Advances in Applied Sociology
2012. Vol.2, No.1, 30-36
Published Online March 2012 in SciRes (http://www.SciRP.org/journal/aasoci) http://dx.doi.org/10.4236/aasoci.2012.21004
Copyright © 2012 SciRes.
The Effectiveness of Skill-Based Intervention for Female Victims
of Intimate Partner Violence: A Critical Review
Fong Lopaschuk1, Cary A. Brown2
1Crisis Response Team, Alberta Health Services, Edmonton, Canada
2Faculty of Rehabilitation Medici n e, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada
Received January 25th, 2012; revised Feb ruary 27th, 2012; accepted March 11th, 2012
Intimate Partner Violence (IPV) is associated with limitations in Activities of Daily Living (ADL). This
paper critically reviews the methodological quality of evidence for life skills interventions provided for
women who have experienced IPV. A comprehensive search was carried out for all relevant studies and
the McMaster critical appraisal tools used to determine methodological quality of selected articles. Three
studies met the inclusion criteria for the review. Findings indicate there is limited evidence available to
inform practitioners as to benefits or weaknesses of current life skills interventions. IPV has serious indi-
vidual and social consequences and methodologically rigorous research is urgently needed.
Keywords: Intimate Partner Violence; Intervention; Activities of Daily Living (ADL); Spousal Abuse;
Intimate Partner Violence (IPV) is a recognized social epi-
demic with devastating individual and societal consequences
(PHAC, 2009). IPV is a term used to depict violence occurring
between people in intimate relationships. While there is no
standard definition of IPV, it is generally agreed IPV includes
physical aggres sion, psychological abuse, economic abuse, forced
intercourse and other forms of sexual coercion resulting in
physical, psychological or sexual harm (PHAC, 2009; Statistics
Canada, 1995; Statistics Canada, 2008). Unlike other types of
violence, the people involved i n intimate relationships may share
children and economic ties in addition to emotional attachments.
IPV not only directly affects victims’ emotional and physical
well-being but also affects the children exposed and in turn, has
a far-reaching impact on the society as a whole. In almost 40%
of domestic abuse cases, children are exposed to violence against
their mothers, often of a very serious nature (Statistics Canada,
2008). Children of mothers who are exposed to IPV experience
a variety of negative emotional and/or somatic symptoms often
accompanied by multiple impairments in their own interper-
sonal relationships, as well as in many other aspects of their
lives (Suglia, Enlow, Kullowatz, & Wright, 2009). These im-
pairments include distress that mirrors their mothers’ symptoms
(Lang & Stover, 2008), higher vulnerability to abuse (Taylor,
Guterman, Lee, & Rathouz, 2009), and maladaptive peer rela-
tions (Katz, Hunterm, & Klowden, 2008). Additionally, of sig-
nificant concern is that research demonstrates exposure to pa-
rental violence is associated with violent interactions in adult-
hood (Ireland & Smith, 2009).
While IPV can be perpetrated by both men and women, in
both homosexual and heterosexual relationships, women are
particularly vulnerable to abuse, especially women with dis-
abilities (Forte, Cohen, DuMont, Hyman, & Omans, 2005). As op-
posed to men, who are more likely to be attacked by a stranger
or an acquaintance, violence against women is frequently per-
petrated by a husband or an intimate male partner (Forte et al.,
2005). In Canada, women are consistently more vulnerable to
IPV across all provinces and territories, accounting for 83% of
all reported cases of domestic violence (Statistics Canada,
2008). Female victims of IPV sustain more frequent and more
severe injuries and are more likely to fear for their lives than
their male counterparts (Statistics Canada, 2005). In the cases
of violence analyzed in Mechanic, Weaver and Resick’s (2008)
study of 362 battered women from residential and non-residen-
tial community agencies, nearly half of the sample reported be-
ing hit repeatedly on the head, or sustaining injuries resulting in
loss of consciousness. Nearly three quarters of the women in this
study reported strangulation. It follows that for some women
this repeated head and neck trauma and partial or complete loss
of consciousness may have enduring neuropsychological and
psychological sequels, such as diminished cognitive function-
ing and post-traumatic stress disorder.
Given the sensitive and personal nature of this type of vio-
lence, victims do not always report all incidents of abuse (Span-
garo, Zwi, Poulos, & Man, 2012), and the majority of violence
experienced in spousal relationships is believed to be recurrent
in nature. Half of self-reported IPV victims state that the vio-
lence has occurred on more than one occasion, and only 27% of
victims report the incident to police (Statistics Canada, 2005).
While not all incidences of IPV are reported, IPV represents
a reality for many couples around the world. According to the
World Health Organization, 10% to 69% of adult women report
having been physically abused by a partner at least once in their
lives, while 6% to 47% report sexual abuse in their intimate
relationships (Krug, Dahlberg, Mercy, Zwi, & Lorano, 2002).
In Canada, over 38,000 incidents of spousal violence were re-
ported across the country in 2006, representing 15% of all po-
licereported violent incidents (Statistics Canada, 2008).
