Background: Based on the experience of hospital nurses, the aim of this study is to explore the phenomenon of how work-engaged nurses stay healthy in relationally demanding jobs involving very sick and/or dying patients. Method: In-depth interviews were conducted with ten work-engaged nurses employed at the main hospital in one region in Norway. The interviews were interpreted using the Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis method (IPA). Results: The results indicate the importance of using the personal resources: authenticity and a sense of humour for staying healthy. The nurses’ authenticity, in the sense of having a strong sense of ownership towards their personal life experiences, and a sense of having a meaningful life in line with their own values and interests, was an important element when they considered their own health to be good in spite of repetitive strain injuries and perceived stress. These personal resources seem to be positively related to their well-being and work engagement, which serves as an argument for including them among other personal resources, often conceptualized in terms of Psychological Capital (PsyCap). The results also showed that the nurses worked actively and intentionally with conditions that could contribute to safeguarding their own health. Conclusion: The results indicated the importance of stimulating the nurses’ area of knowledge about caring for themselves in order to enable them to maintain good physical and mental health. A focus on self-care should be part of the agenda as early as during nursing education.
This paper focuses on the perceived experience of work-engaged nurses who work in relationally demanding jobs when it comes to staying healthy while caring for very ill and/or dying patients in the hospital. Nurses with an experience of life-and-death issues have traditionally been associated with a risk of stress, strain injuries and burnouts due to their exposure to frequent deaths and family grieving [
Work engagement is in line with the perspective of “positive psychology”, which concerns itself with the positive aspects of employee health and resources [
In positive psychology, health is often related to psychological health and well-being rather than psychologi- cal suffering. Subjective well-being (SWB) is defined as a person’s affective and cognitive evaluation of one’s life, and the evaluation includes emotional reactions to events and cognitive judgment of fulfilment [
Quantitative studies have shown that work engagement is positively associated with employee health [
Staying healthy with regard to engagement has to do with both personal resources and job resources [
The JD-R model has been criticized for neglecting the role of employees’ personal resources. As the early versions of the JD-R model consider only characteristics of the work environment, there are still several un- resolved issues regarding the role and incorporation of personal resources in the JD-R model. Personal resources are defined as those aspects of the self that are generally associated with resilience. This refers to the ability to impact and control one’s environment successfully [
In general, relatively few studies have examined the role of personal resources, but some studies have shown that personal resources directly impact work engagement and well-being. A study among teachers [
To our knowledge, studies concerning experiences of work-engaged nurses in staying healthy are still limited, but some studies have shown that personal resources such as resilience [
Basing itself on the self-perceived health status of hospital nurses, the aim of this study is to explore the expe- rience of staying healthy in relationally demanding jobs while caring for very ill and/or dying patients. The focus of this study will be on personal resources.
Data were collected through in-depth interviews [
The approach used in IPA is strongly influenced by phenomenology [
The data was collected at the main hospital in one region in Norway. First, a strategic selection of hospital de- partments was made [
This study is based on the interviews with ten nurses who had strong self-reported work engagement. The nurses’ work involved caring for patients who were seriously ill and/or dying. They were the primary contact nurses for a certain number of patients and their immediate families. The nurses’ age ranged from 31 to 51 years. The nurses’ working experience in their present department varied from 4 to 16 years. Eight participants worked full-time, whereas two were employed part-time. Nine of the respondents had participated in further training in the respective areas of their departments. The informants were either married or lived with a partner and had children and/or teenagers living at home.
The data was collected by the first author through semi-structured in-depth one-to-one interviews with open- ended questions. Each interview lasted for 1.5 to 2 hours. This form of interviewing allows for dialogue and enables the researcher to further explore important points that arise [
The analysis was carried out according to Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) [
The analysis was carried out in several steps, and examples of the analysis in the first theme “A positive sense of ownership towards personal life experience” are shown in
1) The first author began by examining the transcript of one interview in detail before moving on to the other interviews. Each interview was then read through several times to gain a first understanding. Preliminary notes were prepared on the basis of preliminary theme, associations or questions.
