Background: In 2003 a large-scale HIV prevention program was launched for key populations in six high HIV prevalence states of India. This paper assesses the effect of exposure to the intervention on condom use with commercial clients and experiences of sexually transmitted infection (STI) among female sex workers (FSWs) in Tamilnadu, a southern Indian state, between 2006 and 2009. Methods: Data were drawn from two rounds of cross-sectional surveys conducted in 2006 (N = 2010) and 2009 (N = 2500) among FSWs in Tamilnadu, recruited through probability-based sampling. A series of multivariate logistic regression models were constructed to examine the association between exposure to the intervention and change over time with condom use and self-reported STI. All the analyses were performed using STATA 11.1. Results: Overall, 48% of FSWs in 2006 and 90% in 2009 reported exposure to the intervention. Compared to 2006, there was a considerable increase in the proportion of FSWs reporting consistent condom use with regular and occasional clients at follow-up (2009). Further, the increase in consistent condom use over time with occasional (adjusted OR = 3.53, 95% CI: 2.47 - 5.05) and regular clients (adjusted OR = 4.97, 95% CI: 3.43 - 7.16) was significantly higher among FSWs exposed to the intervention than those not exposed. Additionally, a significant decline was observed in self-reported STI overtime among FSWs exposed to the intervention compared to their counterparts (adjusted OR = 0.39, 95% CI: 0.26 - 0.59). Conclusion: The HIV prevention program in Tamilnadu resulted in increased consistent condom use and a decrease in self-reported STI among FSWs exposed to intervention. These findings suggest that HIV prevention programs should aim to saturate coverage among key populations to sustain the gains achieved.
National adult (15 - 49 years) HIV prevalence in India is estimated at 0.26% (2015) [
In India the HIV epidemic is concentrated among key populations―female sex workers (FSWs), high-risk men who have sex with men/transgender persons (MSM/TG) and injecting drug users (IDUs), and since 1992 the National AIDS Control Organization (NACO) has been implementing targeted interventions for high risk groups and bridge populations to contain the epidemic in the high HIV prevalence states [
In 2003, the Tamilnadu AIDS Initiative (TAI) was initiated under Avahan, through the NGO Voluntary Health Services (VHS), to scale up HIV prevention services in selected districts and saturate coverage among FSWs and MSM/TGs in Tamilnadu, a high HIV prevalence state in southern India [
Effective HIV prevention requires strategies that reduce the HIV vulnerability of high-risk groups [
The program was community-led, with the community taking the lead in planning, designing, implementing and monitoring program activities [
Peer-led outreach programs are based on the principle that peers can strongly influence an individual’s behavior [
The program aimed to increase the accessibility of STI services, provide quality care and early STI diagnosis and treatment to reduce infection among FSWs. As community members were hesitant to access STI care from government clinics due to stigma and discrimination, project-run clinics, including full-time clinics and satellite clinics, were set up in places that community members could easily access. Drop-in centers (DIC) were established in each clinic to provide a safe space for the community as well as counselling and condom supplies. By 2006, 41 program-owned STI clinics, five extended clinics and 12 referral clinics were operating in the state. Clinics regularly screened FSWs for STI, provided syndromic case management and referrals to government hospitals where necessary. FSWs’ partners and children were also provided treatment for general ailments. Clinic doctors and staff were sensitized to the needs of key populations and to provide care with empathy, and in each clinic, a committee comprising three community members was set up to provide information on available services and to address community fears regarding internal examinations and drawing of blood for testing. Community members assisted in daily medical and administrative activities at project clinics and DICs. Peer educators were trained and mentored by the clinic nurse, and served as clinic assistants when required. A community liaison officer was appointed at each clinic to ensure clients returned for follow-up visits. At government-run clinics, separate “safe” spaces for communities called “health hubs” were set up. Committee members who staffed the health hubs supported their peers to access clinic services; at the same time, videos and IPC materials were screened/displayed at the health hubs to build acceptance of the community among health staff. Condoms were also distributed at the health hubs.
To address violence, which was widespread among FSWs, a community-led crisis management wing was set up, staffed by informed and empowered key populations, popularly called Araichimani (meaning “Bell of Distress”) [
To build a supportive environment, the program advocated with multiple stakeholders who wield power, such as brothel owners, madams, pimps, brokers, lodge owners, auto drivers and FSWs’ regular sex partners, to create awareness of HIV prevention and the importance of condom use. Posters were displayed at police stations on sex worker-related issues, and videos were developed on safe sex and the need to protect sex workers from violence/abuse by clients and anti- social elements. Meetings were organized with district-level stakeholders such as the police, government officials and doctors from program clinics to advocate on issues affecting key populations, build rapport and seek support. In addition, a lawyers’ forum was established, and in each program district, two lawyers provided advice on key populations’ rights to help them protect themselves from violations.
