In the background of incubation network, the paper studies how incubated enterprises gain cognitive social capital through embedding in the network, obtain intangible resources effectively in the resource-sharing environment and improve their innovation performance. We construct and analyze the theoretical model of cognitive social capital, intangible resource acquisition and innovation performance. The incubated enterprises need to strengthen cognitive social capital accumulation through incubation network; it effects the ability of intangible resource acquisition, then helps start-ups improve innovation performance.
With the development of new round industrial revolution, especially the rapid growth of the Internet innovation, “mass entrepreneurship and innovation” is promoted to the new height as one of the “double engines”, which gives impetus to the economy transformation and guarantees the economy growth. As a bridge between source of knowledge innovation and high-biotechnological industries, meanwhile the platform of cultivating independent innovation enterprises and entrepreneurs, science and technology business incubator plays a vital role in decreasing the risk of entrepreneurship, promoting the incubation and industrialization of high-tech achievements. But a single incubator can’t provide diverse incubation resources, thus it should communicate and cooperate with others through networking. Incubators become the medium that connecting incubated enterprises and external environment, forming an incubation network in which the core is incubators and incubated enterprises, the auxiliary support is relevant external subjects such as universities, research institutions, intermediary institutions, investment and financing institutions.
By offering incubated enterprises and relevant external subjects a circumstance to build constant communication and cooperation [
According to the Resource Based Theory, the resource demand of incubated enterprises can be divided into two categories, that is tangible and intangible resources, in which the valuable, scarce and irreplaceable intangible resources are more important in the formation of the core competitiveness. Compared to tangible resources such as capital, equipment and factory, intangible resources have no obvious material carrier, mainly refer to technology, knowledge, information, ability and other elements which embedded in a series of products and services [
Incubation network is a typical kind of network organization which consists all kinds of actors who have common development strategic objectives. Anne and Jones point out that the generalized incubation network including multiple incubators and actors [
Social capital is a series of actual and potential resources embedded in social networks, which can be contacted or acquired by individuals or social units [
The incubated enterprises are faced with the initial lack of resources; they need to obtain resources from outside to make up for these deficiencies. Intangible resources are difficult to identify, the cost of being used or imitated by other competitors is high. Incubated enterprises should occupy intangible resources in time, and that can favor them to discover new opportunities in the innovative environment, help to identify and eliminate threats [
At the early stage of incubation, the key point is how to establish the core products according to existed resources and market demand. Therefore, incubated enterprises’ innovation performance mainly reflects the ability of product innovation, that is the ability which they use to follow market orientation, reallocate their own resources, apply new technology rationally, then launch more abundant or more functional products and services. The innovation ability of incubated enterprises is related to the development of new products, technology reform or transfer, which determines the products market development ability, cost level and technical level, and have a direct impact on innovation performance.
According to the main contents about product innovation ability of incubated enterprises, we select indexes to measure it from two aspects: innovation effect and innovation efficiency. Innovation effect studies the degree of innovation success of incubated enterprises, including the measurement of technology development, that is the number of patent technology, independent intellectual property rights, and the investigation of market sales, new product market share and product acceptance rate. Innovation efficiency is to examine input-output ratio in the process of enterprises’ innovation, that is, whether the effort made for the success of innovation is effective or not, including conversion rate of scientific and technological achievements, rate of new product development and of success [
The cooperation relationship which based on the common understanding can promote network subjects to form complementary resource pattern, benefits from identifying and exchanging of resources that are proprietary, complex and non-encoding recessive, then improve the ability of innovation and cooperation.
Network subjects are under the guidance of incubators, they tolerate multi-culture to form a uniform network behavior standard and value criterion, further enhance network cohesion and the quality of innovation cooperation. The similar thought of different network subjects on the same situation means that they have no difficulty in understanding and communicating mutually, it is easy to identify partners’ demands and give effective assistance, form the atmosphere helpful to the innovation and growth of incubated enterprises.
Shared vision reflects the willingness of different network subjects to share goals; it is a governance mechanism to reduce opportunism behavior. The innovation process is highly uncertain, and needs to be completed through continuous attempt. Consistent objectives help incubated enterprises to gather potential partners, avoid conflicts raised by goal divergence, to form collaborative innovation cooperation mode and share innovation risk and resources, work together to improve innovation performance [
・ Hypothesis 1. The cognitive social capital has a significant positive effect on the innovation performance of incubated enterprises.
・ Hypothesis 1a. Shared value has a significant positive effect on the innovation performance of incubated enterprises.
・ Hypothesis 1b. Shared vision has a significant positive effect on the innovation performance of incubated enterprises.