2) The connection between the meaning units was examined, and some of the meaning units were clustered together. Key phrases capturing the essence of the informant’s statements, such as “trying to develop my nursing skills”, were used to identify concurrent topics, such as “developing one’s potential”.
3) Providing structure to the analysis to increase the understanding of the processes and structures emerging from the research material.
4) Further refining the themes by creating a summary to help divide the themes into main themes and sub- themes. Theories, such as the JD-R model and PsyCap, were applied during steps three and four to increase the understanding of the processes and structures that emerged from the research material. This process is in line with IPA. Research is viewed as a dynamic process where the analysis represents an on-going process of inter- pretation by the researcher. The method is connected to a two-stage interpretation process or a double herme- neutic process [
The results are evident in tree main themes and six sub-themes (in brackets) (see
The first author discussed the study, its method and findings, with colleagues from other professions in seminars and lectures. The purpose of this discussion was to obtain as much insight as possible.
This study was approved by the Norwegian Social Science Data Service (NSD) and the Regional Committee for
Meaning unit | Connecting the meaning unit into themes | Sub-themes | Main themes |
---|---|---|---|
“You know, I am kind of worn down here and there, but you know, it’s a pretty natural thing considering the job I have.” “My job gives me a strong feeling of having a meaningful life.” “Considering my age, my health is pretty good.” | Health is related to the feeling of having a meaningful life, life experiences and life stages. | Perceived health is a result of having lived one’s life in the way one wants | Having a positive sense of ownership towards one’s own life experiences |
“I am both caring and conscientious. It is important to be these things when choosing the nursing profession.” “I have always wanted to have more children, which I have indeed gotten.” | Making choices in life is related to personal values and interests | Being true to one’s own values and personal interests | |
“I try to stay updated in my field as far as possible, and attend seminars when I feel that I should.” “I want to get things done and get them resolved, so I check with the others when I cannot find the answer myself.” | Utilizing available opportunities in order to develop themselves in their professional practice | Developing one’s potential |
Having a positive sense of ownership towards one’s own life experiences | Being sensitive to their own needs in order to take care of their own health | Having a sense of humour |
---|---|---|
Perceived health is a result of having lived one’s live in the way one wants | Setting limits | |
Being true to one’s own values and personal interests | Being physically active | |
Developing one’s potential | Having mutual social relations in general |
Medical and Health Research Ethics (REK) of mid-Norway. Participants were informed that participation was voluntary and that their confidentiality would be respected.
Staying healthy involved having a positive sense of ownership towards one’s own life experiences, and included: Perceived health is a result of having lived one’s life in the way one wants, being true to one’s own values and personal interests, and developing one’s potential.
Paradoxically, all the nurses considered their own health to be good, in spite of various health ailments such as high blood pressure, stress and insomnia: “My health is impeccable. Fortunately, it is impeccable”.
The nurses considered their health to be a result of the life they lived and had chosen to live. They respected themselves as authorities of their own lives and accepted the consequences of their own choices. One nurse said, “I have wanted to be a nurse for as long as I can remember, but it is a stressful profession which takes its toll on one’s health. However, I knew that from the beginning.” They expressed how a lengthy professional practice in such a demanding job had contributed to strains in the skeleton and muscles. Repeated heavy lifting and work- ing in difficult positions in cramped patients’ rooms had caused both inflammation and minor damages to the neck, shoulders and back area. Five of the respondents suffered from various health ailments related to strain injuries. One nurse said, “You know, I am kind of worn down here and there, but you know, it’s a pretty natural thing considering the job I have.”
The strain injuries they had incurred affected their health, and all five nurses received treatment at regular in- tervals in order to repair and prevent physical strain and injuries. “I am seeing a manual therapist every fortnight that takes care of the chronic shoulder inflammation” and “I go to a physical therapist once a week for a dose of maintenance in relation to a shoulder inflammation.” The nurses communicated that the treatment had good re- sults, which meant that they did not have to be absent from work. In addition to work related strain injuries, they also suffered from various ailments that affected their daily lives. One nurse said, “My blood pressure is a little high, and so is my cholesterol and so on, and then I got a minor back injury at work a few years back, but all in all I’m in good health.”
