly include 6 items: emergy self-sufficiency rate (ESR), emergy waste rate (EWR), emergy yield rate (EYR), renewable resource emergy ratio (R’), non-renewable resource emergy ratio (N’) and waste emergy ratio (W’), among which, emergy self-sufficiency rate is used to evaluate utilization of self-owned resources of the system and self-support ca- pacity of the system, emergy waste ratio is to evaluate availability of wastes discharged from the system and recycling capacity of the system, emergy yield rate is a kind of criterion to measure system operation efficiency, which is similar to the “output-input ratio” (outpu t/input) in economic analysis, renewable resource emergy ratio reflects environmental potential of the system, and non- renewable resource emergy ratio and waste emergy ratio represent the operation efficiency of regional system from perspectives of resource utilization and waste dis- charge respectively, which can be important indexes for metabolic emergy efficiency evaluation [6]. 3.4.3. Metabol i c Evaluati on Inde x China is in a rapid urbanization process. Production and consumption of resources not only support economic growth of cities/municipalities, but also influence eco- logical stress, environmental impact and sustainable de- velopment of public health, etc., making it imperative to evaluate regional sustainable development capacity through system metabolism. Evaluation indexes mainly include metabolic efficiency (u), metabolic intensity (d), metabolic environmental impact (EI) and metabolic eco- logical stress (ELR) [2,11]. Metabolic efficiency refers to the effective part of metabolic flows to the final user, basically defined as the input to output ratio during me- tabolism. Metabolic intensity is defined as the sum of metabolic flows of the system passing the analysis inter- face in a unit time, for which, the bigger the ratio is, the more complicated the structure of urban metabolic sys- tem is, the more perfect the storage system is, the more sufficient the feedback sector is, and the higher the inte- gral stability and optimization degree of the system is. The essential difference between ecological stress and environmental impact lies in their different positions in metabolic system; the former is upstream end impact, while the latter is downstream end impact. Environ- mental impact in metabolic an alysis is de fined as th e su m of environmental impacts of pollutants directly dis- charged during metabolic processes, while waste emergy (W) means the emergy of discharged pollutants, i.e. the sum of the emergy of waste water, waste gas and solid wastes. Thus metabolic environmental impact can be expressed in waste emergy. Operation of metabolic sys- tem not only leads to environmental impact that can be directly measured, but also produces a series of indirect impacts on regional and even global ecological systems, and these impacts together are collectively referred to as ecological stress. Due to difficulties in study methods, scale conversion and data acquisition, this paper adopts emergy environmental loading ratio index (ELR) to rep- resent the pressure of metabolic activities on ecological system. When ELR < 3, the environmental stress is small, when 3 < ELR < 10, the environmental impact is at an intermediate level; when ELR > 10, the environmental stress is especially great [6]. 4. Results and Analysis Based on Chongqing Statistical Yearbooks from 2003 to 2008, Chongqing Statistical Communiqués on National Economic and Social Development and the statistical data, statements and reports of relevant departments [12], energy, material and money flow data in Chongqing from 2002 to 2007 are selected to analyze and evaluate the metabolism of Chongqing eco-economic system. After the original data are converted to a unified emergy unit and simplified and merged into each metabolic emergy flux, the emergy data are taken into the above calculation formulas of emergy efficiency and metabolic evaluation index, and the emergy evaluation table of metabolism of Chongqing Municipality in recent 6 years can be ob- tained (Table 2). Copyright © 2011 SciRes. LCE
