Argentina annually utilizes 240,000 tones of glyphosate in industrial agriculture and a change in the profile of morbidity is perceived for physicians of agricultural areas; now reproductive disorders seem to prevail. The objective of this study is to determine concurrence of glyphosate exposure and reproductive disorders in a typical argentine agricultural town (Monte Maíz). An ecological study was developed with an environmental analysis of pollution sources including measurements of glyphosate and other pesticides and a cross-sectional study of spontaneous abortions and congenital abnormalities prevalence. Glyphosate was detected in soil and grain dust and was found to be at an even higher concentration in the village soil than in the rural area; 650 tonnes of glyphosate are used annually in the region and manipulated inner town contaminating the soil and dust in suspension of the town creating an burden of environmental exposure to glyphosate of 79 kg per person per year. We do not find other relevant sources of pollution. The spontaneous abortion and congenital abnormalities rates are three and two times higher than the national average reported by the national health (10% vs. 3% and 3% - 4.3% vs 1.4% respectively). Our study verified high environmental exposure to glyphosate in association with increased frequencies of reproductive disorders (spontaneous abortion and congenital abnormalities) in argentine agricultural village, but is unable to make assertions cause-effect. Further studies are required with designs for such purposes.
In 1996, Argentina began to grow genetically modified (GM) seeds, and used currently 25 million hectares where 12 million people live; these crops have generated a substantial increase in the pesticide consumption. In 2013, Argentina sprayed 240,000 tons of Glyphosate [
An exploratory ecological study on reproductive disorders and environmental pollution was performed, consisting on the one hand of an epidemiological study (a cross-sectional study) with a household survey of health addressed to the entire population (population survey), designed to geo-reference each record in the village with use of nine ratios census (R) by National Institute Census that divide the town into nine sectors outweighed demographically as seen in the map of
spontaneous or unexplained abortion on the last 5 years and with 5 or more years of living in Monte Maíz) and congenital abnormalities prevalence (children with major congenital abnormalities alive at the time of the interview), these were dependent variables, while sex, age, occupation, stay in the village, smoke, ratio census residence, educational level and the presence of environmental contaminants were the independent variables. On the other hand, an environmental analysis recording sources of contamination such as landfills, cell site (cell tower), electric power transformers, industrial sites, stockpiles of grains, storehouses of pesticides, and spraying machines. We interviewed community and government stakeholders, business owners, city officials, teachers, farmers and workers that sprayed pesticides, in order to recognize the performance of industries, local public services, and agribusiness (drinking water, sewer management, household waste, industries pollutions, routines and doses of pesticides use). Samples of environmental matrices (water, soil, grain husks) were collected and analyzed by the Center for Environmental Research, Faculty of Exact Sciences of National University of La Plata, which selected twelve internal and peripheral sites in the town to examine the presence of glyphosate, its metabolite aminomethylphosphonic acid (AMPA), and currently used pesticides (chlorpyrifos, endosulfan, cipermetrina, atrazine, 2.4D, and epoxiconazole). Both pretreatment and analysis of pesticides were performed under international regulations using liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry [
The study area was Monte Maíz, a town located on Provincial Route N˚11', 33˚12' South latitude and 62˚36' West longitude of Greenwich, at a height above sea level of 114 metres; the town is 113 years old and has 7788 inhabitants (8045 including residents of surrounding rural areas). Agriculture is the main economic activity with complementary metalworking industry that is located on the Southern edge of the town [
Crude rates were obtained through a database and numerical matrix, a bivariate correlation Pearson analysis was conducted to assess the association of spontaneous abortions and congenital abnormalities with independent variables, included the spatial distribution according to ratios census in which the town was divided (R09-R18). We built maps for spontaneous abortions and congenital abnormalities and pollution sources using Quantum GIS 2.4 software and created contingency tables to perform relational measurements between exposure and disease. For this end, the following software was used: INFOSTAT (UNC), SPSS, and EPIDAT (PAHO). Rates of spontaneous abortions and congenital abnormalities of Monte Maíz were compared with the national rates reported by the National Registry of Congenital Abnormalities (RENAC) of the National Health Ministry [
Physicians or medical students carried out the fieldwork during October 2014; all health surveys were conducted by final year medicine students of UNC and medical professors. The study was conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki and under the framework of Act 9694 Article 2 of the Province of Cordoba in accordance with the law regulating health research and was approved by the Bioethics Committee established by this law for observational studies [
In Monte Maíz the electrical network is powered by medium-voltage power distributed in the urban area, with substations of 33 kV to 380 w, no high voltage. Has a sewer system with a domestic collection network reaching every home; solid urban waste is collected by a municipal service that has a Solid Waste plant. Their hinterland has soybeans on 45,000 ha and maize on 20,000 ha which are main summer crops and wheat on 15,000 ha as a winter crop. We identified an open landfill, 800 meters northeast of the town’s limit, with no evidence of fire in the last 5 years. There is an absence of forestry across the periphery of the town, which is replaced by soybean and maize crops, starting at the immediate edge of houses. These crops are frequently treated, with pesticide, by ground equipment and crop dusters. At the southwest of Monte Maíz, we found two livestock breeding farms, and, on the west side, a flood zone, with ponds, a park, and a sewage treatment plant between the crop fields.
