﻿ The Detection and Empirical Study of Variance Change Points on Housing Prices <br/>—Taking Wuhan City Commodity Prices as an Example

Journal of Mathematical Finance
Vol.06 No.05(2016), Article ID:71914,12 pages
10.4236/jmf.2016.65049

The Detection and Empirical Study of Variance Change Points on Housing Prices

―Taking Wuhan City Commodity Prices as an Example

Huihui Shen1,2

1China University of Geosciences, Wuhan, China

2Department of Statistics, Hubei University of Economics, Wuhan, China Copyright © 2016 by author and Scientific Research Publishing Inc.   Received: August 10, 2016*; Accepted: November 7, 2016; Published: November 10, 2016

ABSTRACT

Economic system mathematical model often contains multiple variance change points about structure model. In the same mean, we combine the Bayesian method with the maximum likelihood method on the detection of the variance multiple change points. With Bayesian method, we can eliminate extra parameters first, and then use maximum likelihood method to find the change position. So we both can eliminate extra parameters and can avoid the change point on the prior distribution unknown problem. In addition, the benefit of the maximum likelihood method is just needed to find out likelihood density function of the maximal solution in the solution space, thus the variance of multiple change point detection problem is resolved. By making substantial analysis with an example from commodity house prices in Wuhan, three changes of variance are found in all. They correspond to the major structure changes of contemporary property market in Wuhan city. The method is practical and effective as the final results shown. It also has a certain practical significance.

Keywords:

Change Point, Bayesian Method, Maximum Likelihood Method, Commodity House Prices, Joint Distribution Density Function 1. Introduction

With the rapid economic development of modern society, we need to deal with more and more economic and financial problems. Economic cycle of change point analysis has always been a problem concerned by economists and statisticians  . The change point identification has played a vital role in the economy. Because the problems about change point greatly help to adjust economic policy and develop long-term and stable economic in the economic cycle  . The realty business is an important pillar industry. Commercial housing consumption pulls our country’s economic development, but many problems appear in the process of the sharp development of the realty business. So by the analysis and research on the commercial housing price, we find the factors affecting housing prices, and grasp the contradiction of the housing industry in Wuhan city. We try to find the crux of the problem from the price mechanism, the structure of housing supply, housing market price system and the macroeconomic regulation and control, etc., which provides suggestions for the government to perform effective macroeconomic regulation and management in the realty business. At the same time they provide a reference on market decision for realty business enterprises and personal investment.

Generally, there are many ways to estimate change point, such as Schwarz information criterion method, Binary segmentation method, Bayesian method, maximum likelihood method, the likelihood ratio test, (weighted) Least square method, nonparametric method, cumulative sum method, etc. Schwarz information criterion is set up in 1978 by Schwarz  . The reference  is used to detect the existence of the transition point, and doesn’t need to export its complex distribution function, so the use of information criterion to estimate the number and position of changing point is relatively simple. Binary segmentation method proposed by Vostrikova (1981) can simultaneously detect the transition point number and their position, and can save a lot of computation time  . In literature  the author combined with the previous methods, which was a combination of Binary segmentation method and Schwarz information criterion method, to detect the mean change points.

A likelihood-ratio method to detect changes in gamma distribution parameter for general values of the scale parameter was adapted in the reference  . The reference  considers the detection problem of variance change point in linear process with long memory. They propose the ratio test to detect the variance change point. The limiting distribution for test statistics under H0 is derived and the consistency of the test is also established. The reference  uses the cumulative sum of squares method to tackle the multiple variance change-points issue, in a way similar to the Binary Segmentation approach, this method only needs a small amount of calculation, but detecting change points must use the entire time series segmentation, which is difficult to guarantee the change point being the global significance. The references    and  use the Bayesian method to detect change point problems.

The reference  uses the method of maximum likelihood estimation to estimate distribution parameters’ change point problem for a series of random variable with independent identically exponential distribution, but the method is an approximate result in search of transition point location. The reference  today proposes a new method of Artificial Neural Network (ANN) for the random variable distribution unknown. Through the reference  , I am learning the neural network, and my next work will use deep learning method to detect change point model.