The WHO’s multi-country report on IPV, a study consisting
of 24,000 women in ten countries, found that women who ex-
perienced physical or sexual abuse, or both, were significantly
F. LOPASCHUK ET AL.
more likely to report poor or very poor health than women who
had not experienced IPV (Krug et al., 2002). Long-term nega-
tive health consequences for women exposed to IPV are docu-
mented extensively in the literature (Bonomi, Anderson, Rivara,
& Thompson, 2007; Campbell, 2002; Forte et al., 2005; Mc-
Nutt, Carlson, Persaud, & Postmus, 2002; Plichta, 2004).
Victims of IPV experience a range of physical problems. In
the Canadian National Survey on Violence against Women,
45% of wife assault cases resulted in physical injury, the most
frequent type being bruises (90%), followed by burns (33%),
and broken bones (12%), with almost 10% of injured women
reporting internal injuries and miscarriages (Statistics Canada
1994). Gynecological problems are reported to be the most
consistent, enduring, and largest physical health difference
between battered and non-battered women (Campbell, 2002).
Abused women have 50% to 70% increase in gynecological,
central nervous system and stress-related problems, such as
sexually transmitted diseases, vaginal bleeding, vaginal infec-
tions, pelvic pain, painful intercourse, urinary tract infections,
headaches, back pain, appetite loss, abdominal pain, and diges-
tive problems (Campbell, Jones, Dienemann, Kub, Schollen-
berger, O’Campo et al., 2002). It is not surprising that IPV is
also related to a signifycantly high user rate for healthcare and
social services, unmet needs for medical care, and to increased
medical costs (Plichta 2004, Wood, Hall, Campbell, & Angott,
2008, Wuest, MerrittGray, Ford-Gilboe, Lent, Varcoe, & Camp-
bell, 2008). Women exposed to IPV also experience long term
mental health conesquences such as depression and posttrau-
matic stress disorders (Bonomi et al., 2007). In addition, in all
settings, victims of IPV report significantly higher levels of
emotional distress, thoughts of suicide and suicide attempts than
women who have never experienced IPV (Krug et al., 2002).
IPV victims’ occupational performance is adversely affected
by their poor mental and physical health. Occupational per-
formance is generally defined as the ability to engage in activi-
ties of everyday living in a manner that the individual perceives
as both successful and satisfying (Brown, 2009; CAOT, 2007).
Victims of IPV experience more activities limitations than av-
erage Canadian women (Krug et al., 2002), due to the fact that
they are more likely to have problems walking, and because
they often experience memory loss, dizziness and chronic pain
(Wuest et al., 2008).
As a result of activities limitations, IPV adversely impacts
numerous occupational performance areas in the Instrumental
Activities of Daily Living (IADL). IADL differs significantly
from Basic Activities of Daily Living (BADL), which focuses
primarily on self-care tasks such as feeding and dressing: IADL
is defined as activities requiring cognitive and physical skills
for independent living, such as budgeting and parenting (CAOT,
2007). As performance in IADL decreases for victims of IPV,
their roles as mothers and workers are the most notably affected.
Poor health and chronic pain in survivors of IPV interfere with
employment and child rearing (Wuest et al., 2008). Mothers
currently experiencing IPV, or having experienced IPV in the
past, are significantly and definitively associated with maternal
depression (Casanueva, Foshee, & Barth, 2005; Hazen, Con-
nelly, Kelleher, Barth & Landsverk 2006). There is a positive
association between children whose mothers experience severe
intimate partner violence and these children’s injuries, largely
due to a lack of adult supervision, resulting in use of emergency
room facilities (Casaneueva et al., 2005). These children are
also more likely to experience maltreatment (Ireland & Smith,
2009). However, maternal ability to maintain positive care giv-
ing processes in an abusive context may buffer the effects of
domestic violence on children. These findings underline that the
difficulties inherent to the occupation of motherhood are exac-
erbated for vic tims of IPV (Krane & Davie s, 2007) and provide
insight as to why women who experience IPV struggle with the
parenting skills that are needed for a child’s physical and emo-
tional well-being and development. Some research suggests the
best way to promote positive health in toddlers may be to help
their mothers deal with relationships involving IPV (Suglia et
Due to the traumatic nature of intimate partner violence and
its negative impact on the occupational performance aspects
required for successful independent living skills, women expe-
riencing IPV are at an increased risk of becoming homeless
and/or dependent on their abusers (Helfrich & Aviles, 2001).
The results from Kimerling, Alvarez, Pavao, Mack, Smith, and
Baumrind’s (2009) study of 6698 battered women indicated
substantial rates of unemployment. IPV is also linked to poor
employment stability, and a high use of welfare (Busch & Wol-
fer, 2002; Kimmerling et al., 2009). Researchers found that
both victims of IPV and emergency shelter staff members con-
sidered that increasing abused women’s IADL skills, (such as
seeking and retaining employment, parenting, budgeting, time
management, social navigation skills to locate community re-
sources for housing, child care services and employment ser-
vices) were the most urgent intervention priority (Gorde, Hel-
frich, & Finlayson, 2004).