There are two farm equipment industries, located at the southern tip of the town; these factories use methane gas as a source of energy. The sources of electromagnetic radiation were two cellphone towers, located in R9 and R12 which are highlighted on the map of pollution factors on Monte Maíz in
Local agronomists and agrochemical applicators report that in Monte Maíz GM soybean and corn crops use 10 kilograms of glyphosate per ha per year. Six hundred and fifty tonnes of glyphosate are aerosolized in the area, creating a general burden of environmental exposure to glyphosate of 79 kg per person per year, which varies for agricultural or non-agricultural activity and for spatial distribution of glyphosate. This region utilizes nine hundred seventy five tonnes of all pesticides each year.
Herbicide glyphosate and AMPA was detected in 100% samples of soil and husk. In grain husks from silos, glyphosate and AMPA prevailed (505 and 607 ppb), followed by chlorpyrifos (14 ppb) and epoxiconazole (2.3 ppb) as shown in
Glyphosate also had the highest concentrations among all the matrices studied (3868 ppb), exceeding by far the other pesticides: endosulfan II (337.7 ppb) and chlorpyrifos (242 ppb) (see
Overall, 92% households were visited, 4.8% corresponds to households that refused to answer the survey. Some houses were uninhabited at the time of the visit. The information was collected from 4859 people (62% of the population), its characteristics are available in
98 spontaneous abortions occurred in the last 5 years among 981 surveyed women of reproductive age; 62 of them had only one event, 15 had two, and 2 of them had three abortions, a unintended abortions prevalence rate of 10% per 100 women of reproductive age; 79 women among 981 were those who suffered spontaneous abortions (8%).
Among the population studied there were 853 births in the last 10 years, 25 children presented major congenital abnormalities and were alive at the time of the study (four abnormalities of nervous system, five genitals, four limbs, three renal and urinary, two digestive, four cardiopathies and one biliary atresia, cleft lip and thyroglossal cyst), a prevalence rate of 3% (
S: Site sampling | Glifosato | AMPA | 2.4 D | Atrazina | Clorpirifos | Endosulfan I | Endosulfan II | Cipermetrina | Epoxiconazol |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
S1 drinking water network | <2 ppb | <2 ppb | <1 ppb | <0.5 ppb | DNC | DNC | DNC | <0.005 ppb | <0.005 ppb |
S5 crop field soil | 41 ppb | 116 ppb | <5 ppb | 6.4 ppb | 242 ppb | <1.5 ppb | 2.2 ppb | 58 ppb | 3 ppb |
S6 children’s playground soil | 2792 ppb | 797 ppb | S/D | S/D | 4.4 ppb | <1.5 ppb | <1.5 ppb | 4 ppb | 3.4 ppb |
S6 children’s playground grain husks from silos | 505 ppb | 607 ppb | S/D | S/D | 14 ppb | DNC | <1.5 ppb | DNC | 2.3 ppb |
S8 pesticides deposits soil | 3868 ppb | 3192 ppb | 128 ppb | 52.5 ppb | 150.4 ppb | 17.5 ppb | 338 ppb | 180 ppb | 6.3 ppb |
Characteristics | Magnitude |
---|---|
Number of individuals recorded | 4959 (61.98%) |
Male | 2361 (47.61%) |
Female | 2597 (52.37%) |
Average age of Population | 36.03 years |
People 0 - 15 years | 1175 (23.69%) |
People ≥16 years with complete primary education | 3313/3744 (88.49%) |
People with health insurance | 3859 (78.01%) |
Percentage of people with ≥5 years residence time | 4141/4328 (95.68%) |
Families of rural workers, farmers and agronomists | 270 families, 970 persons |
Smokers | 793/3780 (20.98%) |
Reproductive Impacts | Number of cases | Rate |
---|---|---|
Spontaneous abortions | 98/981 | 10% |
Women with spontaneous abortions | 79/981 | 8% |
Congenital abnormalities alive | 25/853 | 3% |
Congenital abnormalities total estimate | 40/853 | 4,7% |
malformed children who died during this period. Including the dead (calculated in twelve cases) the rate of congenital anomalies would reach 4.3% because the WHO estimates a congenital anomalies mortality of 40% in ten years [
Spontaneous abortions shown correlate with young women and women living in R16 and R17 with a significance of 0.05%, these radiuses (R) are the ones blown by the wind coming from where are the cereal stores. Congenital abnormalities showed no significant correlation with independent variables.
Association levels were measured as occurrence rate (ORs) arising from contingency tables (2 × 2); the OR for spontaneous abortions in women from Radius 16 and Radius 17 with respect to other Radius was 1.29 (CI 0.71 - 2.34) with a non significant p-value, so that despite the existence of apparent risk of abortion in those areas, the presence of bias could not be excluded.
