ABSTRACT

The aim of this work was to investigate the sliding wear coefficient k, using an experimental sliding wear study on the valve-seat insert contact. Commercial inlet valve and seat inserts were used as test specimens. The tests were performed at room temperature and at 200˚C, using test duration of 72,000 cycles and 18,000 cycles, respectively, and both in dry sliding conditions. A load of 5 N, an average speed of 22 mm/s and sliding distance of 2.2 mm were used for all tests. The sliding wear coefficients were calculated using experimental and analytical methods. The wear volume was higher in the tests at 200˚C both in valve and seat insert specimens. The principal wear mechanisms observed in valve specimen were oxidation and abrasion.

Keywords:

Sliding Wear Coefficient, Valve-Seat Insert, Wear Mechanisms

1. Introduction

Some studies have been carried out in order to understand the wear mechanisms that occur in the valve/seat insert interface, some of them concentrating mainly on the inlet valves [1] [2] [3] and others focusing on exhaust valves [4] [5] [6] [7] . Some works have investigated the effects of the combustion pressure [8] , the valve velocity [9] , the fuel type [10] , the cycle number [11] , the high temperature [12] [13] , the wear in valves of heavy duty engines [14] [15] and the effect of applying different hardening processes on the valve/seat insert interface [16] [17] [18] [19] . The operation temperature of inlet valves is between 180˚C and 360˚C [12] . For this specific work, a temperature of 200˚C was used in order to realize an experimental study of sliding wear at the valve/seat insert interface. Some experiments also were performed at room temperature in order to have a comparison parameter of the wear volume. The objective of this study was to investigate the sliding wear coefficient k, at room temperature and 200˚C, using experimental methods.

2. Experimental Details

2.1. Test Apparatus

The experimental tests were carried out in dry conditions using a PLINT TE77 High Frequency Friction/Wear Machine. The specimens were placed as shown in the simplified schematic diagram (Figure 1). The moving specimen (seat insert) is mechanically oscillated against the fixed specimen (valve). A force trans- ducer measures the friction force in both sliding directions.

2.2. Test Specimen

The specimens used are shown in Figure 2. They were obtained from a commercial valve and seat insert and prepared for placement in the PLINT machine. Their mechanical properties are shown in Table 1.

2.3. Test Procedure

Before all of the tests, the valve and seat insert specimens were cleaned of any residue oxide layer by washing in ethanol using an ultrasonic bath.

To know the effects of temperature in the k value, two types of tests were performed, one at room temperature (R.T.) and another at 200˚C. The valve and seat insert were placed in the rig as shown in the simplified schematic diagram (Figure 1). The load was selected in such a way that wear would be produced with a low number of cycles.

The tests performed at R.T. were run to 72,000 cycles and tests carried out at 200˚C were run to 18,000 cycles. This was predetermined with several preliminary tests, to know how many cycles were necessary to cause damage on the surfaces. Table 2 shows the operating conditions of the tests conducted.

3. Experimental Results and Discussion

3.1. Friction Behavior

The coefficient of friction (CoF) was measured in all tests. Friction coefficient increased during the early part of experiment, reaching an average value of 0.6 at the end of the test. Some debris was observed originating an increase in the friction coefficient.

3.2. Wear Volume

During a wear process, one of the major factors causing change in surface profiles is the material removal [20] . The determination of the wear volume in tribological testing is a key element [21] , as it is more discriminative than the wear scar width/diameter. In this work, the total lost material was calculated by adding the wear volume from the valve and seat insert.

The width, length and depth of the valve specimen wear scars, were obtained using profilometry (Figure 3) and optical microscopy. Figure 3(a) and Figure 3(b) show the profile of the wear scar for the tests at R.T. and at 200˚C, respectively. The average data of the depth, width and length of scars, as well as the

wear volume, are shown in Table 3. As can be seen tests at 200˚C produced higher wear volumes due to thermal softening causing the increased damage of the valve surface.

The length of the seat insert face (SIF) (Figure 4(a)) and seat insert upper face (SIUF) (Figure 4(b)) were measured before the tests (see Figure 5 for definitions). The wear volume in the seat insert specimens was calculated measuring the lost volume. It was verified in all tests, by optical microscopy, that the removed volume had a triangular section, represented schematically in Figure 5. The dimensions a, b and c, for each test specimen, were measured using optical microscopy, with which, the wear volumes were calculated (see Table 4).

3.3. Optical Microscopy

Figure 6 shows the images of the wear scars produced on the valve seating face

when they were tested at R.T. and at 200˚C. For R.T. tests (Figure 6(a)), the formation of scratching and gouging can be seen in the sliding direction. Debris at the edges of the wear scars was also observed. In the case of the tests at 200˚C (Figure 6(b)), the main observation was oxidative and abrasive wear evidenced by scratching and gouging in the sliding direction.

Observations of the seat insert face (Figure 7(a) and Figure 7(b)) show the formation of surface cracking and pitting due to the frictional sliding, as well as the presence of scratching. It can also be seen that the size of the worn surface for R.T. tests were smaller than the tests at 200˚C.

3.4. Sliding Wear Coefficient

Previous studies have been carried out to generate the sliding wear coefficient k [22] . In this work, k was determined using the Archard’s Equation [23] [24] (Equation (1)) and the results of the experimental tests.

(1)

where V is the wear volume (m³), k is the sliding wear coefficient, P is the normal force at interface (N), is the slip at interface per cycle (m), N is the number of cycles and h is the hardness (N/m²).

The final results for wear volumes and sliding wear coefficients are shown in Table 5. It can be seen in all tests that the k value was higher in the tests at 200˚C, resulting in an average value of 1.17E−03 and 5.01E−05 for tests at R.T. The previous values of k are compatible with the results reported by Rabinowicz [22] for fretting and abrasive wear in unlubricated conditions.

4. Conclusions

Valve specimens made of martensitic low alloy steel were put in frictional sliding tests against seat insert specimens made of cast tool steel.

1) The experimental procedure employed in this work, for the materials used, provides reliable results in wear volumes and sliding wear coefficients.

2) The wear volume was higher in the tests at 200˚C, both in valve specimens and seat insert specimens.

3) The principal wear mechanism observed in the wear scar surfaces of valve specimens was oxidation and abrasion.

4) The sliding contact produces several damages on the seat insert face, mainly characterized by cracking, pitting and scratching.

Acknowledgements

The work described in this paper was supported by CONACyT México and by the Tribology Group of The University of Sheffield, UK.

Cite this paper

Vera-Cardenas, E.E., Lewis, R. and Slatter, T. (2017) Sliding Wear Study on the Valve-Seat Insert Contact. Open Journal of Applied Sciences, 7, 42-49. https://doi.org/10.4236/ojapps.2017.72004

References