While there has been an explosion of studies in the past few
decades describing the short and long term harm of IPV result-
ing in numerous endeavors to assist victims of family violence,
there is a paucity of outcome research evaluating the effective-
ness of these interventions (Plichta, 2004; Wathen & MacMillan ,
2003). Most, if not all, interventions appear to have occurred in
the absence of scientific evidence on the benefits to be gained
by the use of these programs (Wathern & MacMillan, 2003).
According to Plichta (2004) there are few, if any, studies in the
interrelated fields of health, occupational therapy, dentistry,
health care administration, and pharmacy on the effectiveness
of services being provided to victims of IPV. A scientific re-
view of interventions for violence against women revealed that
no studies have evaluated the usefulness of screening to reduce
violence or improve women’s health, nor were there any studies
evaluating the success rate of shelter stay as a means to de-
crease incidences of violence (Helfrich, et al., 2006). While a
systematic review (Helfrich & Rivera, 2006) revealed advocacy,
career counseling plus conscious awareness, cognitive behav-
ioral counseling, cognitive trauma therapy, peer support groups,
and safety planning as being beneficial for female victims of
IPV, little information is available as to the efficacy and rele-
vance of life skills interventions for this population (Gorde et
al., 2004; Helfrich et al., 2006; Helfrich & Rivera, 2006).
It is apparent that community-based service providers have
both an obligation and the opportunity to address a variety of
important life skills for victims of IPV Helfrich & Aviles,
2001). Occupational therapy is an example of a profession par-
ticularly suited to provide intervention to increase occupational
performance, as occupational therapists are trained in assessing
and providing therapeutic interventions to address individuals
coping skills for the challenges that arise from the dynamic
interactions between peoples and their environment. Given the
profession’s core philosophy of promoting self-efficacy, life
Copyright © 2012 SciRes. 31
F. LOPASCHUK ET AL.
skills for self-management, and social and occupational justice,
occupational therapy have the capacity to assume not only di-
rect therapeutic intervention but also activism and advocacy
activities on behalf of those who are vulnerable and marginal-
ized (Cage, 2007).
Occupational therapy has a social vision with its core mis-
sion to enable occupations through therapeutic use of activity in
promotion of function. Occupational therapists specialize in
promoting engagement in daily life activities, and can play a
vital role in increasing occupational participation (CAOT,
2007). IPV hinders victims from engaging in daily activities in
a healthy, competent and satisfying manner. Occupational
Therapists can play a role in restoring and enhancing the ability
of those women experiencing IVP to participate in their chosen
ADL by focusing on facilitating the acquisition of skills for
healthy, independent lifestyles and the subsequent improvement
of quality of life (Javaherian, Underwood, & Delany, 2007;
Olivas-De La, 2008).
Recognizing that outcome assessment of interventions is ne-
cessary in order to deliver quality programming, research and
theory is beginning to emerge to assist those who experience
IPV to develop or restore their abilities to engage in daily life
occupations. One example is Helfrich and Avile’s (2001) rec-
ommendation for a theory-based outline of assessment and treat-
ment procedures for occupational therapists working with those
who have experienced IPV.
Our background search revealed a gap between the theory-
based discussion of IPV and the apparent lack of findings for
intervention results. To better guide both best-practice and fu-
ture research, a systematic review of all outcome studies to
clarify the benefits of IADL intervention for victims of IP is
required. With that goal, this paper provides a critical review of
the different IADL treatment program research to enhance
women’s participation in their instrumental activities of daily
Research Ques tion and Aim
The research question this paper intends to address is the
following: What is the strength of evidence in favor of ADL
skills intervention for female victims of heterosexual IPV? The
aim of this paper is to analyze studies concerning interventions
geared towards increasing ADL skills in the areas of self-care,
leisure and productivity.
The first author (FL) carried out a Critical Literature Review
(CR) following the standardized approach defined by Law and
MacDermid (2008). Critical Reviews following these protocols
include qualitati ve, quantitative and mixed methods studies. Thi s
approach was selected so as to ensure the identification and as-
sessment of the range of relevant research methodologies. This
broad scoping is important when addressing comp lex, non-linear
social and health-care issues like IPV directed at Canadian wo-
men. The McMaster Protocols were first published on-line in
1998 and updated in 2008 (Law, 2008). They are extensively
used within rehabilitation research and are now translated into
four languages. The Critical Review process result in a system-
atic synthesis of published research findings on ADL interven-
tions based on an explicit search strategy and evaluation of this
literature against quality indicators as identified in the McMas-
ter protocols (Law, 2008). The steps are outlined below.
The following databases were searched: AMED (Ovid),
CINAHL (EBSCO), MEDLINE (Ovid), PsychInfo (Ovid), OTD-
base and OTSeeker. A researcher in the field of Family Studies
and a medical librarian were consulted to validate the accept-
ability and the comprehensiveness of the search strategies. De-
tails of the search are available from the corresponding author.
Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria
For this review, IPV was defined as the physical and psy-
chological abuse of women perpetrated by their male partners.