Seeds that are genetically manipulated to contain a transgene have the ability to survive in saturated environments with glyphosate, an herbicide used to eradicate other plants. Glyphosate interferes with the vital metabolism of plants, but not with transgenic plants for which an alternative metabolic pathway was generated through bioengineering. Since 1996, when GM soy was introduced in Argentina, its use has continued to expand due to the high profit generated by its commercialization and easy harvest [
Monte Maíz shows the effects of this agricultural model, as is a production boom in the region, a high standard of living among its population, and the relocation of local farmers in the village; these farmers left rural areas and moved with their families work equipment and supplies. Deposits of agricultural equipment are multiplying inside the village (twenty-two in total), the largest deposits in town are in R15 and are five pesticide storage sites. A total of 650 tons of glyphosate per year is concentrated, manipulated and has surrounded the town, which now faces fields that are sprayed daily. Glyphosate was found in 100% of soil and husk dust samples, the concentration was 10 times higher than that of other pesticides, this demonstrates that, of all pesticides that pollute the environment, glyphosate is the most prevalent. Concentrations found in inner town are several times higher than in the soil in cultivated fields (see table 1), reaffirming the impression that the town is at the operational center of the sprayed area. Glyphosate is also high in grain dust, it is also accompanied by other pesticides their joint presence discards that glyphosate is high within the village due to its use in gardening.
In metalwork factories, no significant pollution was found; the density per km2 of the source of electromagnetic radiation such as cell site, high voltage power lines, and electrical voltage transformers is low compared with source electromagnetic radiation density in big cities, which minimizes the value of this pollution; for example Nueva Cordoba, a neighborhood of Cordoba city, which is located on the same surface as Monte Maíz with a larger population, has nine cell sites, while there are only two towers in Monte Maíz [
Moreover, household garbage management, sewage, and contaminant-free water (for 16 years now) remove these contaminating factors from the observed pathologies. Thus, pollution with glyphosate and to a lesser extent with other pesticides is the predominant factor in the environmental contamination analysis of Monte Maíz.
The rate of spontaneous abortions in five years (10%) in Monte Maíz was three times higher than that reported in a national analysis conducted in 2005 for the National Health Ministry (0.6% per year) [
There seems to be a clear link between exposure to pesticides, including glyphosate, and pregnancy loss, similar to the observations made by Settini in Italy [
On the other hand, the National Registry of Congenital Abnormalities of Argentina (RENAC) in 2014 Report that between 281.249 newborns a total of 4.120 major structural congenital abnormalities were recorded, with a prevalence of 1.4% [
In 2010 Paganelli demonstrates as glyphosate-based herbicides produce teratogenic effects on vertebrates by impairing retinoic acid signaling [
The Monograph Working Group of IARC-WHO in Evaluation of Carcinogenic Risks to Humans in 2015 reviews 1000 studies on glyphosate and chooses 200 relevant paper to conclude that there is strong evidence that exposure to glyphosate or glyphosate-based formulations is genotoxic based on studies in humans in vitro and studies in experimental animals [
This association is consistent with respect to abortions and malformations, the biological plausibility is very rational for reproductive problems in their causal link with 600,000 kg of glyphosate polluting the environment of Monte Maiz, although recognize that the ecological fallacy cannot be discarded from this analysis and the design of this study is limited for causality. The change in time sequence could not be stated in this cross-sectional study, but local doctors noted changes in the disease profile since the introduction of GM seeds and the massive use of glyphosate. Although the methodological limitations of this exploration suggest that we acknowledge its limited scope, it highlights the association at an evidence level and should be considered with caution given the small size of the population, the self-referenced nature of the survey and the descriptive modality of the study. The resultsofthis study arealso important because they describe a health problem in the environment where the people are living.
This research detected an urban environment severely polluted by glyphosate and other pesticides with high environmental exposure to glyphosate in the villagers and identified elevated frequencies of congenital abnormalities and spontaneous abortion, suggesting a link between environmental exposure to glyphosate and reproductive problems, although this was an exploratory and observational design unable to make direct causal assertions. However, from the point of view of collective health, this link requires recommending the precautionary application of measures to protect the population from this environmental exposure.
To SUMA 400 Program, Secretary of University Extension from UNC that made it possible to travel with a team of 70 people to Monte Maíz. To the Municipality of Monte Maíz, that facilitated the stay of our team during the 5-day field work. To the professors and students of Medicine and Geography from UN, to the professors and students of Chemistry from the Faculty of Naturals and Exact Sciences of National University of La Plata, that conducted the chemical field work at Monte Maiz. And to “Ayni Translations” who carried out the translation of the Spanish original to English.
The authors declare they have no actual or potential competing financial interests.
Avila-Vazquez, M., Difilippo, F.S., Lean, B.M., Maturano, E. and Etchegoyen, A. (2018) Environmental Exposure to Glyphosate and Reproductive Health Impacts in Agricultural Population of Argentina. Journal of Environmental Protection, 9, 241-253. https://doi.org/10.4236/jep.2018.93016