Data for this study were drawn from two rounds (2006 and 2009) of Behavior Surveillance Surveys (BSS), a cross-sectional study conducted among FSWs in six districts of Tamilnadu, India to monitor key components of the HIV prevention program. Inclusion criteria for participation in the survey were any women aged 18 years or older, who had engaged in sex work, either full-time or part- time, in the three months prior to the survey. Sample size was calculated to detect a 15% point increase in consistent condom use with clients from a baseline value of 50% at the district level with 80% power and alpha error of 5%. Overall, a sample of 2010 and 2500 FSWs in 2006 and 2009 respectively, completed the interview.
A multi-staged cluster sampling procedure was used for selection of participants in both rounds. The conventional cluster sampling approach was used for selecting FSWs based in non-public places (brothels, hotels, lodges, homes) and time-location cluster sampling method was used for selecting FSWs soliciting in public places (streets, market areas, highways and cinema halls). A list of hotspots (places where FSWs congregate to solicit clients) was developed through a rapid mapping exercise conducted using key informant interviews with community members and key local stakeholders such as the police and social workers. At each hotspot data were gathered on the presence of FSWs at different times of the day on different days of the week. This information was used to develop the list of primary sampling units for both conventional and time-location cluster sampling. Data collected during the mapping exercise were consolidated and finalized after discussion with the NGOs/community-based organizations (CBOs).
Hotspots located in areas covered by an NGO/CBO outreach worker for program implementation were grouped to form a stratum of 200 - 250 FSWs. Each stratum was further divided into two sampling frames of PSUs based on the typology of sex work (non-public place, public place). In each stratum, FSWs were recruited through a two-stage sampling procedure. In the first stage, a fixed number of PSUs were selected within each stratum using the proportion to population size procedure. The number of interviews to be conducted in each PSU was allocated proportionally. In the second stage, respondents were selected within each selected hotspot.
Face-to-face interviews were conducted by trained field investigators in the local language, Tamil, using a structured questionnaire that included questions on socio-demographic, sexual behavior, self-reported STI symptoms, treatment seeking behavior, and program exposure. Interviews were conducted in locations previously hired for data collection purposes.
Prior to administering the interview, written consent was obtained from all the participants after they were informed in detail about the survey and all their questions answered. No names or identifying information were collected.
The outcome measures used in this study were: 1) consistent condom use with occasional clients, defined as condom use at every sexual encounter with occasional clients in the past year; 2) consistent condom use with regular clients, defined as condom use at every sexual encounter with regular clients in the past year; and 3) self-reported STI symptoms―participants were asked if they had experienced any of the following STI symptoms in the past 12 months: vaginal discharge, lower abdominal pain without diarrhea or during menstrual cycle, and genital ulcer or sores.
Exposure to the intervention was the key independent variable considered in the study, derived through a series of questions that were asked regarding contact by the program, membership in a CBO and service utilization. Those who were contacted by a peer educator or outreach worker at least three times in the past 6 months, had been taken by a peer educator to a program clinic for a health check-up in the past 6 months, had seen a demonstration of correct condom use, had visited a program supported clinic at least 2 - 3 times in the past 6 months, had attended a meeting or discussion at the program office in the past 6 months or were a registered CBO member were defined as exposed to the intervention.
The socio-demographic characteristics considered in this study included age (<30, 30 - 34, 35+ years), education status (illiterate, primary education, secondary education and above), current marital status (yes/no), engagement in occupations other than sex work (yes/no) and alcohol consumption in the past month (yes/no). The sex work characteristics considered in the study included duration in sex work (<4 years, 4 - 7 years, 8+ years) and primary place where clients are solicited (street, home, brothel-based). Both socio-demographic and sex work characteristics were used as covariates in the multivariate analyses.
Descriptive statistics were used to describe the population. Chi-square test was used to assess the difference between FSWs exposed to intervention and those who were not exposed in terms of their socio-demographic and sex work characteristics. A series of multivariate logistic regression models were constructed to examine the association between exposure to the intervention and change over time with condom use behavior and self-reported STI. All the analyses were performed using STATA 11.1.