This Critical Review focuses on the effectiveness of interve-
netions to enhance engagement in ADL. Therefore, publications
were included if they had been peer-reviewed and reported on a
therapeutic intervention that addressed ADL interventions in
the area of self-care, leisure or productivity for women who had
experienced IPV. The Critical Review included only outcome-
based research. All articles, irrespective of re search design, were
included. Studies on substance abuse; prevention of IPV, pro-
grams addressing sexual assault by strangers or acquaintances,
childhood sexual abuse, or studies concerning interventions not
geared towards increasing ADL skills were excluded. The re-
search question focused on outcomes with clinically relevance
to healthcare providers, such as occupational therapists, who
specialize in ADL and increasing the occupational performance
of women who have experienced IPV. Therefore, studies that
evaluate specialized psychological intervention, psychoanalytic
therapy or counseling alone were excluded.
The preliminary search resulted in 494 citations. Review of
the abstracts and application of the exclusion/inclusion criteria
resulted in four articles. The first author (FL), examined the full
text of these and manually searched the reference lists of these
articles. Subsequently three articles (Gutman et al., 2004; Hel-
frich & Avileo, 2001; McFarlane et al., 2002). were retained for
full review and critical analysis (Table 1). The most frequent
reason for the exclusion of a given paper was the focus on top-
ics other than interventions for female victims of IPV, such as
drug abuse, childhood sexual abuse, and interventions for the
perpetrators of IPV.
The Critical Review protocols (Law, 2008) rate the research
quality of individual studies and are based on a determined set
of operational parameters including the following 12 categories:
study purpose, literature, design, design types, appropriateness
of study design, biases, sample, outcomes, i ntervention, results,
drop outs and conclusions and clinical implications. The Jadad
scoring system was also used to assess the quality of randomi-
zation achieved in the one randomized control trial (RCT) re-
trieved in the search (Jadad, Moore, Carrolee, Jenkison, Rey-
nolds et al., 1996). The Jadad Scale is a simple, valid, reliable
instrument that assists in critical evaluation of randomization in
RCTs (Jadad et al., 1996).
Systematic review of the literature revealed a paucity of ma-
terial regarding ADL interventions for IPV victims. Of the three
Copyright © 2012 SciRes.
F. LOPASCHUK ET AL.
Copyright © 2012 SciRes. 33
Descriptions of studies included in the re view of ADL interventions for victims of IPV.
Study Aims Intervention Outcome Assessments Outcome
et al. (2004)
Assess effectiveness of an
intervention for wom en experiencing
IPV and/or homelessness, whose
cognitive impairment s may have
contributed to their inability to
leave an abusive situation
1 hr/week fo r six months
via group and individual 1:1
sessions on 12 IADL areas
GAS scores, pre-post tests
chart review, OT students
logs, acceptability question
99% of the participants expressed a high
degree of satisfaction regardin g the
interventions. All but one participant
achieved expected o ut come or greater in
all intervention area s.
et al. (2006)
Enhance employment knowledge
and skills i n a group of IPV
survivors residing in a shelter
8 sessions in 4 weeks via
group and 1:1 sessions
on vocational skills
Individual knowledge base
and client sa t isfactions
Clinical intervention was effective in
providing opp ortunity to develop skills
critical to obtain and maintain employment.
Article did not address re sul ts from weekly
quizzes and pre/post Ax designed to evaluate
informati on th at had be en reviewed.
et al. (2002)
Increase the number of “safety
promoting” behaviour s practiced
by abused women.
Six safety inte rvention phone
calls, first within 48 - 72 hrs
of initial visit, then remaining
calls at 1, 2, 3, 5, 8 weeks, with
discussion of safety b ehaviour
Safety Behaviour Checklist
Checklist completed at
each phone call and at 3
and 6 month follow up
phone ca l ls t o assess w omen
on the use of safety behaviours
Participant from intervention group practiced
significantly higher number of safety
behaviours at 3 and 6 months.
papers dealing specifically with increasing ADL skills, Helfrich
and Rivera (2006) focused on vocational skills. Gutman et al.
(2004) addressed twelve different IADL interventions, include-
ing, safety planning, vocational skills, practical life skills and
controlling risky behaviours, and McFarlane et al. (2002) fo-
cused on safety behaviours. Only Gutman et al. (2004) explored
leisure as a topic for ADL intervention. Table 2 contain a de-
scriptive summary of each study included in the critical review
and Table 1 presents a descriptive summary and Table 2 pre-
sents the comparative findings of the quality critique for each of
the three studies.
Study 1: Gutman et al.’s (2004 ) study of 26 women employ ed
a cohort design and evaluated a program that addresses possible
cognitive deficits in women who had experienced IPV as com-
pared to what Gutman et al identified as traditional treatment
based on a psychological perspective. Their study utilizes a mixed-
method design and a convenience sample comprised of 26
women, who all reported having a disability. The intervention
targeted ADL needs congruent with those highlighted in the
literature and also focused on the participants’ needs as identi-
fied in initial assessments. The specific ADL skills intervention
focused on the following areas: safety planning, drug and alco-
hol awareness, safe sex practices, assertiveness and advocacy
skill training, anger management, stress management, boundary
establishment and limit-setting, vocational and educational skill
training, money management, housing application, leisure ex-
ploration and hygiene, medication routine and nutrition. Par-
ticipants received intervention for one hour per week over the
course of 6 months via group and one-to-one sessions provided
by four OT students who were supervised by two OTs.