Analysis of Material Metabolism of Eco-Economic System in Chongqing Based on the Emergy Theory 36 Table 2. Metabolic emergy evaluation of chongqing municipality from 2002 to 2007. Item Year 2002 Year 2003 Year 2004 Year 2005 Year 2006 Year 2007 R(×1023sej) 1.020 1.190 1.180 1.160 1.090 1.160 N(×1024 sej) 1.380 1.380 1.580 1.770 1.740 1.930 IMP(×1022sej) 0.776 1.050 1.750 1.780 2.130 2.950 EXP(×1022sej) 1.015 1.451 1.900 2.291 3.045 4.087 GDP(×1023sej) 2.070 2.363 2.819 3.285 3.785 4.701 M(×1023 sej) 2.250 2.360 3.180 3.690 4.300 5.400 U(×1024 sej) 1.490 1.510 1.720 1.910 1.880 2.080 W(×1022 sej) 2.600 2.590 2.530 2.810 2.654 2.247 O(×1022 sej) 3.840 4.100 4.360 4.600 4.360 4.660 F(×1023 sej) 7.060 8.040 8.500 9.940 12.000 14.000 U`(×1023 sej) 7.450 8.450 8.940 10.400 12.400 14.500 ESR 0.995 0.993 0.990 0.991 0.989 0.986 EWR 0.255 0.218 0.214 0.242 0.243 0.194 EYR 192.000 144.000 98.000 107.000 88.000 70.500 R` 0.068 0.079 0.069 0.061 0.058 0.056 N` 0.927 0.914 0.921 0.920 0.930 0.930 W` 0.017 0.017 0.015 0.015 0.014 0.011 u 0.500 0.560 0.520 0.550 0.660 0.700 d 0.649 0.718 0.710 0.740 0.900 0.960 EI(×1022 sej) 2.600 2.590 2.530 2.810 2.654 2.247 ELR 13.700 11.700 13.600 15.500 16.100 16.800 Note: All data used for calculation in this table come from Chongqing Statistical Yearbooks from 2003 to 2008 [9], and all emergy conversion rates come from the referenc es [7,8,10-13]. 4.1. Metabolic Emergy Flux 4.1.1. Metabol i c Input Analysis It is known from Table 2 that, the total emergy utiliza- tion in Chongqing eco-economic system is mainly non- renewable resource emergy, which amounted to 92.3% of the total emergy in 2007, while renewable resource emergy and import emergy only occupied a small portion of the total emergy, accounting for 5.6% and 1.4% of the total emergy respectively in 2007. Non-renewable re- source emergy mainly consists of emergy loss of surface soil layer, raw coal and natural gas, and the 3 items of emergy input account for 99.0% of the non-renewable resource emergy input. Landforms of Chongqing are mainly composed of mountainous areas. The severity of water and soil loss indicates over-intense development of non-renewable resource in Chongqing, indicates that the urban system development is still based on consumption of non-renewable fossil fuel and mineral matters. Hence, the utilization structure should be further improved to replace some non-renewable resources, thus to promote the sustainable development of Chongqing eco-economic compound ecological system. From 2002 to 2007, renewable resource emergy, non- renewable resource emergy and import emergy in eco- economic system of Chongqing were increased in gen- eral (Figure 1), with an annual growth rate of 2.9%, 7.1% and 32.0% respectively. During the 6 years, money flow emergy and its composition were also increased. Money emery reached 5.40 × 1023sej in 2007, with an annual growth rate of 19.6%. Import emergy, export emergy and GDP emergy of Chongqing in 2007 were 3.8 times, 4 times and 2.3 times of those in 2002 respectively. Operation of eco-economic system metabolism in Chong- qing mainly depends on input of local resources in the mass. Import emergy, compared with local resource emergy, is low, but its annual growth rate is obviously Copyright © 2011 SciRes. LCE
Analysis of Material Metabolism of Eco-Economic System in Chongqing Based on the Emergy Theory 37 higher than that of local resource emergy, which shows that, as economy develops, regional metabolic system increasingly depends on external resources, and openness will be improved year by year. Thus, openness to the outside should be further improved, and external emergy should be extensively introduced to improve emergy feedback rate and alleviate resource stress of the region. 