However, the parameters will change with time; in the reference  it used maximum likelihood method to estimate parameters on change point. For general change point problems, we usually consider the changes on the mean and variance, and under the framework of hypothesis test the population distribution is normal in the model, so change point problem of inference is equivalent to the mean or variance change detection  .

2. The Variance Change Point Detection

Change point definition: according to the statistical definition, to a certain random variable sequences, if there is a point in time, the sequence before the point to a kind of probability distribution and after this point in time sequence to another kind of probability distribution (or the same kind of probability distribution but parameters of different), so there is a change point in the sequence. The problem of a change point contains two aspects as follows: 1) to confirm whether there is any change, 2) to estimate the number and position of unknown change-point.

The typical objective of a change point analysis is to identify how many change points a series has and where they occur.

The reference  proposes to use a Bayesian approach to study the mean and variance change point model for the cases of one change and propose to use a sliding window to search for all copy number variations on a given chromosome. the reference  combine the control chart with the Bayesian estimation technique. Bayesian estimator with the informative prior is more accurate and more precise when the means of the process before and after the change point time are not too closed. Paul J. Plummer and Jie Chen (2014) examine the problem of locating changes in the distribution of a Compound Poisson Process where the variables being summed are independent identically distributed normal and the number of variable follows the Poisson distribution  . A Bayesian approach is developed to identify the location of significant changes in any of the parameters of the distribution, and a sliding window algorithm is used to identify multiple change points.

Pignatiello and Samuel (2001) used the EWMA and cusum charts and the maximum likelihood estimator (MLE) to estimate the change point of a process  . The reference  derived the change point estimators under the case where the S chart and MLE are used in a gamma process. Later, the reference  is that the maximum likelihood estimator of a multivariate Poisson process change point is derived for unknown changes that are assumed to belong to a family of monotonic changes.

In view of the above research, for normal random variable variance change point problem, we combine the Bayesian method with maximum likelihood method. First using the Bayesian method eliminates extra parameters, and then using the maximum likelihood method find the place of change point. Thus, we can use the information to estimate the change point more accurately.

Consider , , a series of independent observations from a normal distribution with mean 0 and variance , , where where denote the indexes of the observations before the variance changes and m is the number of variance changes. There are observations with error variance , . Convenient for expressing and . Change points subscript , change points time series is divided into period of time, every time distribution of is the same: , , , .

The main question now is how to estimate the location and the numbers of the change point according to the sample of.

We detect variance change point, it can be seen that

the variance is sample distribution density function, so the detection and analysis of the variance change point ultimately is considered to be the sample density function estimation, and then we use the maximum likelihood method to estimate the location of the change point.

then the joint distribution density function of the observations, as well as the likelihood function is:

where , and m is the number of the change- points.

In terms of the reference  , it gives the joint distribution density function as follows:

(1)

where, and m is the number of the change- points, and, , , , ,.

3. Bayesian Approach to the Change-Point Problem

We want to solve the key parameter k and m, that is the change point location and the numbers of change points, and relatively unimportant, is considered to be a redundant parameter. If we directly use the maximum likelihood method to deal with the redundant parameter, there are a lot of difficulties because of the unknown information of and. However, the Bayesian method can deal with this problem. The posterior distribution density function of the parameters can be obtained by using the Bayesian formula. And then can get the marginal distribution density function of k and m through the integration of the posterior distribution density function of.

To apply Bayesian method expunction extra parameters, we must construct the prior distribution of. In the absence of good prior information of, empirical Bayesian method can solve the problem. Empirical Bayesian’s thought is to construct the prior distribution of from the sample information.