An analysis of the strengths and weaknesses of the study re-
veals several methodological shortcomings. Specifically, co-in-
terventions may have been present because some of the partici-
pants were living in local shelters, where they may have recei-
ved other similar life skills programs. Also, the assessment tools
utilized to determine if participants increased their knowledge
were not validated nor psychometrically tested for reliability
and validity. Strengths of this research include the utilization of
a mixed-method approach with qualitative and quantitative data
collection, which increases internal validity via methodological
triangulation. Triangulation of multiple data sources (background
Methodological quality indicators fo r reviewed stu di es .
Gutman et al.
(2004) Helfrich &
Avileo (200 1 ) McFarlaneet al.
Study purpose :
Stated clearly? yes yes yes
reviewed? yes yes yes
Type? BA BA RCT
Appropriate? yes yes yes
Sample detailed? yes yes yes
Sample justified? yes no yes
Jadad Score N/A N/A 3
Reliable? yes no yes
Valid? yes no yes
Described in de t ail? yes yes yes
Contamina tion avoided? N/A N/A no
Co-interve ntion avoi ded? no no no
Reported w it h Stat. Sig.? yes no yes
Analysis appropriate? yes no yes
reported? yes yes yes
Drop-outs reported? no no yes
Conclusions appropriate? Yes Unclear Yes
Methodological qua lity weak weak weak
literature, the thematic analysis and the data mining results)
strengthens the identification of patterns within the phenomena
being examined (Denzin & L inc oln , 1994).
Gutman et al. (2004) utilized the Goal Attainment Scales
F. LOPASCHUK ET AL.
(GAS) (Kiresuk & Sherman, 1968) for pre- and post-tests, chart
reviews, occupational therapy student logs and a review of
progress notes in the medical record. The use of GAS was ap-
propriate, because this criterion-referenced measure allows the
researcher to quantify specific changes in behaviours and to de-
tect small changes over time (Ottenbacher & Cusick, 1993).
Statistical analysis was also appropriate for this study. Gutman
et al. (2004) performed a t test by converting the raw scores
from the GAS into a standardized T score. The t test is useful
because it can be applied to a small sample size in order to infer
treatment effectiveness (Law, 2008). The results suggest a high
level of success in attaining goals. Based on the methodologies
used and valid outcome measures, this study has an acceptable
level of internal validity.
Study 2: Helfrich and Rivera (2006) studied a vocational pro-
gram for women who had left relationships with IPV for the
safety of an emergency shelter. Their life skills intervention fo-
cused on enhancing employment knowledge and skills. The
researchers utilizing a before and after research design and pre
and post self-assessment.
The sample consisted of only 11 women, and the process of
sample recruitment and the consent process are not clear from
the report. It also appears that participants were not necessarily
aware they were involved in a research study as opposed to the
routine interventions offered at the shelter. Additionally, the
sample size was not justified, no power calculation was pro-
vided, and only anecdotal results were reported with no statis-
tical analysis provided. Intervention consisted of 8 sessions of 4
weeks in duration, via group and one-to-one sessions. Trans-
parency in the intervention process was poor. According to
Siebes et al. (2007), transparency is comprised of both open-
ness and accountability, and all parties involved should have
been clear on the identified occupational performance issues, the
treatment process, activities and goals. Upon program comple-
tion, participants voiced frustration with the facilitators’ inabil-
ity to secure employment for them. Attendance to the program
was inconsistent and attrition was not addressed. Other possible
methodological shortcomings were that while pre/post-test self-
assessments and weekly quizzes were administered to deter-
mine knowledge retention, validity of these assessments and
quizzes was not presented, and no standardized, quantifiable
measures of change were employed. Secondly, statistical analy-
sis of these outcome measures was not conducted to infer treat-
ment effecttiveness, nor was this discussed in the results section.
Additionally, the group leader and the recorder alternated
weekly, creating possible bias resulting from experimenter
expectancies and attention bias. Finally, co-intervention was
possible since participants likely attended other required pro-
grams at the shelter on other aspects of life skills. No mention
of control for this was made in the paper.
While it may be feasible to repeat these types of intervene-
tions in other primary care settings, Helfrich and Rivera’s re-
port raises the point that IPV victims often require a multidi-
mensional approach from the community, as women living in
emergency shelter may have different needs than women living
in transitional housing. While this study concluded that the
intervention was effective, the limitations presented in the re-
search methods reduce the trustworthiness of this article.
Study 3: McFarlane et al., (2002) conducted a Randomized
Control Trial (RCT) to determine the effectiveness of a tele-
phone intervention promoting safety behaviours for victims of
IPV. This paper utilizes two conceptual models to guide an 18-
month clinical trial. A power analysis was conducted to ensure
statistical power, and 150 participants agreed to participate in
this study. A systematic allocation of 75 women in the control
group and 75 women in the treatment group was utilized to pre-
vent sampling bias. When the researchers calculated descriptive
statistics for study variables they found no significant demo-
graphic differences between groups with the exception of age,
which they then treated as a covariate in further analysis where
they found age did not to affect the outcome measure. This stu-
dy also employs Safety Behaviour Checklist, a measure previ-
ously used by the study authors (McFarlane & Parker, 1994).