Of the total sample, 48% in 2006 and 90% in 2009 reported exposure to intervention (not presented in tabular form). No significant difference was observed among the groups exposed and not exposed to the intervention in terms of age, education, and marital status in 2006. A higher proportion of FSWs exposed than those not exposed to the intervention reported engaging in occupations other than sex work and practicing sex work for a longer duration (4+ years) in 2006. Further, a significantly lower proportion of FSWs exposed to intervention reported alcohol consumption in the past month. In 2009 significant differences were observed between FSWs exposed and not exposed to the intervention in terms of education, marital status, engagement in occupations other than sex work, duration in sex work and past month alcohol consumption (
As seen in
Characteristics | 2006 N = 2010 | 2009 N = 2500 | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Exposure to intervention | Exposure to intervention | ||||||
No % (n) | Yes % (n) | P-value | No % (n) | Yes % (n) | P-value | ||
Age (years) | 0.188 | 0.307 | |||||
<30 | 30.5 (322) | 26.9 (257) | 25.7 (66) | 23.6 (529) | |||
30 - 34 | 30.6 (323) | 33.1 (316) | 28.4 (73) | 33.1 (743) | |||
35+ | 38.9 (411) | 39.9 (381) | 45.9 (118) | 43.3 (971) | |||
Education status | 0.109 | <0.001 | |||||
Illiterate | 30.1 (318) | 26.5 (253) | 24.9 (64) | 17.2 (385) | |||
Primary education | 25.3 (267) | 24.5 (234) | 13.6 (35) | 21.9 (492) | |||
Secondary education + | 44.6 (471) | 49.0 (467) | 61.5 (158) | 60.9 (1366) | |||
Currently married | 61.7 (651) | 65.3 (623) | 0.089 | 50.6 (130) | 59.3 (1330) | 0.007 | |
Engaged in occupations other than sex work | 53.9 (569) | 58.3 (556) | 0.047 | 74.7 (192) | 55.7 (1249) | <0.001 | |
Duration in sex work (years) | <0.001 | 0.014 | |||||
<4 | 36.8 (389) | 27.0 (258) | 37.7 (97) | 40.4 (906) | |||
4 - 7 | 40.4 (427) | 49.6 (473) | 42.0 (108) | 46.1 (1034) | |||
8+ | 22.7 (240) | 23.4 (223) | 20.2 (52) | 13.5 (303) | |||
Typology of sex work | 0.504 | ||||||
Street-based | 100.0 | 100.0 | - | 91.1 (234) | 90.2 (2024) | ||
Home-based | 7.0 (18) | 6.5 (146) | |||||
Brothel-based | 2.0 (5) | 3.3 (73) | |||||
Consumed alcohol past month | 85.1 (899) | 77.2 (736) | <0.001 | 46.7 (120) | 24.0 (538) | <0.001 |
*P-value based on Chi-square test of independence for categorical variables.
2006 | 2009 | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Outcome measures | Exposure to intervention | Exposure to intervention | Time x exposure adjusted OR (95% CI) | P-value | ||
No | Yes | No | Yes | |||
Condom use with occasional clients―% (N) | 62.9 (1051) | 76.4 (948) | 44.4 (252) | 86.0 (2210) | ||
Condom use with occasional clients―AOR (95% CI) | Ref | 1.90 (1.56, 2.33) | Ref | 6.80 (5.0, 9.24) | 3.53 (2.47, 5.05) | <0.001 |
Condom use with regular clients―% (N) | 63.4 (981) | 77.7 (945) | 39.7 (242) | 88.8 (2005) | ||
Condom use with regular clients―AOR (95% CI) | Ref | 1.99 (1.62, 2.44) | Ref | 9.51 (6.97, 13.0) | 4.95 (3.43, 7.16) | <0.001 |
Self-reported STI symptoms―% (N) | 17.3 (1056) | 17.3 (954) | 22.2 (257) | 8.6 (2243) | ||
Self-reported STI symptoms―AOR (95% CI) | Ref | 1.0 (0.79, 1.27) | Ref | 0.42 (0.29, 0.60) | 0.39 (0.26, 0.59) | <0.001 |
OR: odds ratio; CI: confidence interval.
follow-up. Further, the increase in consistent condom use over time with occasional clients (adjusted OR = 3.53, 95% CI: 2.47 - 5.05) and regular clients (adjusted OR = 4.97, 95% CI: 3.43 - 7.16) was higher among FSWs who were exposed to the intervention as compared to those who reported no exposure. Additionally, a significant decline was observed in self-reported STI overtime, among FSWs who reported exposure to intervention compared to their counterparts (adjusted OR = 0.39, 95% CI: 0.26 - 0.59).