4.1.2. Metabolic Output Analysis As waste utilization product emergy still appears in the form of renewable resource products and non-renewable resource products, the sum of renewable resource prod- ucts and non-renewable resource products are taken as the total output of eco-economic system metabolism to avoid repetitive computation. From 2002 to 2007, non-renewable resource products and total output emergy in the metabolic system of Chongqing were increased, increasing in 2007 to 1.98 times and 1.95 times of those in 2002 respectively, while renewable resource products increased slowly in fluctua- tion (Figure 2). The total output of metabolism in Chongqing varied mainly with the increase of non-re- newable resource products. Non-renewable resource products accounted for 97.0% of the total metabolic out- put in 2007, which indicated that Chon gqing metabolism still mainly depended on local non-renewable resource, and the renewable resource utilization was low, which needs to be strengthened. Figure 1. Change trend of metabolic emergy input in chongqing. Figure 2. Change trend of metabolic emergy output in chongqing. Metabolic input emergy and metabolic output emergy in Chongqing showed similar growth trends, while the average annual growth amount (1.18 × 1023sej) and the average annual growth rate (7.1%) of metabolic input were less than the average annual growth amount (1.41 × 1023sej) and the average annual growth rate (14.3%) of metabolic output. In 2007, the total metabolic output accounted for 70% of the total metabolic input, indicat- ing that resource cycling utilization measures of Chongqing Municipality contributed to the alleviation of metabolic input of eco-economic system, and there had increasing trend in material inventory of the urban meta- bolic system. 4.2. Emergy Efficiency Analysis From 2002 to 2007, introduction of external resources into Chongqing Municipality increased slowly, and sys- tem emergy self-sufficiency rate, emergy waste rate and emergy yield rate were obviously decreased in general (Figure 3(a)). During the 6 years, The openness of eco- economic system in Chongqing was no t significant. Sys- tem metabolism still greatly depended on internal re- sources. Emergy self-sufficient rate of the system was 98.6% in 2007, a little lower than that in 2002 (99.5%). Emergy waste rates of Chongqing were 25.5%, 21.8%, 21.4%, 24.2%, 24.3% and 19.4% respectively fro m 2002 to 2007, indicating that the level of waste-resource recy- cling in Chongqing was unstable during the 6 years, which requires further improvement of wastes treatment techniques. However, the overall level was still de- creased slowly. With the development of environmen- tally-friendly technologies, the emergy waste rate is ex- pected to further decrease. The emergy output rate was 192 in 2002, 2.7 times of that in 2007, indicating that the operation efficiency of regional metabolic system was not improved under the same economic emergy input. Renewable resource emergy ratio and waste emergy ratio were both decreased (Figure 3(b)), indicating that both the use of renewable resources and the pressure of waste discharge on environment in Chongqing decreased over the 6 years. Renewable resource emergy ratio increased significantly in 2003, mainly because the annual rainfall in renewable environmental resources and the human emergy in organic energy in 2003 were significantly higher than those in 2002 and 2004. Non-renewable re- source emergy ratio was increased in general from 2003 to 2007, which showed that the operation efficiency of non-renewable resource utilization was strengthened during this period, while the utilization rate in 2002 was at a higher level, due to a relatively smaller total emergy of 1.49 × 1024sej. The above analysis shows that eco-economic system in Chongqing still belongs to a resource consumption type. Copyright © 2011 SciRes. LCE
Analysis of Material Metabolism of Eco-Economic System in Chongqing Based on the Emergy Theory 38 (a) (b) Figure 3. Emergy-based analysis of metabolic efficiency for urban system in Chongqing. Economic development does not depend greatly on ex- ternal factors. Due to increasing pressure of urban de- velopment on environment, the mode of economic growth needs to be changed, the industrial structure needs to be updated, and the resource supply and demand structure needs to be optimized. Specifically, utilization of non- renewable resources in great quantities should be trans- formed into more dependence on input of renewable re- sources, so as to improve resource utilization rate and waste-resource recycling rate [15]. 