The author stated the measure had been tested and proven ef-
fective, but no psychometric data were reported.
Six intervention phone calls were provided for the treatment
group, where the investigator discussed specific safety-promot-
ing behaviours. Paired t test and Repeated Measures of Analy-
sis of Variance were conducted to calculate any differences in
knowledge retention between the two study groups. This paper
reported that participants from the intervention group practiced
a significantly higher number of safety behaviours after 3 and 6
months. There was an excellent retention rate: only one par-
ticipant from the control group was unable to complete the pro-
gram due to suicide. This study scored a 3/5 on the Jadad scale
as neither the participants, nor those workers providing inter-
vention, were blind to the group allocation.
In general all three studies were methodologically weak, non-
replicable, and the results therefore not strongly reliable. Also,
none of the studies evaluated the potential harms of the inter-
ventions provided. Consequently it remains unclear how these
intervention affect women who may still be involved in violent
According to Gill and Brown (2009: p. 214), “Rehabilitation
has a theoretical groundin g directly addressing people’s need for
empowerment to assume active self-management of their health
and control over their living environment.” Much has been
learned about the epidemiology of violence against women, but
information on evidence-based approaches in developing reha-
bilitation intervention programs is still severely lacking. Heal-
thcare providers who focus on function and daily activity, like
occupational therapists for example, can play a critical role for
victims of IPV by enhancing their ability to perform ADL. Re-
searchers have identified the promotion of women’s emotional
and physical functioning as key in supporting women in the
development of coping and leaving strategies (Cage, 2007).
Further high level, high quality research into specific skill inter-
ventions programs concerning ADL areas, not limited to par-
enting, budgeting and vocational skills is recommended. Other
areas of research worth exploring include education and aware-
ness training for occupational therapists and students, so they
can better address occupational dysfunction for victims of IPV.
Although there is a scarcity of studies concerning the effec-
tiveness of ADL intervention for victims of IPV, this critical re-
view demonstrates that there are some pioneering studies avai-
lable. The preceding critique and discussion synthesizes key
findings from the literature concerning the interventions of sa-
fety planning and vocational counseling. These two areas of in-
tervention, although being the most widely addressed in the stu-
dies reviewed, demonstrated limited evidence of effectiveness.
Copyright © 2012 SciRes.
F. LOPASCHUK ET AL.
This finding is also consistent with Gorde et al.’s (2004) study,
which concludes that female survivors prioritize independence
and productivity over other concerns. The following discussion
gives more detailed examples of how these two areas were
operationalized within the studies.
Intervention 1: Safety Planning
Safety planning was a key component in both the Gutman et
al. (2004) and MacFarlane et al. (2002) studies. Participants were
taught strategies such as identifying signs of escalating violence,
safe locations, and important documents to take when fleeing
abuse. Other strategies included hiding money, maintaining a
safety bag in a discreet location, developing a code for use with
family and friends to signal need for assistance, and removing
and disposing of weapons in the house.
Intervention 2: Vocational Counseling
Vocational counseling was discussed in Gutman et al. (2004)
and Helfrich and Rivera’s (2006) papers. Topics in this area
generally include identifying possible careers of interest, ex-
ploring vocational training and/or educational options, resume
and cover letter writing and in terview preparation .
Research exploring the effectiveness of ADL interventions
for victims of IPV is promising but very much in its early
stages. This structured scoping and critical analysis of existing
outcome studies demonstrates that current programs in the
community operate despite the current lack of methodologically
sound and reliable evidence of their effectiveness. The follow-
ing are the key messages from the critical review findings:
There is an urgent need for higher quality research on the
usefulness of skills intervention for victims of IPV.
There is some limited evidence suggesting that interventions
in the areas of self-care and productivity are useful skills
and knowledge for victims of IPV. These findings are con-
sistent with Kimerling et al.’s (2009), conclusion that fur-
ther studies on employment programs for victims of IPV are
The background literature demonstrates that healthcare pro-
viders have theoretical constructs (like occupational perform-
ance) that could address life skills and ADL issues for women
who are affected by the trauma of domestic violence (Johnston,
Adams, & Helfrich, 2001). However, existing evidence is very
scant and of insufficient quality to evaluate the effectiveness of
ADL interventions for victims of IPV. Of all relevant studies
reviewed, only McFarlane et al.’s (2002) study approached mo-
derate methodological quality and potentially demonstrated a
positive relationship between ADL training and positive out-
comes. The other studies reviewed offer some limited evidence
suggesting that other IADL interventions may also demonstrate
successful outcomes for women who experience IPV. It is im-
portant to reiterate that there is an urgent need for high quality
research on the usefulness of life skills interventions for victims
of IPV. Clinicians should carefully scrutinize the evidence-base
available and work with researchers to build methodologically
robust research to inform practice when serving the victims of
Bonomi, A. E., Anderson, M. L., Rivara, F. P., & Thompson, R. S.
