In a 50 mL round bottom flask containing 25 mL of methanol was introduced 0.05 g (0.29 mmol) of silver hexafluorophosphate (AgPF6) which was dissolved upon magnetic agitation at ambient temperature. To this stirred solution, 0.10 g (0.58 mmol) of 4,5-dihydro-1H-benzo[g]indazole (C11H10N2) was added in successive small portions. The mixture was stirred overnight and then filtered. The resulting colorless solution was allowed to evaporate in a hood at room temperature. A colorless microcrystalline material unsuitable for single crystal X-ray diffraction was harvested within few days in 82.5% yield.
3. Results and Discussion
3.1. Physical Properties and Elemental Analysis
The synthesized complex salt is insoluble in H2O and slightly soluble in CH2Cl2 or CHCl3. This colorless solid melts at 247 - 249˚C. The experimental values obtained from elemental analysis are in agreement with theoretical values as illustrated on Table 1 and confirms that the synthesized compound is actually bis(4,5-dihydro-1H-benzo[g]indazole)silver(I) hexafluorophosphate, [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6.
Table 1. Percentage of analyzed elements (C, H, N) in [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6.
3.2. IR spectrum of [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6
The FTIR spectrum of [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6 shows a characteristic sharp band at 3410 cm−1 attributed to the vibration of the N-H group of the pyrazole ring   . This band is shifted to higher frequencies of approximately 251 cm−1, with respect to that of 4,5-dihydro-1H-benzo[g]indazole ligand, occurring between 3159 - 3062 cm−1. This indicates that coordination of AgPF6 with the ligand leads to an increase in the IR activity of the N-H group. The variable medium band between 2953 cm−1 and 2832 cm−1 is attributable to the stretching vibration of C‒H of both saturated and unsaturated carbon atoms of the ligand. This absorption band is narrower and less intense compared to that of the free ligand, suggesting that the formation of the [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6 complex is accompanied by a decrease in the IR absorption activity of the C-H group. The variable weak bands between 1618 cm−1 and 1543 cm−1 are due to C=N and C=C vibrations. The broad (br) intense absorption band at 869 - 767 cm−1 indicates the presence of the counter ion. In fact, in the complex [CuL(NCMe)]PF6 (where L= bis(3,5-dimethylpyrazol-1-yl)methane), the hexafluorophosphate anion showed an intense absorption band at 840 cm−1  .
3.3. 1H Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectrum (1HNMR)
The 1HNMR spectrum indicates five families of protons. The N-H hydrogen of the pyrazole ring shows a singlet at δ = 7.9 ppm (2H, s) while the N=CH-hydrogen presents a singlet at δ = 7.5 ppm (2H, s). Furthermore, the multiplet at 7.2 ppm (8H, m) is characteristic of aromatic protons and two triplets obtained at δ = 2.9 ppm (4H, t) and δ = 2.7 ppm (4H, t) are attributable to two methylene (CH2-CH2) groups of the cyclohexane ring.
3.4. Thermogravimetric Analysis
The TG profile of the compound [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6 (Figure 1) evidences two distinct weight losses in the temperature range 50 - 600˚C, the two processes being endothermic. The compound [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6 is thermally stable up to 247˚C, followed by a drastic weight loss (45%) between 247 - 300˚C, and a gradual 10% weight loss between 300 - 600˚C. Although these weight losses cannot be attributed to the departure of particular fragments of the material, the loss observed from 247˚C is accompanied by melting and decomposition of [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6.
Figure 1. TG curve (red) and DTG curve (blue) of [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6.
3.5. Crystal Structure of [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6
Single crystal X-ray diffraction technique could not be used to investigate the crystallographic structure of the synthesized compound, due to the poor quality of crystals obtained. Thus, Rietveld refinement from powder diffraction data revealed that the title compound has the formula [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6. The final refinement plot is shown in Figure 2, with difference plots and peak markers at the bottom. A summary of crystallographic data is listed in Table 2. The MERCURY and the ORTEP views of the title compound are illustrated in Figure 3. A projection of the unit cell is presented in Figure 4 highlighting one anion sandwiching two centrosymmetric [Ag(N2H10C11)2]+ cations. Selected bond lengths and angles are listed in Table 3. Two 4,5-dihydro-1H-ben- zo[g]indazole ligand molecules coordinate to the central silver(I) ion through their pyridine-type N1 atoms, forming a centrosymmetric [Ag(N2H10C11)2]+ ion with a linear N-Ag-N coordination geometry around the silver(I). The hexafluorophosphate ion, , acts as counter anion. The Ag-N bond distance of 2.117 Å is similar to that reported in the complex salt [Ag(dmpzH)2]2Cr2O7 (dmpzH = 3,5-dimethylpyra-zole)  . The bulk structure is achieved by a three-dimensional network of intermolecular N-H…F (2.637 and 2.402 Å), C-H…F (2.558 Å) hydrogen bonds (Figure 5(a)) and Ag…F (3.145 Å) interactions (Figure 5(b)) that interconnect the ionic constituents. Ag...π (3.222 Å) interactions involving the silver center of one [Ag(N2H10C11)2]+cation and the π-electrons system of the benzene ring of the adjacent cations (Figure 5(c)) provide additional stabilization for the crystal packing.