Making choices according to their own personal interests also made it natural for them to accept the cones- quences of the choices they had made. The other five informants had preschool children, and they found it to be quite natural for this stage of their lives to be hectic. One nurse said, “You know, I think of it like this: NOW I’m in a phase where I have kids―we have made the choice to have kids ourselves, and so we should accept the consequences thereof. No use complaining―you can’t change it anyway. I have chosen to work full-time, so that’s a choice I have made”.
All of them suffered from bouts of insomnia, as well as stress during hectic periods of their working day, but that was explained as being a natural part of living life with small children. They made statements as follows:
“I am mostly healthy; I’ve been lucky there. I have some troubles sleeping occasionally, but I guess that’s a pretty normal part of having small kids.” and “It’s rather hectic at times, and I often feel stressed, but I guess that’s part of the job. My health is excellent, and I am rarely ill”. They also expressed that they were frequently busy, but this did not bother them in their daily lives. All of the nurses expressed that they were usually physi- cally tired after work, but they found it to be quite natural when considering the hectic life at the different units.
The nurses made choices in line with their own values and interests, and they had a positive view of their own experiences. From an early age, they had wanted to become nurses and finished the nursing education while they were relatively young. They were positive towards providing care for others, and they had positive associations towards value-laden terms that are related to providing care, such as being conscientious, scrupulous and as- suming responsibility. This is borne out as,
“I am very conscientious; I am not able to let other people be negatively affected. And I am very scrupulous. Well, I may seem to toot my own horn quite a bit here, but I have actually received very positive feedback on these things.”
The nurses found an almost existential purpose with their jobs, and said it was inherently meaningful to be able to contribute to helping people who were in deep distress, and they channelled their own values through their work performance. One nurse said, “I have a unique job that I am very happy with. To me, it is meaningful to be able to contribute to helping patients in the situation they are in. It gives me a strong sense of living a meaningful life.”
The informants expressed that their job had affected them as persons, making them feel less peremptory, more liberal, and less judgmental. They said, “When you work with the things I’m working with here―and when they no longer affect you―the day I am no longer being affected by my job, that’s when I think I’ll stop working there, really.” The job has also influenced the personal values of some of them in the sense of making them less materialistic: “I also find that much of the stuff that I see other people using their time and energy on, such as interior decoration, we spend no time on that in our home. It is pretty irrelevant if the curtains are red or blue.” They also expressed that experiences from work had contributed to making them more present in the moment. Their experiences had taught them that there is a thin line between life and death, and that it was important to be present in the moment instead of living in the future. One nurse said, “I’m not one of those who worries about the future. What’s the point of that?”
The results also indicated that they were satisfied with their own personal lives and made conscious choices based on their own interests. “I can’t be bothered to go around being annoyed by trifles―I don’t want to waste my energy on the fact that it is raining. I have always wanted my own family, and now I have one. What more could I want? I like it just the way it is.” Another nurse stated, “I am pleased with the life I am living.”
The final dimension linked to having a positive sense of ownership towards their own life experiences was con- nected to developing one’s own potential. The nurses expressed having a positive relationship towards their own personal development and that they were in a steady process of personal and professional development. Nine of the ten nurses had undergone further training in their field of expertise, and they attended courses that were relevant to their field. One nurse said, “I try to stay updated in my field as far as possible, and attend seminars when I feel that I should.” They accepted themselves just the way they were, and were realistic when it came to their own abilities. One nurse said, “I must accept that I do not know EVERYTHING. I am good at some things, less good at other things.” They seemed to be very solution-oriented, and they tried to resolve unsolved problems as soon as possible so they would not wear them down. One nurse said, “I want to get things done and get them resolved, so I check with the others when I cannot find the answer myself.”