(2007). Health outcomes in women with physical and sexual intimate
partner violence exposure. Journal of Women’s Health, 16, 987-997.
Brown, C. (2009). Functional assessment and intervention in occupa-
tional therapy. Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal, 32 , 162-170.
Busch, N. B., & Wolfer, T. A. (2002). Battered women speak out:
Welfare reform and their decisions to disclose. Violence against Wo-
men, 8, 566-584. doi:10.1177/107780102400388434
Cage, A. (2007). Occupational therapy with women and children sur-
vivors of domestic violence: Are we fulfilling our activist heritage?
A review of the literature. British Journal of Occupational Therapy,
Campbell, J. C. (2002). Health consequences of intimate partner vio-
lence. Lancet, 359, 1331- 1336. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(02)08336-8
Campbell, J., Jones, A. S., Dienemann, J., Kub, J., Schollenberger, J.,
O'Campo, P. et al. (2002). Intimate partner violence and physical
health consequences. Archives of Internal Medicine, 162, 1157-1163.
Canadian Association of Occupational Therapists. (2007). Enabling
occupation II: Advancing an occupational therapy vision for health,
well-being, & justice through occupation. Ottawa, Ontario: CAOT
Casanueva, C., Foshee, V. A., & Barth, R. P. (2005). Intimate partner
violence as a risk factor for children’s use of emergency room and
injuries. Children and Youth Service s Review, 27, 1123- 1242.
Casteel, C., & Sadowski, L. (2009). What are the effects of interven-
tions initiated by healthcare professionals aimed at women victims of
intimate partner vi o l en c e? Clinical Evidence, 2, 1013-1030.
Denzin, N. K., & Y. S. Lincoln (1994). Handbook of qualitative re-
search. London, Sage Publications.
Forte, T., Cohen, M. M., Du Mont, J., Hyman, I., & Omans, S. (2005).
Psychological and physical sequelae of intimate partner violence
among women with limitations in their activities of daily living. Ar-
chives of Women's Mental Health, 8, 248-256.
Gill, J. R., & Brown, C. A. (2009). A structured review of the evidence
for pacing as a chronic pain intervention. European Journal of Pain,
13, 214-216. doi:10.1016/j.ejpain.2008.03.011
Gorde, M. W., Helfrich, C. A., & Finlayson, M. L. (2004). Trauma
symptoms and life skill needs of domestic violence victims. Journal
of Interpersonal Violence, 19, 691-708.
Gutman, S. A., Diamond, H., Holness-Parchment, S., Brandofino, D. N.,
Pacheco, D. G., Jolly-Edouard, M. et al. (2004). Enhancing inde-
pendence in women experiencing domestic violence and possible
brain injury: An assessment of an occupational therapy intervention.
Occupational Therapy in Mental Health, 20, 49-79.
Hazen, A. L., Connelly, C. D., Kelleher, K. J., Barth, R. P., & Lands-
verk, J. A. (2006) . Female caregi ve rs’ experiences with intimate part-
ner violence and behavior problems in children investigated as vic-
tims of maltreatment. Pediatrics, 117, 99-109.
Helfrich, C. A., & Aviles, A. (2001). Occupational therapy’s role with
victims of domestic violence: Assessment and intervention. Occupa-
tional Therapy in Mental H e a l t h , 16, 53-57.
Helfrich, C. A., Aviles, A. M., Badiani, C., Walens, D., & Sabol, P.
(2006). Life skill interventions with homeless youth, domestic vio-
lence victims and adults with mental illness. Occupational Therapy
in Health Care, 20, 189-207. 0.
Helfrich, C. A., & Rivera, Y. (2006). Employment skills and domestic
violence survivors: A shelter-based intervention. Occupational The-
rapy in Mental Health, 22, 33-48. doi:10.1300/J004v22n01_03
Ireland, T. O., & Smith, C. A. (2009). Living in partner-violent families:
Developmental links to antisocial behavior and relationship violence.
Copyright © 2012 SciRes. 35
F. LOPASCHUK ET AL.
Copyright © 2012 SciRes.
Journal of Youth & Adolescence, 38, 323-339.
Jadad, A. R., Moore, R. A., Carroll, D., Jenkinson, C., Reynolds, D. J.,
Gavaghan, D. J. et al. (1996). Assessing the quality of reports of
randomized clinical trials: Is blinding necessary? Controlled Clinical
Trials, 17, 1-12. doi:10.1016/0197-2456(95)00134-4
Javaherian, H. A., Underwood, R. T., & DeLany, J. V. (2007). Occupa-
tional therapy services for individuals who have experienced domes-
tic violence (statement). American Journal of Occupational Therapy,
61, 704-709. doi:10.5014/ajot.61.6.704
Johnston, J. L., Adams, R., & Helfrich, C. A. (2001). Knowledge and
attitudes of occupational therapy practitioners regarding wife abuse.
Occupational Therapy in Mental Health, 16, 35-52.
Katz, L. F., Hunter, E., & Klowden, A. (2008). Intimate partner violence
and children’s reaction to peer provocation: The moderating role of
emotion coaching. Jou r n a l o f Family Psychology, 22, 614-621.