4.3. Analysis of Metabolic Evaluation Indexes 4.3.1. Analysis of Metabolic Efficiency and Intensity Metabolic efficiency and metabolic intensity of eco- economic system in Chongqing from 2002 to 2007 showed similar growth tendencies (Figure 4). Those in 2007 were 1.4 times and 1.5 times of those in 2002 re- spectively, with an annual growth rate of 7.34% and 8.41% respectively, indicating that, with rapid economic development, metabolic efficiency and intensity were both higher than before; the effective part of metabolic process was also relatively strengthened during this pe- riod; the structure of metabolism system became in- creasingly complicated, the storage system was increas- ingly perfect, the feedback sector was increasingly suffi- cient, and the integral stability and optimization of the system was also relatively improved. 4.3.2. Analysis of Metabolic Environmental Impact and Ecological Stress Metabolic environmental impact (EI) during the 6 years showed a trend from rising to dropping in the mass. Waste emergy did not change significantly compared to the rapid economic growth. Total amount of discharge of waste gas, water and residues in 2007 dropped slightly over that in 2002, i.e. 86.4% of that in 2002, indicating that Chongqing have paid much attention to the end-of -pipe treatment of industrial waste in recent years and the eco- logical environment has obtained increasing focus and improvement, while pollution treatment input and strength should be enhanced to improve environmental conditions. The environmental loading ratio of eco-economic sys- tem in Chongqing was increased. The environmental loading ratio in 2007 was 1.23 times of that in 2002, in- dicating that the pressure of urban system in Chongqing on local environment was not weakened with the urban development (Figure 5). Environmental loading ratios over the 6 years were all higher than 10, fluctuating be- tween 16.8 and 13.7. The opera ti on of metabolic sy stem in Chongqing has exerted significant indirect influence on upstream front-end of the ecological system. Although a Figure 4. Development trends of system metabolic efficiency and intensity in chongqing. 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 Year 18 ELR Figure 5. Development trend of metabolic ecological stress in chongqing. Copyright © 2011 SciRes. LCE
Analysis of Material Metabolism of Eco-Economic System in Chongqing Based on the Emergy Theory 39 high environmental loading ratio indicates stronger sys- tem emergy utilization [16], the system will develop in a negative trend once the strong utilization exceeds the support threshold of the system. In the urban system of Chongqing, efforts should be made to maximize the utilization of local renewable resources and protect non- renewable resources, such as sustainable utilization of mineral resources. 5. Conclusions and Development Suggestions 5.1. Conclusions 1) The total available emergy in Chongqing during 2002 ~ 2007 was quite abundant, and its annual growth and annual growth rate were 1.18E + 23sej and 7.07% re- spectively, with higher economic development. Local renewable natural resources were relatively in shortage, mainly consisted of local non-renewable resources (ac- counting for 92.79% of the total emergy in 2007). It is learned from the above that the economic development mainly relies on internal resources, and is on the basis of high-intensity use of local resources. Therefore, as a whole, the urban system metabolism in Chongqing is relatively closed and the utilization degree of external emergy is low. 2) Metabolic output of the urban system of Chongqing and its structure were both increased. Its annual growth and annual growth rate were 1.41E + 23sej and 14.3% respectively, both higher than the metabolic input emergy. This indicates that the recycling utilization and the resource recycling utilization of waste have made some contributions to alleviating the urban system metabolic input, and the material inventory of urban metabolic system is with net increase. 