To develop their own potential, the nurses processed and reflected on difficult experiences either by reflecting on them on their own, or seeking assistance when they needed help to move on. They learned from the ways in which they dealt with issues and accepted their own inadequacy in certain situations. One nurse said, “It is im- portant to accept that I could not have done anything differently then and there.”
All the nurses expressed how they had mostly been regarded as positive persons. They tried to make the best of the situation they were in by focussing on the opportunities rather than the deficiencies. One nurse said, “It is important to concentrate on the things you can do something about. Get to grips with it and make the best out of it.” Another nurse said, “I get many questions about how it is possible to work in a place like this. To me, it’s not so much about death. It’s rather about making life as good as possible for those who are here.” They also focused on the healthy part of the patient, rather than the part suffering from illness: “We are very concerned with highlighting the healthy parts of the human being.” But at the same time, they are realistic: “It is the healthy part we use our time and energy on at work, but it has to be a realistic optimism taking the person’s diagnosis into account.” In focussing on the healthy aspects of the patients, the nurses contributed to developing positive relations with the patients.
Staying healthy means being sensitive to their own needs, including setting limits, being physically active, and having mutual social relations in general.
The respondents perceived themselves as having a good knowledge of their own physical and mental health, and they were sensitive toward their own needs in almost all situations. One dimension of being sensitive toward their own needs was setting limits. Their ability in setting limits was expressed as a sense of knowing their own personal limits. They accepted their own limitations, and they sought help when they needed it. The nurses’ long professional experience was a factor that reduced having them bring work-related problems home, and vice versa, thinking about domestic issues when they were at work. They felt a strong sense of work engagement, which they regarded as a prerequisite to be able to deal with their job. However, their work engagement was mostly limited to the job arena.
They also believed that it was important to be highly mentally balanced in order to do a good job, and they stayed at home when they experienced great personal stress. One nurse said, “I believe it is impossible to com- bine such a tough job with personal stress. When I lost my sister five years ago, I was absent for several weeks after the funeral in order to recover.” They also chose to stay at home when they were ill or in poor shape, and they believed the department could manage well without them. One nurse said, “If I had a fever or a headache, I would stay a day or two in bed and know that the world moves on just fine.” Moreover, the informants enjoyed spending time on their own, without having to do anything in particular. As one of the mothers with young chil- dren said, “… and just having some time to oneself after the children are in bed, and not doing anything, it’s de- lightful.” Another said, “When I need it, I like to lie on the couch with a good book, watch TV or reflect on life in general.”
Another dimension of being sensitive to their own needs was related to physical activity. The nurses felt that physical activity was energising, and they were eager to try to keep in shape. Most of the nurses were physically active in some form or another, and they felt that they had good physical health. They were often physically tired after work and felt that a workout restored their energy. Six of them exercised regularly, up to several times a week either at the gym or by jogging, walking or cycling outside. Some of the nurses were physically active in several ways. One nurse said, “I do weight training, go cross-country skiing, run, walk in the woods, cycle and walk in the mountains.” The other four respondents had children under school age or in primary school, and they adapted their activities to their children’s needs. They prioritised the follow-up of the children’s activities in everyday life, and their afternoons were often busy and involved driving the children to different activities, but they were often physically active together with the family on weekends. One nurse said, “I walk and swim to- gether with the children or we go for walks together. On weekends we often go walking in the woods. It’s a great way to relax.”
The last dimension relating to being sensitive toward their own needs concerned social relations in general. The nurses valued social interaction highly, and they believed there was a curative effect in being in the company of others. They maintained relationships with family and friends in an outreaching and active manner by, among other things, inviting them home from time to time. One nurse said, “I am very social, I enjoy good company, and I often invite others to dinner.” However, they also expressed that the relationships were reciprocal, that they had both a private network as well as a work network with colleagues who were a great support for them whenever they needed it, and that their spouses often held a unique position in this context.