3.6. Theoretical Analysis
The optimized structure, the molecular electrostatic potential and the electron
Figure 2. Rietveld refinement plot for [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6 with difference plots and peak markers at the bottom. The lowest portions show the high-angle range at a magnified scale (5).
Figure 3. Mercury view (ball and sticks) of the molecular structure of [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6 Ag(pink), N(blue), P(orange), F(greenish yellow) (a); ORTEP view of the molecular structure of [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6 showing the numbering and labeling of the different atoms (b).
Figure 4. Projection of the unit cell of the title compound highlighting the anion sandwiching two centrosymmetric [Ag(N2H10C11)2]+ cations.
Table 2. Summary of Crystallographic data of [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6 obtained from Rietveld refinement on X-ray diffraction pattern.
Table 3. Selected bond lengths and angles in the title compound.
density map of [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6 are shown in Figure 6. The optimized structure (Figure 6(a)) shows a complete delocalization of the π-systems of electrons in the pyrazole units and the benzene fractions of the ligands. However, the reproducibility of the optimized geometry is satisfactory even though the symmetry observed around the silver center and the phosphorus atom is lost in the optimized structure. In fact, the corresponding bonds in the two ligand molecules of the optimized structure show a slight discrepancy ranging from 0.000 - 0.008 Å. However, the C3-C4, C5-C6, C6-C7, C10-C11 and the C8-C9 bond lengths remained unaltered in the two ligands. On the average bases, the Ag-N bond length in the optimized structure was elongated to 2.148 Å from 2.117Å in the experimental structure, giving a disparity of 0.031 Å. In the same respect, the N1-N2 bond increased from 1.345 Å to an average of 1.384 Å in the optimized structure, giving a difference of 0.039 Å. This sensitive gap is attributed to the difference between the experimental model (solid phase) and gas phase model. All other corresponding bond lengths experienced slight elongation in the optimized structure, resulting to a general disparity ranging from 0.004 Å to 0.197 Å. These changes in the optimized bond lengths result to corresponding changes in bond angles and dihedral angles. For instance, the linear N1-Ag-N1 angle in the experimental structure was distorted to 173.20˚ in the optimized structure.
(a) (b) (c)
Figure 5. Intermolecular (a) N-H…F (2.637 and 2.402 Å), C-H…F (2.558 Å); (b) Ag…F (3.145 Å) and (c) Ag...π (3.222 Å) interactions in the title compound.
Figure 6. Optimized structure (a) and Molecular electrostatic potential and the electron density map (b) of [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6 at an isosurface value of 0.020 a.u. and an isodensity of 0.0004 a.u.
In order to study the site of [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6 available for electrophilic and nucleophilic attack, the molecular electrostatic potential (MEP) map (Figure 6(b)) was plotted. This map also gives an insight on the size, shape and charge density of the title compound. Different values of the electrostatic potential at the surfaces are represented by different colors; red represents regions of most negative electrostatic potential, blue represents regions of most positive electrostatic potential and green represents regions close to zero electrostatic potential. Thus, the most positive region of the MEP map of this complex is localized over the N-H group of the ligand, indicating that they are the most susceptible sites for nucleophilic attack. Meanwhile, the red and orange regions around the fluorine atoms of indicate that the region is rich in electron density and are the most suitable for electrophilic attacks. Some global reactivity descriptors of the complex, were obtained as follows; I = 144.79 kcal/mol, A = 42.48 kcal/mol, μ = −93.64 kcal/mol, η = 51.16 kcal/mol, S = 0.00977 mol/kcal and ω = 85.70 kcal/mol. The FT-IR vibrational frequencies of [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6 were also obtained using the LanL2DZ basis set. Selected calculated IR vibrational frequencies (cm−1) of [Ag(N2H10C11)2](PF6) complex and their assignment are presented in Table 4. It is worth noting that, the N-H stretching vibration observed between 3705 - 3455 cm−1 is shifted to higher frequency with respect to what is obtained experimentally. Since this experimental frequency range is similar to N-H stretching of imidazole (C3H4N2) observed by Ramasamy at 3376 cm−1  , it could be concluded that to some extent, the experimental results are more reliable than the theoretical. This is concretized by the fact that, the C-H group also shows multiple theoretical vibrational modes at very different frequency values. For instance, the C-H group of the pyrazole unit vibrates at 3292 - 3289 cm−1, while the benzene fragment of this compound shows symmetric and asymmetric C-H stretching at 3232 - 3231 cm−1 and 3211 cm−1 respectively. To add, the cyclohexane part of this complex exhibits C-H scissoring at 1353 cm−1, rocking at 1396 - 1361 cm−1 and twisting in the interval 1517 - 1502 cm−1.