This study presents findings on the effect of an up scaled HIV prevention program for FSWs in the state of Tamilnadu, India. The results indicate a strong association between exposure to the intervention and a reduction in HIV risk with regard to condom use and self-reported STI. Our findings show that FSWs exposed to the intervention were significantly more likely to report consistent condom use with both regular and occasional clients. Further, a significant decline in self-reported STI was observed among FSWs reporting program exposure. These findings are in line with results from assessments of HIV prevention programs with FSWs in other high HIV prevalence states of India, indicating improvements in condom use with commercial partners and a decline in STI [
As highlighted in this study, there was a dramatic increase in program exposure between 2006 and 2009. Possible reasons for increased exposure could be the rapid scale-up of the Avahan program in Tamilnadu and the involvement of the community in all aspects of program implementation. While initially experts from program implementing NGOs conducted program monitoring, under Avahan, the approach was to engage community members in monitoring activities with supportive supervision from NGO staff. As reported in other assessments of Avahan [
The increase in consistent condom use may be the result of several factors. Along with peer educators motivating FSWs to adopt safer sex behaviors through regular risk reduction counselling, condom use demonstrations and building FSWs’ negotiation skills, the program was also able to meet the minimum requirements for condoms through the distribution of condoms by peer educators, as well as social marketing to cover the estimated number of commercial sex acts. Improving access to condoms when needed may have contributed to the reported improvement in condom use with commercial partners over the stu1dy period, as has been observed in other states which adopted a similar intervention approach [
Due to the lack of information on clinically-diagnosed STIs, self-reported STIs were taken as a proxy indicator. Similar to findings from assessments of interventions with FSWs in other high prevalence states of India, a significant decline in self-reported STI symptoms was observed in the current study [
The significant reduction in self-reported STI and high exposure to the intervention also indicate that the HIV prevention program is reaching FSWs, and safer behaviors are being adopted, as observed in the current study where a higher proportion of FSWs exposed to the intervention as compared those with no exposure reported using condoms.
The need to build a supportive environment to address the distal factors of HIV vulnerability, including stigma and violence for effective HIV prevention is well documented [
While this study highlights a strong association between exposure to the TAI- VHS HIV prevention intervention and safer sex behaviors and lower self-re- ported STI, the study results should be interpreted in light of certain limitations. First, the 2006 survey was conducted when the HIV prevention program was already underway, and hence it was not a true baseline. Second, the dependent variables considered in this paper were based on self-reported responses, which may be biased due to socially desirable responses from participants. However, the use of experienced researchers may have reduced this bias to some extent. Finally, the study findings cannot be generalized to all FSWs across India as sex work in India is characterized by inter- and intra-regional differences. However these limitations do not compromise the internal validity of the data. Our study findings are consistent with results from other assessments indicating an improvement in condom use behavior with commercial clients and reduction in STI following upscaled HIV prevention programs [
In short, our study shows that the HIV prevention program in Tamilnadu resulted in improvements in consistent condom use with regular and occasional clients, and a decrease in self-reported STI among FSWs exposed to intervention. These findings suggest that HIV prevention programs must aim to saturate coverage among key populations to sustain the gains achieved in reducing HIV risk.
This paper was written as part of the Knowledge Network project of the Population Council, which is a grantee of the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation trough Avahan, its India AIDS initiative. The views expressed herein are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and Avahan and the organizations that the authors are affiliated with.
JDW and AV led conceptualization, provided critical inputs and revised the manuscript. KP wrote the manuscript. NS assisted in conceptualization of analytic approach and interpretation of study findings. SR conducted the analyses, and assisted in writing the manuscript. DG revised the paper and provided critical inputs. All authors have read and approved the final manuscript.
Williams, J.D., Vijayaraman, A., Krishnaswamy, P., Saggurti, N., Ramesh, S. and Ganju, D. (2017) Impact of an HIV Prevention Intervention on HIV Risk Behavior and Sexually Transmitted Infection among Female Sex Workers in Tamil Nadu, India. World Journal of AIDS, 7, 166-178. https://doi.org/10.4236/wja.2017.73014