3) Money flow emergy of the urban system of Chongqing and its structure were both increased. The money emergy amount in 2007 reached 5.4E + 23sej, with an annual growth of 6.3E + 22sej and an annual growth rate of 19.6%. This indicates that, with develop- ment and status importance improvement of the economy in Chongqing, Chongqing will depend more and more on external environment, the input of external resources will keep growing, and th e openness will rise year by year as well. 4) Indexes reflecting emergy efficiency were mostly decreased, among which, emergy self-sufficiency rate, emergy waste rate, emergy yield rate, renewable resource emergy ratio and waste emergy ratio in 2007 were 99%, 76%, 37%, 82% and 62% of those in 2002. By contrast, non-renewable resource ratio was fluctuating to rise. This indicates that, environmental impact of the waste dis- charged by the urban system on environment is turning better, but the urban system of Chongqing is a resource consumption one on the whole, and waste treatment techniques and resource utilization rate are yet to be im- proved. 5) Metabolic effect, metabolic efficiency and meta- bolic intensity of the urban system were keeping rising, with an annual growth rate of 14.3%, 7.34% and 8.41% respectively. The metabolic environmental impact was fluctuating to decrease. This indicates that the awareness of environmental protection and reasonable resource utilization is gradually improving and the self-organiza- tion capacity and development potential are both devel- oping in an optimistic trend. However, the rising trend of metabolic ecological stress shows that the potential treat of resource consumption of Chongqing urban system upon the upstrea m end of the ecological system is gradu- ally increasing. Therefore, only through reasonably re- gulating and controlling the interactive relationship be- tween metabolic fluxes and through promoting the coor- dinated symbiosis of urban metabolic emergy fluxes can the sound operation of urban metabolic system be achieved. 5.2. Suggestions on Sound Development of the Urban Metabolic System in Chongqing Currently, Chongqing should, based on its original de- velopment conditions, continuously introduce new tech- nical innovative components, improve the utilization efficiency of input emergy, raise the emergy yield rate and waste-to-resource efficiency, reduce the system reli- ance on non-renewable resources, strengthen the devel- opment of renewable resources, and increase the social and economic benefits obtained from a unit environ- mental pressure so as to achieve sound cycling of system metabolism. The following should be done in order to achieve sound development of the urban system metabo- lism: 1) To improve system openness and enhance input of external emergy. Non-renewable resource emergy, re- newable resource emergy and import emergy in Chong- qing in 2007 were 92.79%, 5.58% and 1.42% respec- tively of the total emergy, indicating that environmental and resource pressures became increasingly obvious with the economic development. Despite a great annual growth rate (32%) of the import emergy during 2002 ~ 2007, the total amount was small; thus, openness to the outside should be increased and external emergy (such as tech- nologies, equipment and resources) should be extensively introduced to improve emergy feedback ratio, help emergy grow more rapidly and alleviate local resource pressure. Moreover, high-quality talents should be intro- duced in great numbers to improve talent structure and lay a human resource foundation for sound development of the system metabolism in Chongqing. Copyright © 2011 SciRes. LCE
Analysis of Material Metabolism of Eco-Economic System in Chongqing Based on the Emergy Theory Copyright © 2011 SciRes. LCE 40 2) To guide with policies, adjust the industrial struc- ture and change the mode of economic growth. Since environmental loading ratios reflecting the metabolic ecological stress of Chongqing urban system all are higher than 10, fluctuating between 16.8 and 13.7, the government needs to consider how to protect environ- ment and integrate macro-policy requirement of ecologi- cal factors while satisfying human needs. Besides, in the total emergy amount of Chongqing, non-renewable re- source emergy accounts