With the above information, , , , , Under the condition of given k and m are as follows:

(2)

Thus we can derive the distribution of according to the type (2), and use it as the prior distribution of. And then we get the prior distribution of. The prior distribution of contains the sample information, so we use the Bayesian method. Combining with the type (1):

For, , , then

,

, on both sides of the equation at the same time integration for

4. MLE of the Change Point

By type (1):

The likelihood function is as follows:

(, ,)

Therefore, we want to use the Bayesian method, also need to know the prior distribution of m. The prior information of m is unknown, which plays a crucial role in solving problem. We use the maximum likelihood method to calculate k and m according to the above joint density function that is the likelihood function. Thus we can avoid the problems of the prior distribution information of m unknown. We first give m with an initial value, and then we determine as the location estimation of the change point number is m by the maximum density function.

5. Empirical Analysis

Housing price problem is the core of the realty business market, housing price is related to the people to live and work in peace and contentment in China, relates to the healthy development of the real estate market  . In the process of the whole real estate market, the price mechanism is always a basic adjustment mechanism, the rationality of the price or not also affects the realization of the real estate policy goals, to restore the real estate market in the current country commodity housing boom continuous research of the new policy environment, the deputy provincial city housing prices in Wuhan empirical research has practical significance.

The commodity house prices in Wuhan from 2000 to 2015 are as shown in Table 1. Since the housing system reform in 1998, the Wuhan city real estate development investment into a new historical period, and quickly formed a new real estate boom, the

Table 1. Commercial housing sales price (Yuan/square meters) from 2000 to 2015 in Wuhan city.

rising trend of real estate industry has lasted for 15 years. With a nationwide real estate boom climate, statistics show that: 16 years in Wuhan commodity house average price rose from 1983.52 Yuan/square meters to 8861.00 Yuan/square meters, the average annual growth of 13.14%.

As is shown in Table 2, the average increment of house prices in every year is got by the data in Table 1.

From the annual sales average increment data shows upward trend since 2001, the price fell slightly after 2012, down 1.01%, but the price increases for three consecutive years since 2013.

In the process of trying to find a place to change point, we first give m with an initial value, for m = 1, and then maximizing can be calculated to. Using change point solution of consistency, we put the m components of as the estimations for solution of the m components of, and maximizing can be got the estimation of another component. According to the nature of the optimal solution which each component of the optimal solution must be mutually conditional, fixed the m components of respectively, by maximizing to amend another component, until every component does not change. So we can get the position estimation of change points for, at this point. If meet the conditions will terminate or to continue.

We use the above analysis method to detect the 16 sequence data by the data of Table 1 and Table 2, and get the results of variance change points as shown in Table 3.

Table 2. Wuhan city commercial housing in 2001-2015 average increment (Yuan/square meters).

Table 3. The results of variance change points in Wuhan city commercial housing in 2001-2015.

From the analysis result shows that this set of data has two change points. Because the logarithmic likelihood density increment is 31.853 when, which is most significant, the change point location is 3, corresponding to the year is 2004. The change point will be the 16 data is divided into two segments, whose sample variances are 15179.9 and 151208.7 respectively, in front of and behind the data sample variance ratio 9.96. There is another change point location in 6 place, corresponding to the year is 2007, this change divided the data into two segments, where the sample variances are 52684.54 and 133163.1 respectively. The sample variance ratio between the front and the behind is 2.53. When, corresponding in 2010, the logarithmic likelihood density increment is 1.106, relative to the above two logarithmic likelihood the density increment is very small, the sample variance ratio is 0.42. So from 2000 to 2015 the commodity housing sales price variance in change point analysis it is concluded that there are three change points appropriately. Changing point in 2004, 2007 and 2010 respectively conforms the situation of the realty business market in Wuhan.

6. Interpretation and Discussion

Raising interest rates in 2004 as a prelude to comprehensive adjust and control the real estate regulation policies to follow up. The province government in Hubei adopted a series of policies and measures such as subsidies and reducing the deed tax the purchase of second-hand housing, which have obvious positive role and effect. Accumulation fund, housing loan portfolio and the secondary housing market fully open, which the housing reform policies carry forward all-around. Residents purchase ability and the demand increase promote the rapid development of the real estate industry. As a result, prices rose in 2004 can locate as “rising” at a high speed.