Table 4. Selected calculated IR vibrational frequencies (cm−1) of [Ag(N2H10C11)2](PF6) complex and their assignment.
ῡ, represents vibration; py, stands for pyrazole; s, indicates stretching; ben, represents benzene; ss denotes symmetric stretching; as, is asymmetric stretching; cy, represents cyclohexane; t, stands for twisting; sc, is scissoring; w indicates wagging and r represents rocking.
Meanwhile, the experimental C-H vibration (2953 cm−1 and 2832 cm−1) is in agreement with literature  . Peculiar also of the theoretical IR results is the C=C and C=N stretching in the region 1665 - 1522 cm−1 which is quite similar to the interval 1618 - 1543 cm−1 obtained experimentally. Finally, the theoretically asymmetric and symmetric stretching, noticed between 825 cm−1 and 600 cm−1 respectively, is very close to the experimental range and those reported in literature  .
The DFT elucidation shows that [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6 has 358 molecular orbitals (MO), 129 occupied molecular orbital and 229 unoccupied molecular orbitals. The highest occupied molecular orbital, HOMO, is the 129th MO (Figure 7(a)) and has an energy of −144.79 kcal/mol while the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) which is the 130th MO (Figure 7(b)) has an energy of −42.48 kcal/mol. The red and green colors represent the positive and negative phases of the molecular orbitals respectively. The Ag+ metal center makes 3.036% contributions to the HOMO and 1.748% to the LUMO. makes negligible contributions to both the HOMO and LUMO. The calculated energy gap of HOMO-LUMO, of value 102.31 kcal/mol explains the ultimate charge transfer interface within the complex and characterizes the chemical reactivity and kinetic stability of the material.
The Bis(4,5-dihydro-1H-benzo[g]indazole)silver(I) hexafluorophosphate salt, [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6, has been synthesized and characterized using various techniques, such as IR and 1HNMR spectroscopies, TGA/DTG analyses, Rietveld refinement from powder X-ray diffraction and DFT studies. In the solid, the ionic constituents of the salt are linked through electrostatic and intermolecular interactions. DFT studies in gaseous phase revealed structural preferences of the atoms in [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6, demonstrating disparities between the X-ray and optimized structures in terms of bond lengths and angles, albeit they are within
Figure 7. View of highest occupied molecular orbital (a) and lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (b) of [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6.
acceptable ranges. The different IR vibrational frequencies were observed and the approximated reactivity of the material was estimated by the calculation of the ionization energy and the electron affinity of the materials. The [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6 complex salt appears less reactive and more chemically stable than the related [Ag(N2C11H10)2]NO3 reported earlier  . However, just like the case with [Ag(N2C11H10)2]NO3, the N-H group of the present compound [Ag(N2H10C11)2]PF6 provides site for nucleophilic attacks while the fluorine atoms of the uncoordinated hexafluorophosphate are susceptible for electrophilic attacks.
The authors are grateful to Prof Norberto Masciocchi of the Università del l’Insubria (Como, Italy) for X-ray facilities and to Prof C. Pettinari of the University of Camerino (Camerino, Italy) for spectroscopic analysis facilities.
Cite this paper
Fomuta, T.R., Ngoune, J., Djimassingar, G., Djampouo, T.A., Matemb, J.M.N.T., Anguile, J.J. and Nenwa, J. (2017) Synthesis, Rietveld Refinement and DFT Studies of Bis(4,5-di- hydro-1H-benzo[g]indazole)silver(I) Hexafluorophosphate Complex Salt. Open Journal of Inorganic Chemistry, 7, 102-115. https://doi.org/10.4236/ojic.2017.74007