Social capital promotes the ability of incubated enterprises to acquire intangible resources, they turn the simple relationship network into a rich network of resources with the accumulation of social capital, and the exchange and transformation of resources with other network subjects can improve their ability of recognition and acquisition of novel and scarce intangible resource [
The cognitive social capital provides incubated enterprises a tool to obtain intangible resources effectively. They need to strengthen the understanding of intangible resources by making use of common cognition, and then realize the effective digestion and absorption of intangible resources. It provides an opportunity for incubated enterprises to deepen cooperation with other subjects, helps effectively resolve conflicts of interests in the process of cooperation, create a harmonious atmosphere of cooperation, promote exchanges of intangible resources [
・ Hypothesis 2. The cognitive social capital has a significant positive effect on the acquisition of intangible resources of incubated enterprises.
・ Hypothesis 2a. Shared value has a significant positive effect on the acquisition of intangible resources of incubated enterprises.
・ Hypothesis 2b. Shared vision has a significant positive effect on the acquisition of intangible resources of incubated enterprises.
Resource environment has a crucial impact on innovation performance. Innovation of incubated enterprises is the process of integrate existing resources and create core products, it requires not only the possession of tangible resources such as funds and goods, but also need to configure the intangible resources which formed from the effective configuration of technical and business support in the incubation network [
Incubated enterprises ought to maintain sensitivity to external information, explore new needs of customers from the market information, find a new breakthrough from technology information, obtain new trend from policy information, access information in the incubation network and analyze them scientifically, accurately grasp innovation opportunity [
Start-ups’ own lack of knowledge accumulation need to be overcame by obtaining knowledge widely from the incubation network, breaking the barriers of technology innovation [
・ Hypothesis 3. The acquisition of intangible resources has a significant positive effect on the innovation performance of incubated enterprises.
・ Hypothesis 3a. The acquisition of intangible resources has a significant positive effect on the innovation effect of incubated enterprises.
・ Hypothesis 3b. The acquisition of intangible resources has a significant positive effect on the innovation efficiency of incubated enterprises.
Lack of intangible resources is the main obstacle to the innovation of start-ups [
・ Hypothesis 4. The acquisition of intangible resource plays an intermediary role in the impact of cognitive social capital on innovation performance.
Based on the above analysis, the theoretical model is shown in
Based on the references, we designed the required items according to existing maturity indicators and scales. It mainly consists of two parts: the basic information of incubated enterprises and the influence of their cognitive social capital on intangible resource acquisition and innovation performance in the incubation network. Investigation of the influence is divided into: 1) cognitive social capital. Based on the research of Nahapiet, cognitive social capital contains 2 indicators: shared value and shared vision, and is measured by 8 items; 2) intangible resource acquisition. Based on the division of intangible resources by Danny [
1) The incubated enterprises need to strengthen cognitive social capital accumulation through incubation network. They should make full use of the cohesion of incubation network, explore valuable innovation points from the frequent communication and interaction with other network subjects, and promote the formation of “sharing economy” model of innovation resources. As the core subjects, incubators should help network members establish shared perception, so that incubated enterprises can select partners and improve the effectiveness of cooperation.
2) Incubated enterprises should make efforts to strengthen the cognition, acquisition and utilization of intangible resources. They need to maintain a high degree of sensitivity to intangible resources in the incubation network, try to internalize external resources, absorb and digest intangible resources in time, so as to better serve innovation. In order to improve the acquisition efficiency of intangible resources, incubated enterprises should make full use of all kinds of resources platforms, such as investment and financing platform, business mentor platform, public service platform and technology platform.
This paper analyzes the static relationship among cognitive social capital, intangible resource acquisition and innovation performance. But the degree of social capital accumulation of incubated enterprises in the network is different according to incubation time. Their innovation process is also dynamic, and the demand for intangible resources is different according to different stages of innovation. Therefore, it is of great significance to further explore the relationship among the social capital of incubated enterprises, intangible resources demand and innovation performance in dynamic evolution process. These issues will be the focus of future research.
Supported by the National Nature Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 71403182). Zhenhua Li and Fuwei Li would like to extend our sincere gratitude to the sponsor of the national conference, for it provides a valuable chance for scholars to communicate in their research area. Second, grateful acknowledge to our research group, both professors and graduate students gave us considerable help by means of suggestion and comments.
This work was supported by the National Nature Science Foundation of China (NSFC) [grant number 71403182].
Li, Z.H. and Li, F.W. (2017) Impact of Incubated Enterprises’ Cognitive Social Capital on Innovation Performance in Incubation Network: Acting through Intangible Resources Acquisition. Open Journal of Social Sciences, 5, 74-83. https://doi.org/10.4236/jss.2017.510007