for the majority part, indicating that the economic growth in Chongqing mainly relies on the input of nonrenewable resources, in a mode of eco- nomic growth with high resource consumption, which seriously damages ecological and environmental resources and does not conform to the sustainable development concept in a harmonious society. Therefore, efforts should be made to adjust the industrial structure, change the mode of economic growth from extensive growth to intensive economy, rely on high technologies, utilize resources, well protect natural resources and ecological environment, improve comprehensive resource utiliza- tion efficiency and enlarge environmental capacity of regional development. 3) To develop educational system and promote com- mercialization of study output. Only through education can advanced technologies and experience with a great amount of creative emergy be converted and amplified into emergy and wealth to promote economic develop- ment and social progress. 4) To reasonably organize planning and vigorously develop tourism. The decrease trend of emergy yield rate in Chongqing indicates that Ch ong qing should streng then industries with higher net emergy yield rates such as tourism, to make better advantages of natural and geo- graphical environments and cultural scenery, and sig- nificantly promote local economy. REFERENCES [1] R. S. Halla, D. Shauna and A. K. Christopher, “Estimat- ing the Urban Metabolism of Canadian Cities,” Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, Vol. 30, No. 2, 2003, pp. 468-483. doi:10.1139/l02-105 [2] D. Li, J. R. Liu and R. S. Wang, “Progresses on the Ana- lyzing Methods and Evaluating Indicators of Urban Eco- systems Metabolism,” Ecological Economy, No. 6, 2008, pp. 35-39. [3] Q. F. Ma, X. J. Huang, S. T. Yu, et al., “Review on the Research of Metabolism,” Journal of Natural Resources, Vol. 22, No. 1, 2007, pp. 141-152. [4] H. Haberl, S. Batterbury and E. Moran, “Using and Shaping the Land: A Long-Term Perspective,” Land Use Policy, Vol. 18, No. 1, 2001, pp.1-8. doi:10.1016/S0264-8377(00)00040-5 [5] W. Liu, M.T. Ju, Z. Li, et al., “Energy Flow Analysis in Regional (Urban) Environmental and Economic System,” China Population, Resources and Environment, Vol. 18, No. 5, 2008, pp. 59-63. [6] Y. Zhang and Z. F. Yang, “Emergy Analysis of Urban Material Metabolism and Evaluation of Eco-efficiency in Beijing,” Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae, Vol. 27, No.11, 2007, pp. 182-189. [7] J. Zhou, A. G. Qi, D.Y. Yuan, et al., “Emergy Analysis of Eco-economic Systems of Hunan Province,” Chinese Journal of Eco-Agriculture, Vol. 16, No. 2, 2008, pp. 488-494. doi:10.3724/SP.J.1011.2008.00488 [8] H. Liu, Q. Wang, Y. Song, et al., “Evaluating Regional Circular Economy Based on Emergy Theory: A Case Study in Liaoning Province,” Resources Science, Vol. 30, No. 2, 2008, pp.192-198. [9] Chongqing Bureau of Statistics, “Chongqing Statistical Yearbook (2003-2008),” Chinese Statistical Press. [10] S. F. Lan, P. Qin and H. F. Lu, “Emergy Analy sis of Ec o- economic System,” Chemical Industry Press, 2002. [11] R. Q. Wang and X. M. Rong, “Emergy Analysis of Agro- economic System in Shanxi Province,” Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, Vol. 19, No. 10, October 2008, pp. 2259-2264. [12] B. Y. Du, M. X. Men, H. Xu, et al., “Comprehensive Evaluation of Environmental Resources and Farmland Ecosystems in Hebei Province Based on Emergy The- ory,” Resources Science, Vol. 30, No. 8, 2008, pp. 1236- 1242. [13] H. T. Odum, “Environment Accounting: Emergy and Environment Decision Making,” John Wiley and Sons, 1995. [14] H. T. Odum, “Energy, Environment and Public Policy,” Oriental Publishing House, 1995. [15] L. Z. Zhang, Z. F. Yang, B. Chen, et al., “An Analysis on Urban Ecological Competition Capability with Biophysi- cal Accounting Method,” Acta Ecologica Sinica, Vol. 28, No. 9, 2008, pp. 4344-4351. [16] D. W. Yang, Z. J. Chen, H. Y. Ni, L. Jiang and X. Y. Liao, “Assessment of Sustainability in Eco-economic Systemin Sichuan Province Based on Emergy Analysis,” Resources and Environment in the Yangtze Basin, Vol. 15, No. 3, 2006, pp. 303-309.
|