Three years later in 2007, the macroeconomic regulation and control prices still rising, disappointed with the reality of policy generally bullish but lead to consumer expectations. In 2007, the density increases mainly by means of financial regulation. The central bank raises interest rates four times in 8 months time. Such a density increases in interest rates. Touched by month high CPI growth, mainly used to suppress the surge of excess liquidity, prevent the possible inflation later. Difference from the developers for housing prices to judge “to do” in 2004, 2007 is the prices of basic steady, firm, real estate prices rising more concentrated. As a result, prices rose in 2007 can locate for “high rise”.

Have to say is the hottest in 2009 that is an inevitable phenomenon. Because of the sudden regulation in 2008, the main demand is depressed for a year, concentrated burst out in a short time, the market suddenly rushed up, the developers are very confident, the price is carried higher. Panic buying appeared at the end of 2009. Prices uptrend continued in 2010. So the housing price in 2010 has gone up a lot, we also detected the corresponding results from the model.

Test results and the actual housing conditions in line with the prices in Wuhan. It shows that the variance change point analysis technology in our country are explained from the perspective of quantitative control measures on the housing prices have a certain effect. The real estate market regulation has achieved initial results, but the complexity of the market operation and unstable factors still exist, the real estate market regulation is still in a critical period. In 2015 to continue the current regulation policies do not relax, expected prices to keep smooth, not ups and downs.

Change point in the field of economics and finance, its application prospect is very broad, which can solve many practical problems. Find out the change point, and deduce which factors in the model or parameter changed, use them for policy evaluation, analysis and forecasting.

On the housing forecast model, the real estate market is a complex system, many factors affect the housing prices, and the influence degree is different   . So we want to build a commercial housing forecast model, there is a certain difficulty. If we use the current Deep Learning approach is an effective method to deal with the big data, we can further study the prediction model about commercial housing prices and predict the future house prices, and quantitative evaluation of the real estate market macroeconomic regulation and control policy influence, provide technical support for government decision-making. Therefore, we can establish a reasonable housing forecast model according to the situation of China’s national conditions, which is the key point of our further research direction and research work.

7. Conclusion

In this study, we proposed the Bayesian approach combination with the maximum likelihood method for estimation of the variance change point. With Bayesian method, we can eliminate extra parameters, and then use maximum likelihood method to find the change position. So we both can eliminate extra parameters and can avoid the change point on the prior distribution unknown problem. In addition, the benefit of the maximum likelihood method is just needed to find out likelihood density function of the maximal solution in the solution space, thus the variance of multiple change point detection problem is resolved. Finally, by making empirical analysis with an example from commodity house prices in Wuhan from 2000 to 2015, we get the test results and the actual housing conditions in line with the prices in Wuhan. It suggests that the combination method to detect the variance change point is effective. There is also a certain practical significance and reference value.

Acknowledgements

I thank my tutor for helpful discussion and careful guidance, and this work is supported by the Program for Excellent Youths in Hubei Provincial Department of Education under grant Q20121902.

Cite this paper

Shen, H.H. (2016) The Detection and Empirical Study of Variance Change Points on Housing Prices. Journal of Mathematical Finance, 6, 699- 710. http://dx.doi.org/10.4236/jmf.2016.65049

References

1. 1. Wang, K.Z. (2005) Real Estate Economy and Its Cycle Research. Shanghai University of Finance and Economics Press, Shanghai.

2. 2. Worsley, K.J. (1979) On the Likelihood Ratio Test for a Shift in Location of Normal Populations. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 74, 365-367.

3. 3. Zhao, W.Z., Tian, Z. and Xia, Z.M. (2010) Ratio Test for Variance Change Point in Linear Process with Long Memory. Statistical Papers, 51, 397-407.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00362-009-0202-3

4. 4. Vostrikova, L.J. (1981) Detecting “Disorder” in Multidimensional Random Processes. Soviet Mathematics Doklady, 24, 55-59.