All the nurses thought it was invaluable to have a sense of humour in order to maintain good health. They worked with very serious problems in heart-rending human conditions, and they often had to deal with patients and their families who were in despair. They found it necessary to have a sense of humour to distance them- selves from exceedingly difficult situations. One nurse said, “It is important to have a counterpoint to the seri- ousness of it all―we must get some humour into the department.” Another nurse said, “We work with patients who have a really tough time, and their relatives, who are in a state of crisis when they lose their loved ones. It’s a tough job, and it is absolutely necessary to have a sense of humour around here.” Meeting colleagues in the staff room was often used as a relief station when the pressure became too high in the departments.
Four respondents claimed that they did not have a good sense of humour when they began working in the de- partments, but they had learned from their colleagues and eventually became integrated into the department’s internal humour. The various departments had developed a certain kind of gallows humour, which was internal and unique to the department. One nurse said, “The jokes, the irony and the gallows humour that we have in the staff room should not be heard outside the door, one has to be aware of the surroundings in order to cope and understand that it is actually all right and not meant in a negative manner. We have a lot of humour in the de- partments.” The nurses also used humour in conversations with the individual patients, but they stressed that they were careful in their speech, and wanted to get to know the patients before they used this form for commu- nication. One nurse said, “It is possible to be witty about it, even though everyone knows that at the end of the day it is a tragic case.” The nurses believed that a good laugh relieved the physical and psychological pressure that could occur in difficult situations, and it made them relax and focus on the positive aspects of the situation.
Interestingly, the summary of the results shows that the nurses considered their health to be good in spite of having various ailments in the form of strain injuries, stress, insomnia and high blood pressure. How is it possi- ble to feel that one are in good health when one is suffering from such ailments? The results indicate that the nurses had a positive sense of ownership towards their own life experiences, and they perceived their health status to be a natural consequence of the life they were living and had lived. They lived a life that was in line with their values and interests, and their sense of having a meaningful life had a significant effect on their ability to stay healthy. They had a pragmatic approach towards their own health, regarding health as a relative phe- nomenon that had to be considered in relation to what they found reasonable to expect in terms of life stages and life experiences. They took it for granted that life experiences left their marks on them, and they would suffer a little from ailments and strain after spending years in such a strenuous job.
The nurses viewed life as something that could be affected, and they considered themselves to be fully able to influence their own health in a favourable manner. They were sensitive toward their own needs, and the results show that the nurses’ experiences imply that it was important to address both their physical and mental health. They were actively coping with regard to choosing activities that were right for them and gave them energy.
All the nurses also emphasized the importance of having a sense of humour related to the job in order to maintain good health.
The aim of this study was to explore work-engaged nurses experiences of staying healthy in relationally demanding jobs involving caring for very ill and/or dying patients. The focal point of this study has been per- sonal resources. Findings in the present study give new insights into the nurses’ use of personal resources and also provide new insights in the nurses’ self-perceived health. First, the findings pertaining to the authenticity of personal resources and sense of humour will be discussed. These are two new personal resources that have to do with work engagement and staying healthy that have, as far as we know, not been identified in previous studies, and hence, they will be given special attention in the discussion. The findings will then be discussed in terms of extending the scope of PsyCap, as well as possible implementation in the JD-R model.
The results showed that the nurses were pleased with their own situation, and they had a strong sense of own- ership towards their own life experiences. Their feeling of leaving a meaningful life, which was in line with their values and interests, was a significant factor when they assessed their own health. The nurses made choices in line with their own values, accepting that the consequences of the choices they made came naturally to them. Educating themselves to be nurses was one of the important value choices they had made, and they channelled their abilities through their professional practice. They were also satisfied with their own personal lives and said they had each gotten the family they had wanted.