Kiresuk, T. J., & Sherman, R. E., (1968) Goal attainment scaling: A ge-
neral method for evaluating c omprehensive comm u ni t y mental health
programs. Community Mental Health Journal, 4, 443-453.
Kimerling, R., Alvarez, J., Pavao, J., Mack, K. P., Smith, M. W., &
Baumrind, N. (2009). Unemployment among women: Examining the
relationship of physical and psychological intimate partner violence
and posttraumatic stress disorder. Journal of Interpersonal Violence,
24, 450-463. doi:10.1177/0886260508317191
Krane, J., & Davies, L. (2007). Mothering under difficult circumstances:
Challenges to working with battered women. Journal of Women &
Social Work, 22, 23-38.
Krug, E. G., Dahlberg, L. L., Mercy, J. A., Zwi, A. B. & Lozano, R.,
(Eds.) (2002). World report on violence and health. Geneva: World
Lang, J. M., & Stover, C. S. (2008). Symptom patterns among youth
exposed to intimate partner violence. Journal of Family Violence, 23,
Law, M. C. (Ed.). (2008). Evidence-based rehabilitation: A guide to
practice (2nd ed.). Thorofare, NJ: Slake.
McFarlane, J. & Parker, B. (1994). Abuse during pregnancy. A protocol
for prevention and intervention. New York: National March of Dimes
Birth Defects Foundation.
McFarlane, J., Malecha, A ., Gist, J., Watson, K., Batten, E., Hall, I., et
al. (2002). An intervention to increase safety behaviors of abused
women: Results of a randomized clinical trial. Nursing Research, 51,
Mcnutt, L., Carlson, B. E., Persaud, M., & Postmus, J. (2002). Cumula-
tive abuse experiences, physical health and health behaviors. Annals
of Epidemiology, 12, 123-130. doi:10.1016/S1047-2797(01)00243-5
Mechanic, M. B., Weaver, T. L., & Resick, P. A. (2008). Risk factors
for physical injury among help-seeking battered women: An explora-
tion of multiple abuse di mensions. Violence against Women , 14, 1148-
Olivas-De La O, T. (2008). Perspectives. OT saved my life: Surviving
domestic violence. OT Practice, 13, 23-24.
Ottenbacher, K. J., & Cusick, A. (1993). Discriminative versus evalua-
tive assessment: Some observations on goal attainment scaling. Ame-
rican Journal of Occupational Therapy, 47, 349-354.
Plichta, S. B. (2004). Intimate partner violence and physical health
consequences: Policy and practice implications. Journal of Interper-
sonal Violence, 19, 1296-1323. doi:10.1177/0886260504269685
Public Health Agency of Canada. (2009). What is intimate partner
violence. URL (last checked 10 December 2011).
Siebes, R. C., Ketelaar, M., Go rter, J. W., Wijnroks, L., De Blécourt, A.,
Reinders-Messelink, H. et al. (2007). Transparency and tuning of re-
habilitation care for children with cerebral palsy: A multiple case
study in five children with complex needs. Developmental Neurore-
habilitation, 10, 193-204. doi:10.1080/13638490601104405
Spangaro, J. M., Zwi, A. B., Poulos, R. G., & Man, W. Y. (2010) Who
tells and what happened: Disclosure and health service responses to
screening for intimate partner violence. Health and Social Care in
the Community, 18, 671-680. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2524.2010.00943.x
Statistic Canada. (2005). Family violence in Canada: A statistical pro-
file, 2005 (No. 85-224-XIE). URL (last checked 10 December 2011).
Statistic Canada. (1994). Wife assault: The findings of a national sur-
vey. URL (last checked 10 December 2011).
Statistic Canada. (2008). Family violence in Canada: A statistical pro-
file, 2008 (No. 85-224-X). URL (last checked 12 November 2011).
Suglia, S. F., Enlow, M. B., Kullowatz, A., & Wright, R. J. (2009).
Maternal intimate partner violence and increased asthma incidence in
children: Buffering effects of supportive caregiving. Archives of Pe-
diatrics & Adolescent M e dicine, 163, 244-250.
Taylor, C. A., Guterman, N. B., Lee, S. J., & Rathouz, P. J. (2009).
Intimate partner violence, maternal stress, nativity, and risk for ma-
ternal maltreatment of young children. American Journal of Public
Health, 99, 175-183. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2007.126722
Wathen, C. N., & MacMillan, H. L. (2003). Interventions for violence
against women: Scientific review. The Journal of the American Me-
dical Association, 289, 589-600. doi:10.1001/jama.289.5.589
Woods, S. J., Hall, R. J., Campbell, J. C., & Angott, D. M. (2008). Phy-
sical health and posttraumatic stress disorder symptoms in women
experiencing intimate partner violence. Journal of Midwifery and
Women’s Health, 53, 538-546. doi:10.1016/j.jmwh.2008.07.004
Wuest, J., Merritt-Gray, M., Ford-Gilboe, M., Lent, B., Varcoe, C., &
Campbell, J. C. (2008). Chronic pain in women survivors of intimate
partner violence. Journal of Pain, 9, 1049-1057.