5. 5. Shen, H.H. (2010) Change Point Determination and Its Analysis of Application in Residents’ Consumption in China. Commercial Age, No. 3, 9-10.

6. 6. Sun, J., Jiang, S.Y. and Li, H.G. (2001) Bayesian Analysis of the Economic Sequence Change Point. Statistical Research, No. 8, 27-30.

7. 7. Inclan, C. and Tiao, G.C. (1994) Use of Cumulative Sum of Squares for Retrospective Detection of Changes of Variances. Journal of American Statistical Association, 89, 913-923.

8. 8. Inclan, C. (1993) Detection of Multiple Changes of Variance Using Posterior Odds. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics, 11, 289-300.

9. 9. Jandhyala, V.K., Fotopoulos, S.B. and Hawkins, D.M. (2002). Detection and Estimation of Abrupt Changes in the Variability of a Process. Computational Statistics and Data Analysis, 40, 1-19.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0167-9473(01)00108-6

10. 10. Schwarz, G. (1978) Estimating the Dimension of a Model. Annals of Statistics, 6, 461-464.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1214/aos/1176344136

11. 11. Son, Y.S. and Kim, S.W. (2005) Bayesian Single Change Point Detection in a Sequence of Multivariate Normal Observations. Statistics, 39, 373-387.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/02331880500315339

12. 12. Fotopoulos, S. and Jandhyala, V. (2001) Maximum Likelihood Estimation of a Change-Point for Exponentially Distributed Random Variables. Statistics & Probability Letters, 51, 423-429.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0167-7152(00)00185-1

13. 13. Shao, Y.E. and Lin, K.-S. (2015) Change Point Determination for an Attribute Process Using an Artificial Neural Network-Based Approach. Discrete Dynamics in Nature and Society, 2015, Article ID: 892740.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2015/892740

14. 14. Niaki, S.T.A. and Khedmati, M. (2013) Change Point Estimation of High-Yield Processes with a Linear Trend Disturbance. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 69, 491-497.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00170-013-5033-7

15. 15. Chen, J., Yigiter, A. and Chang, K.-C. (2011) A Bayesian Approach to Inference about a Change Point Model with Application to DNA Copy Number Experimental Data. Journal of Applied Statistics, 38, 1899-1913.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/02664763.2010.529886

16. 16. Monfared, M.E.D. and Lak, F. (2013) Bayesian Estimation of the Change Point Using Control Chart. Communications in Statistics—Theory and Methods, 42, 1572-1582.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/03610926.2011.594536

17. 17. Plummer, P.J. and Chen, J. (2014) A Bayesian Approach for Locating Change Points in a Compound Poisson Process with Application to Detecting DNA Copy Number Variations. Journal of Applied Statistics, 41, 423-438.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/02664763.2013.840272

18. 18. Pignatiello, J.J. and Samuel, T.R. (2001) Estimation of the Change Point of a Normal Process Mean in SPC Applications. Qual. Technol, 33, 82-95.

19. 19. Shao, Y.E., Hou, C.D. and Wang, H.J. (2006) Estimation of the Change Point of a Gamma Process by Using the S Control Chart and MLE. JournalJournal of the Chinese Institute of Industrial Engineers, 23, 207-214.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/10170660609509010

20. 20. Niaki, S.T.A. and Khedmati, M. (2014) Monotonic Change-Point Estimation of Multivariate Poisson Processes Using a Multi-Attribute Control Chart and MLE. International Journal of Production Research, 52, 2954-2982.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00207543.2013.857797

21. 21. Li, P. (2005) The Policy Factors Affect Real Estate Prices and the System Adjustment. Commercial Age, No. 9, 69-70.

22. 22. Zhang, H.M. (2014) The Idea and Strategies that China’s Real Estate Market Regulation in the Future. Social Sciences, No. 4, 44-53.