The results may indicate that the nurses had a great degree of authenticity in their personal resources, which is termed in positive psychology as a higher-order strength or capacity [
In order to enhance their authenticity, people have to employ self-development and self-regulation [
Authenticity also includes being true to one’s own needs and wants [
The nurses prioritised their own interests, and they chose to stay at home when they were ill or in poor shape, a choice that helped them protect their physical health against further stress. Furthermore, they were aware of processing the emotional stress that occurred at, e.g., a death in the immediate family, and they chose to be ab- sent from work in such instances. In an exposed occupation that requires both emotional and physical strength, it may be of crucial importance for the safeguarding of one’s health that the nurses are well when they are at work; otherwise, the wear and tear will, in time, be too great. The informants were also concerned with trying to keep fit, and they found that physical activity restored their energy after work and contributed to maintaining good health and preventing repetitive strain injuries. This result is in line with studies showing that physical exercise and physical resources have positive health effects [
The result is in line with Antonovsky’s theory SOC [
The analysis also revealed another personal resource among the nurses: having a sense of humour. The nurses thought it was invaluable to have a sense of humour in order to maintain good mental health at work. When be- ing involved with very sick and/or dying patients, some situations require for one to be able to distance oneself from the situation. The nurses felt that a good laugh relieved the physical and psychological pressure that could build up in difficult situations and gave them the energy to focus on the positive aspects of the situation. This is in accordance with studies that show that humour has been associated with a positive coping style and is consid- ered one of the positive defence mechanisms people need in order to cope with the stresses of everyday life [
The above-mentioned results indicate that both authenticity and a sense of humour are personal resources that are of great importance for the nurses when it comes to staying healthy; however, these personal resources are still not included in PsyCap. As mentioned earlier, personal resources are defined as aspects of the self that are generally associated with resilience [
Paradoxically, the results showed that the nurses perceived themselves as being in good health, in spite of a number of ailments stemming from repeated strain or stress.
The results are in line with SWB, which is defined as a person’s affective and cognitive evaluation of one’s own life, as well as the fact that the evaluations include emotional reactions to events and cognitive judgment of fulfilment [
The JD-R model has been criticized for neglecting the role of employees’ personal resources, and most of the studies among nurses have focused on job resources that predicted work engagement. For example, a supportive practice environment [
This study has some limitations. The interviews were retrospective, and one cannot say whether the nurses’ au- thenticity and sense of humour were an outcome of a long professional career, or whether they had these per- sonal resources when they started working. Therefore, there is a need for longitudinal studies that can address the development of authenticity and sense of humour over time. The survey was conducted in only three de- partments in a medium-sized hospital, and it is therefore difficult to generalise the results to apply to workplaces other than departments at other hospitals that involve relationally demanding work. However, the study identi- fies personal resources and a way of safeguarding one’s health that could potentially be linked to experiences of staying healthy over time in relationally demanding jobs.
The results indicate the importance of using the personal resources authenticity and a sense of humour in the experience of staying healthy in the nurses’ job, which involves very sick and/or dying patients. In hospital de- partments, a practice should be developed that encourages discussions and awareness of authenticity and a sense of humour, and the nurses’ individual abilities and knowledge of the importance of caring for their own health in order to maintain good physical and mental health should also be encouraged. The nearest head of department can undertake the role to initiate such discussions. Furthermore, the results suggest that it might be appropriate to integrate physical training during working hours. This can be done by allowing each employee a one-hour workout session per week, which can take place at the end of the working day. An organised training program at the hospital’s premises will encourage a sense of fellowship among the employees with regard to keeping in shape.
The personal resources authenticity and a sense of humour seem to be positively related to work engagement and well-being, serving as an argument to include them among other personal resources that has often been conceptualized as Psychological Capital (PsyCap). These results also serve as an argument for having personal resources included directly in the JD-R model on par with job resources, and also that job characteristics are significant with regard to how the employees utilize their personal resources.
These insights can possibly increase our knowledge on how nurses can improve their health. The current study revealed the need for studies focussing on personal resources in a variety of work settings.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
ABB drafted the introduction, carried out the design of the study, collected data, performed the analysis and drafted the methods and results. ABB and KV discussed the results of the data analysis, and ABB drafted the discussion section. KV served as an active discussion partner during the writing of the paper, and all the authors read and approved the final manuscript.
The authors would like to thank the nurses for their generous participation in this study, and Sør-Trøndelag University College in Norway for their financial support.